Master Index of Archived Threads


Which way to go, Part 2: The vests

A

22 votes

B

1 votes

Benjamin Grimm May 18 2009 09:03 AM

No "I don't care" votes. You have to choose, A or B. (Or else, don't vote.) <img src="http://turnkeyintell.com/SurveyBuilder/surveyResources/1577856/UniformNY_1.jpg" width="500" height="300">

Benjamin Grimm May 18 2009 09:04 AM

These are both horrendous, the worst of the possible choices. I voted for A, because it's less horrendous than B. The worst thing about both of these is, I think, the solid orange numeral on the right breast. Both the solidness and the position are awful.

TransMonk May 18 2009 09:10 AM

="Benjamin Grimm":2rvppji6] I voted for A, because it's less horrendous than B.[/quote:2rvppji6] Yup. Edgy DC May 18 2009 09:27 AM I think A would be fine-ish for a new Metly team. If Bingo wore them, or Brooklyn, I'd find it to be quite handsome. The problem is what it is not. It is not a Met uniform. And it doesn't belong on an old metly team. It would look like something less than a playful corruption and something more like an outright abomination, on a minor-league affiliate. Or if a fan wore the left one? Cool. The solid blue is wrong. The insignia, to me, should always be orange. I guess they put it in blue for contrast here, but orange has shown up OK on a white background on the Giants' uniforms, hasn't it? metirish May 18 2009 09:28 AM On buckets FB I said I would take A over any of them , again if I was offered one for free. holychicken May 18 2009 09:37 AM I look at one and decide to choose the other one. . .and then I look at the other and decide to choose the first. This is a tough one. I just flipped a coin. Fman99 May 18 2009 09:48 AM The actual Mets poll had a choice that said "I don't like either of these," or words to that effect. That was the one I picked in this case. A Boy Named Seo May 18 2009 09:56 AM ="Edgy DC":2592l7gl] The insignia, to me, should always be orange. I guess they put it in blue for contrast here, but orange has shown up OK on a white background on the Giants' uniforms, hasn't it?[/quote:2592l7gl] Yah, and I can make out the orange number just fine on the white one. I voted "A", but think they're both ungood. themetfairy May 18 2009 10:04 AM ="TransMonk":2x8ww5z8] ="Benjamin Grimm":2x8ww5z8] I voted for A, because it's less horrendous than B.[/quote:2x8ww5z8] Yup.[/quote:2x8ww5z8] Yupİ Yupİ LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 18 2009 10:43 AM ="Fman99":3ngqvyqp]The actual Mets poll had a choice that said "I don't like either of these," or words to that effect. That was the one I picked in this case.[/quote:3ngqvyqp] Ditto. Both of these would go nicely with Cross-Colour jeans and an 8-ball bubble coat in my mom's basement. John Cougar Lunchbucket May 18 2009 11:22 AM ="holychicken":2gdz4o8a]I look at one and decide to choose the other one. . .and then I look at the other and decide to choose the first. This is a tough one. I just flipped a coin.[/quote:2gdz4o8a] Same. I don't love them but don't think they suck that hard. I mean, they're gonna do an alternate, these are much better than the armpit ones. Which of these I can't choose. I have some good associations with the solid-blue BPs of the 80s so I like B; but the orange # -- sans shadow and heavy outlines -- are nice in style A. soupcan May 18 2009 12:43 PM ="TransMonk":3c5wns3r] ="Benjamin Grimm":3c5wns3r] I voted for A, because it's less horrendous than B.[/quote:3c5wns3r] Yup.[/quote:3c5wns3r] Me too. Ashie62 May 18 2009 02:28 PM I saw these at Abercrombie & Fitch marked down