Master Index of Archived Threads


All-Time National League East Team: The Second Baseman

Edgardo Alfonzo, NYM

2 votes

Wally Backman, NYM/PIT/PHI

0 votes

Dave Cash, PIT/PHI/MON

0 votes

Luis Castillo, FLA/NYM

0 votes

Delino DeShields, MON

1 votes

Denny Doyle, PHI

0 votes

Doug Flynn, NYM/MON

0 votes

Phil Garner, PIT

1 votes

Marcus Giles, ATL

0 votes

Tommy Herr, STL/PHI/NYM

0 votes

Ron Hunt, MON/STL

0 votes

Jeff Kent, NYM

0 votes

Mike Lansing, MON

0 votes

Mark Lemke, ATL

0 votes

Jose Lind, PIT

0 votes

Bill Mazeroski, PIT

0 votes

Felix Millan, NYM

0 votes

Mickey Morandini, PHI

0 votes

Johnny Ray, PIT

0 votes

Ryne Sandberg, PHI/CHI

23 votes

Ted Sizemore, STL/PHI

0 votes

Rennie Stennett, PIT

0 votes

Manny Trillo, CHI/PHI

0 votes

Dan Uggla, FLA

0 votes

Chase Utley, PHI

16 votes

Jose Vidro, MON/WAS

0 votes

G-Fafif May 27 2010 04:52 PM

The National League East requires strength up the middle. Who are your two second basemen, Metsian or otherwise? We are considering strictly the N.L. East tenures of the players in question, so the jury is instructed to disregard anything it saw from second basemen who hit World Series-winning home runs prior to 1969, for example.

Kong76 May 27 2010 05:15 PM Re: All-Time National League East Team: The Second Baseman

I took Ryne and Chase, probably should have taken Mazeroski instead of Chase though now thinking about it. I give full per- mission to pencil me in for him and not Chase if need be.

G-Fafif May 27 2010 06:09 PM Re: All-Time National League East Team: The Second Baseman

If this were the Cub Pool Forum, it might be an issue, but just for the record, apologies to Glenn Beckert for his inadvertent omission from the 2B ballot. I'd add him in, but I think it would render all previous votes vanished.

Rockin' Doc May 27 2010 06:11 PM Re: All-Time National League East Team: The Second Baseman

Sandberg was the class of the field. As much as I hate voting for him, I would give the back up role to Utley.

LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 27 2010 10:07 PM Re: All-Time National League East Team: The Second Baseman

Those two. When all's said and done, provided he stays reasonably healthy and barring an Old-Testament style smiting, Utley will have had a better career than Ryno. By far.

soupcan May 28 2010 07:43 AM Re: All-Time National League East Team: The Second Baseman

Sandberg and Garner.

Edgy DC May 28 2010 08:07 AM Re: All-Time National League East Team: The Second Baseman

Schneider is a beast of the East --- with the 'Pos, the Nats, the Mets, and now the Phillies.