Master Index of Archived Threads


All-Time National League East Team: The RHP

Joaquin Andujar, STL

0 votes

Josh Beckett, FLA

0 votes

Steve Blass, PIT

0 votes

David Cone, NYM

0 votes

Ron Darling, NYM/MON

0 votes

John Denny, STL/PHI

0 votes

Doug Drabek, PIT

0 votes

Dock Ellis, PIT/NYM

0 votes

Bob Forsch, STL

0 votes

Dwight Gooden, NYM

4 votes

Bill Hands, CHI

0 votes

Greg Maddux, CHI/ATL

17 votes

Pedro Martinez, MON/NYM/PHI

0 votes

Bob Gibson, STL

4 votes

Livan Hernandez, FLA/WAS/NYM

0 votes

Ferguson Jenkins, CHI

1 votes

Josh Johnson, FLA

0 votes

Bobby Jones, NYM

0 votes

Rick Reed, PIT/NYM

0 votes

Rick Reuschel, CHI/PIT

0 votes

Steve Rogers, MON

0 votes

Scott Sanderson, MON/CHI

0 votes

Curt Schilling, PHI

0 votes

Tom Seaver, NYM

20 votes

Bill Stoneman, MON

0 votes

Rick Sutcliffe, CHI

0 votes

Craig Swan, NYM

0 votes

John Smoltz, ATL

10 votes

Javier Vazquez, MON/ATL

0 votes

Rick Wise, PHI/STL

0 votes

G-Fafif May 29 2010 12:35 AM Edited 2 time(s), most recently on May 29 2010 02:00 AM

There is much talent to consider from across, how do you say, 41+ seasons National League East right handed starting pitching. Why don't we treat ourselves to three righties? *PLEASE NOTE ALPHABETICAL ORDER IS A BIT ASKEW, SO READ AND VOTE CAREFULLY*

Ashie62 May 29 2010 12:55 AM Re: All-Time National League East Team: The RHP

I'm sticking with one

Nymr83 May 29 2010 01:38 AM Re: All-Time National League East Team: The RHP

Seaver and Maddux would have been my two if we went with only 2 in this poll, and i didnt even have to think about it much. the third guy took a bit, but i went with Smoltz.

Benjamin Grimm May 29 2010 04:16 AM Re: All-Time National League East Team: The RHP

I voted Seaver, Maddux, and Smoltz. (I really wanted to vote for Gooden, but Smoltz got it done for a longer period. A much longer period.) If we weren't limited to divisional play, I would have voted for Bob Gibson.

Swan Swan H May 29 2010 06:27 AM Re: All-Time National League East Team: The RHP

What Ben said, with an added nod to Fergie Jenkins.

Rockin' Doc May 29 2010 07:27 AM Re: All-Time National League East Team: The RHP

Went with Seaver, Maddox, and Smoltz. This is the most stacked field in this entire polling process. When Gibson, Gooden, and Jenkins are left on the sidelines it shows how great the quality of right handed starting pitchers has been throughout the history of the NL East.

LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 29 2010 10:26 AM Re: All-Time National League East Team: The RHP

Not to mention guys like Sutcliffe, Drabek, Cone, Schilling, and Montreal/Mets-era Pedro (who was good-to-great-- with his last year in Montreal beginning his historic spell of dominance-- for 6 of his 8 years in the division).

Zvon May 29 2010 11:05 AM Re: All-Time National League East Team: The RHP

I'm sticking with one So am I! unintentionally :( Maybe you should make it RHP's for us brain impaired.

MFS62 May 30 2010 03:36 PM Re: All-Time National League East Team: The RHP

If I wanted one pitcher, to win one game, I voted Gibson. Later