Forum Home

Master Index of Archived Threads


The Casey Award

Edgy DC
Nov 08 2010 07:25 PM

No, this isn't one of my new forum awards, though it should be. The Casey Award is given out by Spitball Magazine, in honor of the best baseball book of the year.

This year's nominees:

[list][*]The Amazing Tale of Mr. Herbert and His Fabulous Alpine Cowboys Baseball Club: An Illustrated History of the Best Little Semipro Baseball Team in Texas by DJ Stout (University of Texas Press)

[/*:m]
[*]Cardboard Gods: An All-American Tale Told Through Baseball Cards by Josh Wilker (Seven Footer Press)


[/*:m]
[*]The Empire Strikes Out: How Baseball Sold U.S. Foreign Policy and Promoted the American Way Abroad by Robert Elias (The New Press)


[/*:m]
[*]Fifty-Nine in '84: Old Hoss Radbourn, Barehanded Baseball & the Greatest Season a Pitcher Ever Had by Edward Achorn (Harper)


[/*:m]
[*]The Immortals: An Art Collection of Baseball's Best by Dick Perez, text by William C. Kashatus (Brilliant Graphics)


[/*:m]
[*]The Last Boy: Mickey Mantle and the End of America's Childhood by Jane Leavy (Harper);


[/*:m]
[*]The Last Hero: A Life of Henry Aaron by Howard Bryant (Pantheon);


[/*:m]
[*]Pie Traynor: A Baseball Biography by James Forr and David Proctor (McFarland);


[/*:m]
[*]Target Field: The New Home of the Minnesota Twins by Steve Berg (MVP Books);


[/*:m]
[*]Willie Mays: The Life, The Legend by James S. Hirsch (Scribner).
[/*:m][/list:u]

I'm surprised to learn that I only own (and have only read) one of these, considering how many ballbooks got added to my library this year. Suffice to say that that one book (Cardboard Gods) was a walkoff grand slam. Chares Radbourn's 1884 used to fascinate me when I was a kid ("his arm was so sore, he couldn't lift his arm up to comb his hair"), but I remember as a kid always understanding that he won a nice, round 60 games that year. Sometime along the road to my adulthood, somebody adjusted the record and subtracted a win from his total.

Only, I can't find any record of the record being adjusted, and I'm left to believe either (1) I misremember my childhood, (2) I was a dummy in my childhood, or (3) I'm caught in some kind of W.P. Kinsella psychic time warp where I'm living in the same present as everybody, but remember a different baseall past.

I'm certain it must be (3). Anyhow, I'm very interested in the the Radbourn book.

In wonder Boys, protagonist Grady Tripp has a rival in Walter Gaskell, the head of his department. Gaskell is insufferable and humorless and a memoriabilia collecting Yankee fan, working on a marital biography of Joe DiMaggio and Marilyn Monroe tentatively titled The Last American Marriage. I've since learned that a good way to package nostalgia as serious history is to put "The Last... " in the title, as if your modest subject was in fact a turning point, a hinge of history. Bah. I'm therefore suspicious of items six and seven on the list. But I'm sure they're great.

Anyhow, when you're wondering what to buy me some day...

seawolf17
Nov 08 2010 07:46 PM
Re: The Casey Award

Mays book was excellent; I liked the Radbourn one as well, but I'm spoiled by Radbourn's Twitter feed and wanted the book to be snarkier. That doesn't make any sense, but either way, it's a good read. The Aaron book is on my nightstand right now and is next up for me. Cardboard Gods was good but not great.

Dick Perez book would be awesome if it wasn't $200. (Not a typo.)

Edgy DC
Nov 08 2010 08:03 PM
Re: The Casey Award

Shut up! Cardboard Gods was beautiful --- like getting-kicked-in-the-balls-by-an-angel beautiful.

Benjamin Grimm
Nov 09 2010 06:53 AM
Re: The Casey Award

I havent read any of these (I only tend to read one or two baseball books per year anymore) but the 1884 book intrigues me. And maybe I will give the Cardboard book a try. The next baseball book I read is likely to be the Walter Johnson book that his grandson wrote.

Edgy DC
Nov 09 2010 06:58 AM
Re: The Casey Award

Walter Johnson: Baseball's Big Train. Also wonderful.

RealityChuck
Nov 09 2010 09:42 AM
Re: The Casey Award

Edgy DC wrote:
Chares Radbourn's 1884 used to fascinate me when I was a kid ("his arm was so sore, he couldn't lift his arm up to comb his hair"), but I remember as a kid always understanding that he won a nice, round 60 games that year. Sometime along the road to my adulthood, somebody adjusted the record and subtracted a win from his total.

Only, I can't find any record of the record being adjusted, and I'm left to believe either (1) I misremember my childhood, (2) I was a dummy in my childhood, or (3) I'm caught in some kind of W.P. Kinsella psychic time warp where I'm living in the same present as everybody, but remember a different baseall past.
According to official records of the time, he won 60. There is one game in dispute. The starter pitched five innings and left with Providence losing by a run. But Providence went ahead the next inning, and Radbourne finished the game without allowing a run.

Under the rules of the time, the official scorer gave Radbourne the win because he pitched more effectively. Under current rules, the win goes to the other pitcher and Radbourne gets the save.

I say that 60 should be the correct number. Changing the number to 59 is akin to giving Babe Ruth three more home runs because he hit three walk-off hits into the stands that, under the rules of the time, were not scored as home runs. You can't overrule the record book because the rules changed from then to now.

Edgy DC
Nov 09 2010 09:46 AM
Re: The Casey Award

There we go. Thanks. Me not crazy.