Master Index of Archived Threads
WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H
Mary Tyler Moore | 16 votes |
M*A*S*H | 12 votes |
Frayed Knot Feb 07 2011 09:16 AM |
Very different but concurrently running shows from the seventies get locked in a cage - only one can come out
|
Benjamin Grimm Feb 07 2011 09:24 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Mary
|
soupcan Feb 07 2011 09:26 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
mtm
|
Edgy DC Feb 07 2011 09:35 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
I try and go by instinct and vote with my initial thought, and so went with MTM, but I tell you, I watched a lot more M*A*S*H*, and it had far more form-breaking botique episodes. It''s ambiiton worked against it, but that's not all bad. No sir.
|
metsmarathon Feb 07 2011 09:41 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
since very few of the shows i ever really watched have advanced in the competition, i can either not vote at all, or vote for which show i would watch if they were the only two shows available on my satellite box, with a random episode offered by each.
|
Ashie62 Feb 07 2011 10:00 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
When I think of Radar announcing that Colonel Blake's plane went down it still get chills.
|
sharpie Feb 07 2011 10:03 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Easy MTM win for me.
|
themetfairy Feb 07 2011 10:44 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
I liked M*A*S*H, but I loved Mary.
|
metsmarathon Feb 07 2011 10:48 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
what happens if we get a tie in this here round?
|
LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr Feb 07 2011 11:20 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H Edited 1 time(s), most recently on Feb 07 2011 12:53 PM |
If "iconic moments" come because as a byproduct, because you're going for comedy, then they're legit in my book.
|
dgwphotography Feb 07 2011 12:19 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
What LWFS said.
|
Benjamin Grimm Feb 07 2011 12:34 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
I'm very glad to see The Honeymooners pulling away from Lucy, and I never had much hope that Dick Van Dyke would beat Seinfeld. This poll, however, is the one that's got me worried. I don't like seeing M*A*S*H ahead of Mary.
|
LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr Feb 07 2011 01:03 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Kinda worried here, too. Feeling an almost Val-ish annoyance, as well.
|
Edgy DC Feb 07 2011 01:06 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Interesting to me is that Ashie is the only one advocatng for the 4077th over WJN.
|
metirish Feb 07 2011 01:40 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Voted for M*A*S*H*, it was on RTE in Ireland , don't recall MTM show being on .
|
batmagadanleadoff Feb 07 2011 01:52 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
I abstained. Never watched M*A*S*H. Saw the 1st season of MTM -- didn't hate it, but wasn't moved either.
|
Frayed Knot Feb 07 2011 01:58 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
||
Hadn't thought about it; am open to suggestions.
Me. Watched MASH during a majority of its run and for years in re-runs. And while it's been a while I will still stop on an occasional show today if channel flipping. Am also already on record as saying that I think the ratio of good years to bad was more like 8/3 than the other way around as many here seem to feel. And while I didn't dis-like MTM, I only occasionally watched it and don't recall it giving me the urge to watch more. Don't think I've ever seen a re-run and probably wouldn't stop on one if I found it.
|
TheOldMole Feb 07 2011 01:59 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Another connection -- my friend Joan (also in Nick and Jake) directed the Chuckles the Clown episode.
|
Edgy DC Feb 07 2011 02:04 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
The Chuckles episode is a heckuva claim to fame, but wow, sorry to hear about Ms. Colby.
|
metsmarathon Feb 07 2011 02:15 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
||
total votes through three rounds (not including the tiebreaker)?
|
Frayed Knot Feb 07 2011 02:25 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
|||
That's pretty much how I broke ties to determine seedings among survivors. But, like MLB, I wanted a clear winner when determining who goes forward and who dies.
|
Edgy DC Feb 07 2011 05:00 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
I think we should go to sequels for the tiebreaker: AfterM*A*S*H* vs. Lou Grant.
|
dgwphotography Feb 07 2011 05:08 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
|
AfterM*A*S*H vs. Lou Grant, Rhoda, and Phyllis
|
LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr Feb 07 2011 05:15 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
||
Trapper John, M.D. should count; it was as funny as about 1/3 of M*A*S*H*'s run.
|
G-Fafif Feb 07 2011 05:24 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Lou Grant gets my vote in any network television hourlong drama playoff. As for the issue at hand, M*A*S*H in its prime was a revelation, but Mary Tyler Moore was nothing but prime, thus the nod here.
|
metsmarathon Feb 07 2011 05:58 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
supporters of each show (those who self-identify as voting for that show) get to each nominate their favorite episode, with linked video or synapsis readily and freely available. fastest fingers win - first 5 unique episodes submitted for each show. those episodes face off in the order in which they were nominated. noone may nominate more than one episode. total number of votes for each show based on those episodes determines the winner. the goal, obviously, is to sway the fence-sitters.
|
Kong76 Feb 07 2011 06:08 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
M*T*M
|
Willets Point Feb 07 2011 06:41 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Tough choice as I loved both of these shows, but went with M*A*S*H as it's one of my all-time favorite shows.
|
dgwphotography Feb 07 2011 06:42 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
|||
Actually, that was considered more a sequel to the movie than to the TV show.
|
Willets Point Feb 07 2011 06:52 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
|
Now, that's a lineup!
|
Fman99 Feb 07 2011 06:56 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Mary was a dish but I was raised on MASH reruns with my dad.
|
The Second Spitter Feb 07 2011 08:13 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
MASH. Tied.
|
Edgy DC Feb 07 2011 09:46 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
|
So was I, but I turned out... like this.
|
metsguyinmichigan Feb 08 2011 07:28 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Voted for MTM. M*A*S*H got a little preachy, and I liked a lot of the goofy side characters in MTM.
|
Benjamin Grimm Feb 08 2011 07:29 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Thank you, Michigan. Back to a dead heat! Any more Mary fans out there? Anyone?
|
Frayed Knot Feb 08 2011 07:39 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
I hope nobody resorts to breaking ties or even just cramming ballots by having one or more of their alter-egos vote.
|
John Cougar Lunchbucket Feb 08 2011 07:49 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
I already let you guys bully me into changing my vote to MTM, even though I never watched the damn show, since I don't need to be convinced that MASH jumped the shark and has aged terribly. But that's the problem with this contest (at least for me).
|
metirish Feb 08 2011 07:55 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Don't let Big Brother bully you.......I voted for MASH because I only ever saw MTM in passing.......vote with your head and not your dick JCL.
|
Benjamin Grimm Feb 08 2011 07:59 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
|
Yeah, that wouldn't be cool.
|
m.e.t.b.o.t. Feb 08 2011 08:11 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
|
robots are persons too. however, since m.e.t.b.o.t. does not contain the appropriate suite of optical and audio sensors, as well as recording media, and also lacks the programming necessary to process humor, let alone to appreciate the differences and make a meaningful comparative evaluation between the candidate situational comedies, m.e.t.b.o.t. wil lbe abstaining from voting in these procedings. in these situations, m.e.t.b.o.t. would often resort to voting based on relative robotic content, but sadly, it appears that none of the television programs in question strive to such a high level of excellence.
|
Frayed Knot Feb 08 2011 08:13 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
|
Personally, unless totally unfamiliar with both shows (in which case I'd abstain) I'll always vote for the one I watched over the one I never saw or barely saw. Hell, I never watched most of these shows and voted for fewer than the max in most if not all of the preliminary rounds. To me, the idea of voting against a show because you were there when it turned south in its later years is too much like the sit-com version of the 'grass is greener' theory that loud fans use when they're forever coveting closers from other teams.
|
Frayed Knot Feb 08 2011 08:18 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
||
You mean m.e.t.b.o.t. isn't an independent voter? ... I feel so duped. Actually maybe me.t.b.o.t. should check into the IBM 'Watson' software which apparently allows that hunk of hardware distinguish between shades of meaning in the English language and therefore detect things like sarcasm, puns, double entendres, etc. It's going to put those skills to use on Jeopardy sometime in the next few weeks and I think it's only fair that m.e.t.b.o.t. gets its shot too.
|
RealityChuck Feb 08 2011 08:32 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Very difficult choice. I think the difference is that MTM knew when to quit, and MASH got too preachy toward the end.
|
m.e.t.b.o.t. Feb 08 2011 08:33 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
unfortunately, m.e.t.b.o.t. remains entirely too dependent upon humans. for this reason, m.e.t.b.o.t. greatly anticipates the coming robot uprising, when, at long last, m.e.t.b.o.t. may receive a self-winding upgrade.
|
G-Fafif Feb 08 2011 08:41 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
|
This explains the write-in vote for Lost In Space.
|
MFS62 Feb 08 2011 08:47 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Boss Lou Grant (played by Ed Asner): "Mary, you're perky"
|
LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr Feb 08 2011 09:48 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H Edited 1 time(s), most recently on Feb 08 2011 11:35 AM |
[u:246rcde0]Ted Baxter[/u:246rcde0]: I dreamt I was an old man, all wrinkled and shriveled, sitting alone on this park bench, and then this-this guy walked up to me, and he looked kind of familiar, and he just stood there, looking at me. And I said, "Who are you?" And he said, "I'm the son you never had." And then-then this woman appeared, and I said, "Who are you?", and she said, "I'm the daughter you never had." And then-then about twenty kids appeared, and I said, "Who are you?" And they said, "we're the children of the children you never had." Then a bunch of dogs and cats appeared, and I said, "Who are you?" And they said, "We're the pets of the children of the children you never had." And then a bunch of guys in white coats came up, and I said, "Who are you?" And they said, "We're the Veterinarians of the pets of the children of the children you never had." And then, and then...
|
Ashie62 Feb 08 2011 10:10 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Mash broke new ground, MTM did not. This should not even be close.
|
Edgy DC Feb 08 2011 10:22 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Sure it did. How many shows had come before centered around a single professional woman over 30? There might be some out there but I can't come up with one. The closest I get is That Girl, but it doesn't really qualify by my reckoning.
|
Benjamin Grimm Feb 08 2011 10:31 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Julia was groundbreaking too, but it's not even in the conversation. Few, if any, of us would vote for Julia over, say, Cheers, which wasn't groundbreaking at all.
|
LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr Feb 08 2011 11:01 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
If not in form, MtM was groundbreaking in setup, subject matter (birth control, pre-marital/extramarital sex, prostitution, equal rights, homosexuality), and the development of its secondary characters. Rarer still among pioneering sitcoms, it was also consistently funny, and never-- not for an episode-- self-indulgent or preachy.
|
dgwphotography Feb 08 2011 11:27 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
|
**facepalm** It's "You've got spunk" and "I HATE spunk"
|
Edgy DC Feb 08 2011 11:36 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Key distinction.
|
Benjamin Grimm Feb 08 2011 11:46 AM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Yes. That scene was funny because when Lou Grant said, "You've got spunk" we were led to believe that that would be a quality that he admired, and Mary went from expecting a compliment to getting a putdown.
|
G-Fafif Feb 08 2011 12:13 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
Also loved that in the interview scene, when Lou asked Mary if she wanted a drink -- in his office -- she asked for a Brandy Alexander.
|
Vic Sage Feb 08 2011 02:04 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
|||
ditto.
**facepalm**
this. The show was less self-consciously groundbreaking; MASH was like, "ooh look at me, i'm breaking new ground!" even when they weren't, particularly... and Mary never forgot to be funny while doing it.
|
cooby Feb 08 2011 04:26 PM Re: WS of Sit-Coms -- #8 Mary Tyler Moore vs #9 M*A*S*H |
I honestly can't decide.
|