Forum Home

Master Index of Archived Threads


i hate scotty mccreery...

Vic Sage
May 13 2011 10:02 AM

... i'm just saying.

this American Idol finalist is the most annoying singer to make the top 4 ever.

He is an adolescent with a deep voice that allows him to feign a maturity and depth he does not possess and a world-weariness he has not earned. He uses a cliched set of country hiccups and musical phrasing that were corny when Mel Tillis and Conway Twitty used them. His attempts to be hip and/or modern devolve into finger waggin' hiphop gestures that are as inauthentic as his good ole boy shtick.

But i get it. He's a cute, cleancut boy with a deep voice. girls like him. fine. whatever. I DON'T get the judges constant BJs, especially when they are giving a hard time to the infinitely more interesting and talented Haley, but like i said... whatever. I wasn't going to let it get me riled.

But then the other night, singing "inspirational songs", Scotty boy wallows in the most pandering performance in the history of the show... after we shoot Osama, Scotty the body sings a 9/11 song, that allows him to wave the flag and the bible in both hands. Then, in song #2, Lady Gaga tries to break him of his irritating, mannered and stupid habit of holding the mike like its a piccolo and he gets all sexually threatened by her metaphors, forcing him to kiss his cross as if to ward off the sexual predator stalking him. Which is funny, considering he's singing YOUNGBLOOD, which is a song glamorizing a stalker. But its a GUY stalker, so that's fine. Gaga, however, as a woman claiming her own sexuality, must have a stake driven through her evil heart.

I lost interest in AI once the interesting Casey "Seth Rogen" Jacobs got voted off, but the continulatin' existence of McCreery is an agrivatinly anus-clenchin' example of the fact that the Civil War never really ended.

John Cougar Lunchbucket
May 13 2011 10:41 AM
Re: i hate scotty mccreery...

Haven't seen a moment of AI all year but I'd like more recaps written like that.

LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr
May 13 2011 10:44 AM
Re: i hate scotty mccreery...

That Casey kid got me with his off-kilter "Nature Boy"... and then he was gone again in, like, a week. Week by week, they keep losing much more interesting voices-- slightly off-kilter gospeller Jacob, metaaaaaahl boy James-- while this little fucker sticks around.

And even when you get past the more substantial reasons to dislike his shtick... there's the fact that you get at least one of these...

... every single performance. I'd call it "satanic" but that would imply some sort of magnetism or charisma.

metirish
May 13 2011 10:54 AM
Re: i hate scotty mccreery...

John Cougar Lunchbucket wrote:
Haven't seen a moment of AI all year but I'd like more recaps written like that.



I've not watched since the top ten was announced , agree with the recap. Facebook was lit up last night with "my friends" crying about the lad with the tic getting kicked out. I do believe is Simon was there McCreery would have been kicked out by now, him and his one trick pony.

Fman99
May 13 2011 08:55 PM
Re: i hate scotty mccreery...

American Idol blows dead bears.

bmfc1
May 14 2011 03:27 PM
Re: i hate scotty mccreery...

Good job, Vic. I sat with my wife, half paying attention except when Pia Toscano was on and she had my full attention. Pia was booted around when the Mets returned so I haven't watched. I agree with you about McCreery.

Ashie62
May 14 2011 03:33 PM
Re: i hate scotty mccreery...

It is just a teenage popularity contest.

The Second Spitter
May 20 2011 05:29 AM
Re: i hate scotty mccreery...

LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr wrote:
That Casey kid got me with his off-kilter "Nature Boy"....


WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Vic Sage
May 20 2011 08:14 AM
Re: i hate scotty mccreery...

the 2 country teens make it into the finals.
Yawn.

S'long Haley and thanks for all the fish.

Edgy DC
May 20 2011 08:28 AM
Re: i hate scotty mccreery...

While I've never had interest in that show, I'm doubly suspicious of an institution capable of creating a context where Gaga is on the side I'm supposed to root for.

Vic Sage
May 20 2011 08:42 AM
Re: i hate scotty mccreery...

Edgy DC wrote:
While I've never had interest in that show, I'm doubly suspicious of an institution capable of creating a context where Gaga is on the side I'm supposed to root for.


oh, most definitely ditto.