Forum Home

Master Index of Archived Threads


Totally Missed This

Edgy DC
Jun 27 2011 12:55 PM

It happens when you're at work and following the game at the same time, but I missed the report that the ejection of Elvis Andrus yesterday, which was reported in the radio booth two innings after the fact, was the result of Terry Collins being given the option of which Ranger to toss, as the umps felt the whole bench was out of line. Terry, being sporting (and probably somewhat humbled by the breaks he was getting) chose a reserve infielder who was probably too injured to play anyhow.

I guess, if he wanted to be supersporting, he could have chosen yesterday's starting pitcher. I've never heard of this designated ejectee situation before and I wonder if Terry's choice of the least-valuable offensive player is some sort of un-written understanding managers have in that situation.

Ceetar
Jun 27 2011 01:06 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

that's weird.

Edgy DC
Jun 27 2011 01:08 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

I have to say, I'm not sure this is true. All the sources that are confirming it so far are secondary fan-journalism type sources.

Ceetar
Jun 27 2011 01:14 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

Edgy DC wrote:
I have to say, I'm not sure this is true. All the sources that are confirming it so far are secondary fan-journalism type sources.



I kind of doubt it too, but who knows. I do know that if you're on the DL you're not allowed to benchjockey.

Benjamin Grimm
Jun 27 2011 01:15 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

Sounds fishy to me. I would think that in such a situation, the ump would send all non-playing players to the clubhouse, to be summoned if needed.

John Cougar Lunchbucket
Jun 27 2011 01:16 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

Had to have been an act of good sportsmanship.

Edgy DC
Jun 27 2011 01:19 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

Ceetar wrote:
Edgy DC wrote:
I have to say, I'm not sure this is true. All the sources that are confirming it so far are secondary fan-journalism type sources.



I kind of doubt it too, but who knows. I do know that if you're on the DL you're not allowed to benchjockey.

And how do you enforce that, except by kicking out active players?

Ceetar
Jun 27 2011 01:22 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

Edited 1 time(s), most recently on Jun 27 2011 01:25 PM

Edgy DC wrote:
Edgy DC wrote:
I have to say, I'm not sure this is true. All the sources that are confirming it so far are secondary fan-journalism type sources.



I kind of doubt it too, but who knows. I do know that if you're on the DL you're not allowed to benchjockey.

And how do you enforce that, except by kicking out active players?


I don't remember the punishment.

looked it up. Basically ejection. Which doesn't really do much besides banish him from the bench.

metirish
Jun 27 2011 01:22 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

s the umps felt the whole bench was out of line



I didn't see the whole game, what happened?

Edgy DC
Jun 27 2011 01:24 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

Really, everything about yesterday was weird. Do you realize (I imagine you do) that the Mets took a series while being outhomered 7-0?

metirish
Jun 27 2011 01:25 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

Edgy DC wrote:
Really, everything about yesterday was weird. Do you realize (I imagine you do) that the Mets took a series while being outhomered 7-0?



yes but they had like 700 singles right?

Edgy DC
Jun 27 2011 01:40 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

Yeah, and also the twin blessings of perhaps four-five unjustly benevolent calls and a superduperstar held out of the rubber game, while carrying a starter pulled early with an achey-breaky heart, a closer pitching lousy, and Bay-Hairston-Turner coming up empty against Holland in that game three, plus the aforementioned power outage.* I don't know, but I feel like they got outplayed by both Oakland and Texas, and somehow came up with the series both times. The team still seems to be looking for answers. They're just managing to find a series of temporary ones right now.

*Citi Schmitty. If this team can't hit homers in Arlington, they can't really hit 'em.

Ceetar
Jun 27 2011 01:45 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

Edgy DC wrote:
Yeah, and also the twin blessings of perhaps four-five unjustly benevolent calls and a superduperstar held out of the rubber game, while carrying a starter pulled early with an achey-breaky heart, a closer pitching lousy, and Bay-Hairston-Turner coming up empty against Holland in that game three, plus the aforementioned power outage.* I don't know, but I feel like they got outplayed by both Oakland and Texas, and somehow came up with the series both times. The team still seems to be looking for answers. They're just managing to find a series of temporary ones right now.

*Citi Schmitty. If this team can't hit homers in Arlington, they can't really hit 'em.


That's fine. I feel like they've outplayed some teams, like the Phillies in some cases, and lost.
And they did get a lot of near misses with home runs

soupcan
Jun 27 2011 01:47 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

From The New York Times article this morning:

In the sixth inning, the home plate umpire Andy Fletcher ejected Rangers shortstop Elvis Andrus for arguing ball and strike calls from the bench, even though Andrus was not in the game. When Texas Manager Ron Washington went out to argue, he was tossed, too.

Collins went to Fletcher to try and convince him that Young was really the offending party.

“I knew the one guy that was yelling, and I wanted to make sure he was the guy they threw out, which he wasn’t,” Collins said. “They didn’t know who it was, and I did, and I wanted him out of the game.”


Bit of a different version to say the least.

Frayed Knot
Jun 27 2011 01:54 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

Yeah, and the designated (by the opposition no less) ejectee stuff sounds like hooey to me.

86-Dreamer
Jun 27 2011 02:04 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

From The New York Times article this morning:

In the sixth inning, the home plate umpire Andy Fletcher ejected Rangers shortstop Elvis Andrus for arguing ball and strike calls from the bench, even though Andrus was not in the game. When Texas Manager Ron Washington went out to argue, he was tossed, too.

Collins went to Fletcher to try and convince him that Young was really the offending party.

“I knew the one guy that was yelling, and I wanted to make sure he was the guy they threw out, which he wasn’t,” Collins said. “They didn’t know who it was, and I did, and I wanted him out of the game.”


Bit of a different version to say the least.



here is Newsday's version:

The Reyes call got Texas manager Ron Washington riled up, and he reached his boiling point in the sixth inning, when he was thrown out along with Elvis Andrus. The annoyed Washington came out to argue with plate umpire Andy Fletcher after Murphy's RBI double, and Fletcher also was angered by someone on the Texas bench.

Fletcher informed them that someone had to go and the Rangers picked Andrus, who did not start and was not playing. Collins had a discussion with Fletcher about it and later said the umpire settled for the wrong guy.

"I knew who the one guy was that was yelling and I wanted to make sure he was the guy they threw out," Collins said. "They didn't know and I did. I wanted him out of the game."

Collins said it was Young, who had tormented his team all weekend. But after Andrus was tossed, DH Young gave a knowing nod to Collins on his way to the plate.

"I was tired of watching him hit the ball out of the ballpark," Collins said.

Vic Sage
Jun 27 2011 02:41 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

And they did get a lot of near misses with home runs


yeah, because that's how that works.

Ceetar
Jun 27 2011 02:47 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

Vic Sage wrote:
And they did get a lot of near misses with home runs


yeah, because that's how that works.


Duda rocked one three inches from the top of the wall. fraction of an inch lower and it clears the fence, a fraction of a second faster and it clears the fence more to the right. There were a couple of other hard hit balls that went far. It's not like they were just stringing singles.

Vic Sage
Jun 27 2011 02:53 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

fraction of an inch lower and it clears the fence, a fraction of a second faster and it clears the fence more to the right.


and if it had wheels and was painted yellow, it would be a school bus.

Ceetar, you're a wonder at talking about things that didn't happen as evidence as to why they will, but not so hot with actual events, especially if they conflict with the pre-written narrative of hope and miracles you've got going on in your head.

Ceetar
Jun 27 2011 02:59 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

Vic Sage wrote:
fraction of an inch lower and it clears the fence, a fraction of a second faster and it clears the fence more to the right.


and if it had wheels and was painted yellow, it would be a school bus.

Ceetar, you're a wonder at talking about things that didn't happen as evidence as to why they will, but not so hot with actual events, especially if they conflict with the pre-written narrative of hope and miracles you've got going on in your head.


A scorcher off the wall is not the same thing as a single. It represents power, even if it didn't clear the fence. He hit the crap out of the ball, it was nearly the Grand Slam in long time. (and it also wasn't his only XBH of the day) The ability to tattoo the wall with doubles is much more suggestive that a guy is capable of hitting some home runs and likely will, than it is that he's a singles hitter and the Mets got lucky to win the series.

seawolf17
Jun 27 2011 06:59 PM
Re: Totally Missed This

Edgy DC wrote:
Really, everything about yesterday was weird. Do you realize (I imagine you do) that the Mets took a series while being outhomered 7-0?

I was too busy being excited about winning Texas brisket from my Rangers fan friend in Abilene. Yum!

Edgy DC
Jun 28 2011 05:15 AM
Re: Totally Missed This

I'm also sort of surprised there was no off-day news yesterday. I kind of got the impression that if Francsico Rodriguez was auditioning for the Rangers on Sunday and failed.

Ceetar
Jun 28 2011 06:13 AM
Re: Totally Missed This

Edgy DC wrote:
I'm also sort of surprised there was no off-day news yesterday. I kind of got the impression that if Francsico Rodriguez was auditioning for the Rangers on Sunday and failed.


Yesterday was really slow it seemed. Summer doldrums?

bmfc1
Jun 28 2011 06:45 AM
Re: Totally Missed This

It was nice to have a day without news of a Met injury, team finances or somebody saying something stupid. The only newsy item I heard was Ed Coleman telling Steve Somers that David Wright could be available before the ASB but it would make sense to hold him back until after the ASB.

Edgy DC
Jun 28 2011 06:52 AM
Re: Totally Missed This

I just really expected a transaction.

John Cougar Lunchbucket
Jun 28 2011 07:13 AM
Re: Totally Missed This

Tracky wrote an off-day profile of Dillon Gee, painting him as a clever guy who knows how to succeed. Like Bobby Parnell, Dillon is the son of a firefighter.

We should start a Met parentage thread.

Ceetar
Jun 28 2011 07:14 AM
Re: Totally Missed This

bmfc1 wrote:
It was nice to have a day without news of a Met injury, team finances or somebody saying something stupid. The only newsy item I heard was Ed Coleman telling Steve Somers that David Wright could be available before the ASB but it would make sense to hold him back until after the ASB.


I'm of two thoughts on that, I think they should get him back here, and he wants to be back here, sooner rather than later, but I think one of the big mistakes they made last year was bringing Castillo and Beltran back immediately after the break. Beltran got 4 days off after rehab, and then jumped right into MLB pitching. That seems a rough transition, and is it really any surprise that they struggled? With the extra day off you could have Wright play in AAA on Thursday before bringin him up. Of course, do you want the first three pitchers he faces in the majors to be Halladay, Lee, Hamels?

bmfc1
Jun 28 2011 07:24 AM
Re: Totally Missed This

Good point Ceetar. Why activate him to face Linecum and Cain (the guy that beaned him) then have him rest for 4 days (he'd probably skip the ASG but go anyway to sit) when he could be in the minors facing real pitching. There's no way around the MFPs staff unless he "needs" another few days of rehab games.

Ceetar
Jun 28 2011 07:31 AM
Re: Totally Missed This

bmfc1 wrote:
Good point Ceetar. Why activate him to face Linecum and Cain (the guy that beaned him) then have him rest for 4 days (he'd probably skip the ASG but go anyway to sit) when he could be in the minors facing real pitching. There's no way around the MFPs staff unless he "needs" another few days of rehab games.


Well, Bisons are off M-T-W too. No guarentee it's Lincey and Cain to finish off that series. It's also 20 straight games without an off day after the break, which seems harsh.