Master Index of Archived Threads


Phil Cuzzi Can't Count To 4

bmfc1 Jul 03 2011 11:18 AM

Phil Cuzzi with another bad call last night. Look at the video, below: the Mariners got screwed last night by Cuzzi, who can't count to four. That's the same Phil Cuzzi that helped the Mets win a game last July in SF and allegedly helped the Mets earlier this year against the Nationals (so this isn't a Mets rant). He also helped the MFYs win a playoff game against the Twins in 2009. http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/gameday/index.js ... &mode=wrap

Frayed Knot Jul 03 2011 12:11 PM Re: Phil Cuzzi Can't Count To 4

My question on these things always is -- how did the pitcher/catcher/fielders/opposing manager all not realize what was up? Especially since it's not like the call on the first pitch - the only called strike of the bunch which could possibly been confused with a called ball - was ambiguous or anything. The remaining pitches were either swinging strikes or foul strikes. Sounds like maybe the scoreboard messed up pitch #1 (you hear the announcers say 1-1 rather than 0-2 after the second pitch) and that everyone simply went along with it from there. Not that any of that absolves Cuzzi or anything ... but, geez, pay attention folks. It's only your livelihood.

LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr Jul 03 2011 02:10 PM Re: Phil Cuzzi Can't Count To 4

Supposedly-- as per Howie earlier, and a few other anonymous-sourced reports I've seen online-- he inspires LOTS of eye-rolling among his peers.

Frayed Knot Jul 03 2011 04:16 PM Re: Phil Cuzzi Can't Count To 4

LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr wrote: Supposedly-- as per Howie earlier, and a few other anonymous-sourced reports I've seen online-- he inspires LOTS of eye-rolling among his peers. HE as in who? Cuzzi, or the Mariner manager who wasn't paying attention? If it's Cuzzi it would be surprising only in that you rarely hear umps talk about each other even on the quiet.

bmfc1 Jul 03 2011 04:19 PM Re: Phil Cuzzi Can't Count To 4

With such a track record, why is Cuzzi still a major league ump? Does he have tenure, like a teacher? Maybe MLB is waiting for him to determine a World Series game first.

Gwreck Jul 03 2011 04:24 PM Re: Phil Cuzzi Can't Count To 4

Phil Cuzzi, Angel Hernandez, CB Bucknor, Joe West. Nobody knows why they are still employed.

LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr Jul 03 2011 11:38 PM Re: Phil Cuzzi Can't Count To 4

Frayed Knot wrote: LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr wrote: Supposedly-- as per Howie earlier, and a few other anonymous-sourced reports I've seen online-- he inspires LOTS of eye-rolling among his peers. HE as in who? Cuzzi, or the Mariner manager who wasn't paying attention? If it's Cuzzi it would be surprising only in that you rarely hear umps talk about each other even on the quiet. Cuzzi. Managers' attention shouldn't wane. Home plate umpires who ignore the counter in their hand shouldn't be employed.