Master Index of Archived Threads


Who Do You Trust?

Mike Pelfrey

0 votes

R. A. Dickey

4 votes

Jonathon Niese

13 votes

Chris Capuano

0 votes

Dillon Gee

4 votes

Frayed Knot Jul 30 2011 08:14 AM

Fill in the blank: You've just been handed tickets to an upcoming Mets game and, because you've checked the schedule and realize it could be a real important one for the stretch drive (work with me here, OK?), your first thought is; "Oh, I really hope ________ is pitching that night." In other words, without muddling up your answer by bringing in factors such as age, future hopes, general likability, or grading on a curve due to salary & expectations, which one of the current starters would you currently trust the most to put in a good outing on a given night?

dgwphotography Jul 30 2011 08:25 AM Re: Who Do You Trust?

George Stone (some pain just don't go away) Seriously, my first, knee-jerk reaction is Niese.

MFS62 Jul 30 2011 08:29 AM Re: Who Do You Trust?

I voted Gee - the best option for a good performance on a given night. But on second thought, R.A. Dickey, while not as consistent, might be the one to pitch the team's first no-hitter on any given night. DGW - that's not just pain. That's massive trauma. Later

LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr Jul 30 2011 08:43 AM Re: Who Do You Trust? Edited 1 time(s), most recently on Jul 30 2011 09:58 AM

Gee may have been a contender for my vote early, and he's impressed me with the battling-with-bad-stuff jobs he's done in the last 2-3 starts. But it's really a two-man race here, and Hawkman takes it by a sensitive hangnail over Beowulf. (It's REAL close.)

themetfairy Jul 30 2011 08:46 AM Re: Who Do You Trust?

None of these guys compares to pre-injured Johan. But among this batch I've seen Niese pitch some great games, so I'd go with him.

TheOldMole Jul 30 2011 09:39 AM Re: Who Do You Trust?

Good, difficult question. I went with Niese.

metirish Jul 30 2011 09:45 AM Re: Who Do You Trust?

TheOldMole wrote: Good, difficult question. I went with Niese. Yes, good question ...went with Gee but waffled on it .

Edgy DC Jul 30 2011 10:00 AM Re: Who Do You Trust?

I went with Niese, but it's really a four guys I'm comfortable with, and one guy I'm not.

TransMonk Jul 30 2011 10:08 AM Re: Who Do You Trust?

Edgy DC wrote: I went with Niese, but it's really a four guys I'm comfortable with, and one guy I'm not. I went with Dickey, but feel the same as Edgy. I'm OK with 80% of the staff.

soupcan Jul 30 2011 10:45 AM Re: Who Do You Trust?

NIese, but shouldn't it be 'whom do you trust?'

Fman99 Jul 30 2011 11:11 AM Re: Who Do You Trust?

Went with Niese in a close call over Gee.

themetfairy Jul 30 2011 12:02 PM Re: Who Do You Trust?

soupcan wrote: NIese, but shouldn't it be 'whom do you trust?' Yes - that's been driving me nuts all day.

Edgy DC Jul 30 2011 01:39 PM Re: Who Do You Trust?

On the 27th day of October In the Autumn of eighty-six While the Mets were jumping Orosco I was born like a ton of bricks I licked all the boys in Ohio As we fought in the midwestern dust Come on, baby, take a walk with me child And tell who do you trust? Who do you trust? Who do you trust? I got 40 pounds of weight on my curveball grip Take it easy baby don't you give me no lip Who do you trust? Who do you trust? Got a Steve Carlton arm and a Bob Gibson mind I'm just twenty-four and I don't mind dy'n' Who do you trust? Who do you trust? Now Terry puts the game ball right in my hand Said "Howard's up and we need him fanned" Who do you trust? Got a nose like a hawk and bite like snake Here comes Utley who they say can rake Unleashed my curve and somebody screamed You should've heard what I'd seen Who do you trust? Who do you trust? Who do you trust? Who do you trust? Got a Steve Carlton arm and a Bob Gibson mind I'm just twenty-four and I don't mind dy'n' It starts at your shoulders, comes crash at your feet It's the 12-6 curve, babe, it sets up the heat Who do you trust? Who do you trust? On the 27th day of October In the Autumn of eighty-six While the Mets were jumping Orosco I was born like a ton of bricks I licked all the boys in Ohio As we fought in the midwestern dust Come on, baby, take a walk with me child And tell who do you trust? Who do you trust? Who do you trust? Who do you trust? Who do you trust?

Frayed Knot Jul 30 2011 02:17 PM Re: Who Do You Trust?

^ Nice one, although that wasn't my inspiration. Actually ... soupcan wrote: NIese, but shouldn't it be 'whom do you trust?' ... I was going for a play off the old TV game-show which gave Johnny Carson his start (no, really, I was) but then abandoned the idea of making a reference to the show seeing as how I never saw it and probably fewer have even heard of it ... but then I kept the title as the subject heading anyway.