Master Index of Archived Threads


Victor Martinez - Done for season?

Frayed Knot Jan 17 2012 05:29 PM

Torn ACL during winter workouts. Getting 2nd opinion but probably slated for surgery which would wipe out all of 2012 Suxx to be Detroit right about now.

Edgy MD Jan 17 2012 07:02 PM Re: Victor Martinez - Done for season?

Expect everybody and his sister to be calling Detroit with offers of big-stick-no-glove guys. Maybe the Mets'll offer Doodie.

John Cougar Lunchbucket Jan 17 2012 07:15 PM Re: Victor Martinez - Done for season?

Muffy, even better.

metsguyinmichigan Jan 17 2012 08:29 PM Re: Victor Martinez - Done for season?

Much weeping and gnashing of teeth here in the Mitten State. Local sports talk callers were demanding Prince Fielder -- which is not going to happen -- then turned to David Wright, citing to the hole at third, where Brandon Inge and his .215 stick reside. Assuming Justin Verlander would not be coming over, I don't see too many of these guys that we'd want at Citi in exchange for our one drawing card.

Ceetar Jan 17 2012 08:47 PM Re: Victor Martinez - Done for season?

metsguyinmichigan wrote: Much weeping and gnashing of teeth here in the Mitten State. Local sports talk callers were demanding Prince Fielder -- which is not going to happen -- then turned to David Wright, citing to the hole at third, where Brandon Inge and his .215 stick reside. Assuming Justin Verlander would not be coming over, I don't see too many of these guys that we'd want at Citi in exchange for our one drawing card. Murphy really would be a perfect fit.

Edgy MD Jan 17 2012 08:52 PM Re: Victor Martinez - Done for season?

I'm not of a mind, but if they are, I'm sure there's somebody they can match up with. Murphy for Scherzer maybe.

John Cougar Lunchbucket Jan 17 2012 09:26 PM Re: Victor Martinez - Done for season?

Edgy DC wrote: I'm not of a mind, but if they are, I'm sure there's somebody they can match up with. Murphy for Scherzer maybe. Yup yup. I love what Muffy did for us last year but I'm having trouble imagining him as an everyday 2Bman. I think maybe that's Reese Havens' job.

Frayed Knot Jan 18 2012 06:34 AM Re: Victor Martinez - Done for season?

Also wrist surgery for Carl Crawford which may cause him to not be ready by opening day. You're always surprised by surgeries done at this time of year rather than in October or November but it just goes to show you that medicine isn't an exact science (except on talk radio and websites).

Ceetar Jan 18 2012 06:43 AM Re: Victor Martinez - Done for season?

Frayed Knot wrote: Also wrist surgery for Carl Crawford which may cause him to not be ready by opening day. You're always surprised by surgeries done at this time of year rather than in October or November but it just goes to show you that medicine isn't an exact science (except on talk radio and websites). Presumably due to the topical nature of WFAN, there are still people calling up killing the Mets for Beltran having surgery in January. Or Blaming Beltran for purposely waiting to have it.

Frayed Knot Jan 18 2012 06:50 AM Re: Victor Martinez - Done for season?

Well it's the nature of fans in general and not just 'The FAN' in particular to not be a medical professional yet play one on the air and/or the web. Mets fans specifically have killed the team's medical conduct in recent years* but if they were to suddenly switch their allegiances elsewhere they'd find the same complaints. * and isn't it funny how losing seasons seem to exacerbate that trend? -- Of course one could claim that the 'malpractice' was part of the cause of the losing but I think we're into a chicken and egg thing here.

Ceetar Jan 18 2012 06:56 AM Re: Victor Martinez - Done for season?

Frayed Knot wrote: Well it's the nature of fans in general and not just 'The FAN' in particular to not be a medical professional yet play one on the air and/or the web. Mets fans specifically have killed the team's medical conduct in recent years* but if they were to suddenly switch their allegiances elsewhere they'd find the same complaints. * and isn't it funny how losing seasons seem to exacerbate that trend? -- Of course one could claim that the 'malpractice' was part of the cause of the losing but I think we're into a chicken and egg thing here. Maybe I don't follow enough Red Sox fans, but are they killing Crawford for waiting? Or they blaming it on out of shape from fried chicken and beer? Are there beat writers tweeting every skeptical medical decision, right or wrong, from the last 6 years? Don't forget finance experts. It's obviously not just the radio, but I find the radio makes a good scape-goat, seems to draw out some of crazier people. Or maybe it's just that I've learned not to read Mets blog comments, and unfollowed some of the ignorant ones on Twitter so that I see it most in my 45 minutes of WFAN a day.

Frayed Knot Jan 18 2012 07:18 AM Re: Victor Martinez - Done for season?

Ceetar wrote: Maybe I don't follow enough Red Sox fans, but are they killing Crawford for waiting? Or they blaming it on out of shape from fried chicken and beer? Are there beat writers tweeting every skeptical medical decision, right or wrong, from the last 6 years? I don't know, I'm just saying that fans who think medical decisions that look so simple to us outsiders aren't, otherwise there'd be not such thing as second opinions, multiple options, or actual malpractice suits. And that those who think those questions are unique to their team's medical staff need to get out a little more. Two years back, the Sox sat Pedroia out from late June until late August claiming he needed rest & rehab but not surgery. He made it back to the lineup, played in two games, then sat out the rest of the year and had the surgery they were trying to avoid.