Master Index of Archived Threads


This Week's Going Nine - On Second Thought

Mark Healey Nov 27 2005 01:24 PM Edited 1 time(s), most recently on Nov 27 2005 02:13 PM

http://www.gothambaseball.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1588 Please, discuss (better?) :-)

DocTee Nov 27 2005 01:30 PM

Damn-- not even a "please" or "fell free to..." tsk tsk

MFS62 Nov 27 2005 03:50 PM

"Yes, we know that this would give the Mets the "worst" defensive left side of the infield in baseball" Heals, are you also trying to tell us that if the Mets acquired Soriano, he would be playing third or short? Please tell us that was errata. Later

Nymr83 Nov 27 2005 04:12 PM

who are "we" and "us"? are you writing this column in conjunction with someone? i HATE when a writer refers to himself in the plural for no reason (though if "we" does mean more than just you then thats fine)

Edgy DC Nov 27 2005 04:49 PM Edited 1 time(s), most recently on Nov 27 2005 05:23 PM

It's a time-honored (thouugh not nymr-honored) journalistic technique, when writing a column with a continuing title. For one, often the research and the writing are being provided by more than one person, for another, it allows the column to be handed off.from one writer to another. It's used often in gossip columns where more than one peep is bouncing around society getting dish, but it's used in sports also, usually for catch-all columns. The Village Voice's Jockbeat column used it, as does Mets by the Numbers. It's less convincing, I'll grant, when the byline is a singlular guy's name, rather than an abstraction like "The Reliable Souce" or "Loose Lips" or a collective like "The Village Voice sports staff." It also works with no byline at all, letting the column's continuing title to serve as the signature.

ScarletKnight41 Nov 27 2005 05:07 PM

Mark - instead of starting a different thread for each week's column, would you consider an All Purpose Going Nine thread? We have similar threads for Patchy Fogg's shows and for FAFIF, and they have been working out very well. Thanks :)

Yancy Street Gang Nov 27 2005 05:14 PM

My impression has always been that it's the "royal we" and I don't really care for it either, although I use it myself!

Mark Healey Nov 28 2005 03:43 PM

MFS62 wrote: "Yes, we know that this would give the Mets the "worst" defensive left side of the infield in baseball" Heals, are you also trying to tell us that if the Mets acquired Soriano, he would be playing third or short? Please tell us that was errata. Later It was, and it has been fixed. Thanks.

Mark Healey Nov 28 2005 03:44 PM

ScarletKnight41 wrote: Mark - instead of starting a different thread for each week's column, would you consider an All Purpose Going Nine thread? We have similar threads for Patchy Fogg's shows and for FAFIF, and they have been working out very well. Thanks :) If that's what you guys would prefer, sure.

Edgy DC Nov 28 2005 03:55 PM

The All-Purpose Thread Mafia would like to announce the addition of ScarletKnight to our ranks. Scarlet has a long track record of rule enforcement and command over a staff of shin-kicking minions. A press conference is scheduled for 1:00 tomorrow. Though it's after lunch, we ask that the press corps arrive without food stains.

seawolf17 Nov 28 2005 03:59 PM

I hope she doesn't demand my uniform number.

ScarletKnight41 Nov 28 2005 04:02 PM

I did say please, you know....