Master Index of Archived Threads


Small-Time All-Time Catcher

Alomar, Jr.

0 votes

Berra

14 votes

Carter

5 votes

Grote

0 votes

Hundley

0 votes

Lo Duca

0 votes

Stearns

0 votes

Torre

0 votes

Other

0 votes

Edgy MD Jun 18 2012 11:57 AM

Who was the greatest catcher in Major League history to ever don a Mets uniform, without achieving all-time Met status. In other words, greatest catcher in MLB history, who played for the Mets (no matter how well or poorly), not named Piazza.

Edgy MD Jun 18 2012 12:25 PM Re: Small-Time All-Time Catcher

Added Torre. Please vote again, as editing the poll can wipe out the numbers.

LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr Jun 18 2012 02:45 PM Re: Small-Time All-Time Catcher

So we're not going exclusively by Met career/impact here?

Edgy MD Jun 18 2012 03:20 PM Re: Small-Time All-Time Catcher

Absummalutely not.