Master Index of Archived Threads


Small-Time All-Time First Baseman

Donn Clendennon

0 votes

Carlos Delgado

3 votes

Gil Hodges

1 votes

Dave Kingman

1 votes

Eddie Murray

14 votes

Jon Olerud

3 votes

Dick Stuart

0 votes

Mo Vaughn

0 votes

Other

0 votes

Edgy MD Jun 18 2012 12:13 PM

Who was the greatest firstbasmean in Major League history to ever don a Mets uniform, without achieving all-time Met status. In other words, greatest firstbaseman in MLB history, who played for the Mets (no matter how well or poorly), not named Hernandez.

Edgy MD Jun 18 2012 12:13 PM Re: Small-Time All-Time First Baseman

Only Gil Hodges has wieners on his card, so...

seawolf17 Jun 18 2012 12:19 PM Re: Small-Time All-Time First Baseman

Murray. Second-best as a Met was Olerud.

TransMonk Jun 18 2012 01:59 PM Re: Small-Time All-Time First Baseman

seawolf17 wrote: Murray. Second-best as a Met was Olerud. Agreed.

sharpie Jun 18 2012 02:06 PM Re: Small-Time All-Time First Baseman

Dick Stuart not getting a lot of support.

Swan Swan H Jun 18 2012 02:14 PM Re: Small-Time All-Time First Baseman

Not that he'd win, but it's sad that the guy with the most hits in Mets history can't even crack this level of respect.

LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr Jun 18 2012 02:58 PM Re: Small-Time All-Time First Baseman

Longevity be damned-- Oly was a better player at his peak AND he peaked for us.