Master Index of Archived Threads
Rank the 1984 superalbums
John Cougar Lunchbucket Jul 26 2012 08:31 AM |
Put the following albums in order, best to worst. Show your work.
|
Edgy MD Jul 26 2012 08:37 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
All derided by hardcore fans as candy-colored sellouts.
|
Mets – Willets Point Jul 26 2012 08:41 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
|
I'd just copy the good songs from all 3 on to a mixtape.
|
The Second Spitter Jul 26 2012 08:46 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
1. VH: 1984
|
Edgy MD Jul 26 2012 08:50 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Synch actually was 1983, come to think of it.
|
Mets – Willets Point Jul 26 2012 08:53 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
That's it, I'm voting for Sports.
|
Vic Sage Jul 26 2012 08:57 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
lets hear it for the boy!
|
batmagadanleadoff Jul 26 2012 09:04 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
|
I knew that. I'd vote here ... if I actually listened to any of the other two. http://rateyourmusic.com/charts/top/album/1984/
|
TransMonk Jul 26 2012 09:05 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
I think Synchronicity is the best of the bunch. You could feel the tension in this album (mostly between Copeland and Sting) and I think it made the performances better. I have always admired the balls that it took for the Police to go out on top and call it quits after this mega-hit. I don't know if I would say it was their best album, but I think it was their most complete album. It is very atypical for an album to not feature a single on the first side (or within the first couple songs). The first side is very good on it's own...and that's before you flip it over to hear the hit-parade.
|
TransMonk Jul 26 2012 09:08 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
I would also rate Purple Rain right up there with any of these.
|
John Cougar Lunchbucket Jul 26 2012 09:10 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
I'm gonna go.
|
Mets – Willets Point Jul 26 2012 09:19 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
Huey Lewis and the News should have stuck with the theme of naming every album after a section of the newspaper. They could have followed Sports with:
|
TransMonk Jul 26 2012 09:23 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
Like A Virgin should probably get a mention, too.
|
Edgy MD Jul 26 2012 09:23 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
|
I also had that notion for Huey's career. Didn't come up with the obits angle, though. Nice.
Top culprits: Madonna, rap, Reagan, Challenger disaster, Phil Collins, Live Aid, AIDS, drugs, and Howard the Duck. I'm going to guess that the tremendous platform that MTV gave music of that era infest the industry with the petty grievances of countless parasites scrambling to get theirs. I also associate that era with the number of megastars (Cyndi Lauper, ZZ Top, Tears for Fears) who took way too long to follow up and produce inferior albums. The only ones who came out of that period smelling like a rose: .38 Special.
|
metirish Jul 26 2012 09:25 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
I knew coming here I would see a poll regarding Synchronicity , saw on FB you were listening to it on Rdio.
|
soupcan Jul 26 2012 09:33 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
Cyndi Lauper?
|
John Cougar Lunchbucket Jul 26 2012 09:35 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
It was my first listen-through of Synchronicity in a long time and got me thinking of this. I bought the album new like everyone, but distinctly remember after a while only playing side A for "Synchronicity II" which was the last song on it, and not really needing to play Side B since the radio did that for me (Every Breath, King of Pain, Wrapped Around). "Mother" is completely unlistenable, "Oh My God" and "Walking in Your Footsteps" boring. I can see where Sting wanted to go and the playing is very good and economical but it's just never been something demanding a listen all the time.
|
cooby Jul 26 2012 09:38 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
Purple Rain
|
soupcan Jul 26 2012 09:39 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
Yeah, I'm with cooby and Edgy on the 'Purple Rain' grassroots campaign.
|
Mets – Willets Point Jul 26 2012 09:44 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
Out of left field vote for the Fat Boys' debut:
|
Fman99 Jul 26 2012 10:18 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
|
The greatest track in the history of hip hop, right there. Two votes for Kool Rock Ski, Prince Markie Dee and the Human Beat Box.
|
metsguyinmichigan Jul 26 2012 11:01 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
I'd vote:
|
LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr Jul 26 2012 12:12 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
||
I'm LWFS, and I approve this message.
|
HahnSolo Jul 26 2012 02:30 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
And the album that topped both Prince and Springsteen for Album of the Year was?
|
sharpie Jul 26 2012 02:53 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
Prince
|
Vic Sage Jul 26 2012 03:00 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
while i loved the early POLICE albums, Synchronicity was better only than the entirely lame ZENYATTA MANDATTA, maybe tied for 3rd with GHOST IN THE MACHINE, but no higher.
|
Fman99 Jul 26 2012 06:53 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
Fat Boys
|
Kong76 Jul 26 2012 07:10 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
The drumming on Born In always sounded to me like the
|
G-Fafif Jul 27 2012 05:25 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
This conversation in real time, 28 years ago at this moment, would have to have included, given the monstrous commercial implications inherent in its release (commercial letdown notwithstanding)...
|
Edgy MD Jul 27 2012 06:51 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
Victory was a landmark in that regard, in that set-lists from the tour that shared its name included no music from the album, rendiering the LP quite lierally a souvenir.
|
TransMonk Jul 27 2012 07:17 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
|
Vic Sage Jul 27 2012 08:03 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
|
and that's a BAD thing?
|
TransMonk Jul 27 2012 01:19 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
Very much so. I'm guessing even Max Weinberg winces at the sounds (not performances) of the drums on that album.
|
metirish Jul 27 2012 01:25 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
This was decent!
|
Edgy MD Jul 27 2012 01:34 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
|
In a sense, Bruce's "breakup" was more than symbolic, as the next album featured a pared-down version of the E-Street Band --- with none of the tracks featuring all of the players, and in fact only through the intercession of his manager was he dissauded from Tunnel of Love not being an E Street album at all. There's drum machines, synths, no Miami Steve, some chick on vocals, and no saxes. Today, it's not really considered part of the E Street canon.
|
Ashie62 Jul 27 2012 04:50 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
1. Prince Purple Rain
|
Edgy MD Jul 27 2012 08:44 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
Like a Virgin over Let It Be. Rilly?
|
Gwreck Jul 28 2012 07:36 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
|
No offense taken, I'm not putting Bruce in the top spot here myself. My ranking is: 1. Purple Rain 2. Born in the USA 3. Synchronicity 4. 1984
|
Edgy MD Jul 28 2012 09:04 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
[list=1]A Top Ten o' Mine
|
TransMonk Jul 28 2012 09:36 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
1984 was the height of SST Records (IMO) as they released a few classics that year in addition to Zen Arcade:
|
batmagadanleadoff Jul 28 2012 09:43 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
||
Totally agree. Not necessarily sayin' it's the best of '84, but my favorite. Two more good ones from '84 not yet mentioned in this thread:
|
The Second Spitter Jul 28 2012 10:42 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
||
Holy shit. How could I forget about this album? I make love to this album every night. Batmags, I hate to say it, but you have exceeded yourself.
No worries, mate. "I'm on Fire" is still the best song of 1985. Even a future First Lady of the United States of America agrees. (You'll see in 8 years).
|
Ashie62 Jul 28 2012 12:04 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
|
Nice call on Husker Du...I had Madonna on my list because I had a girlfriend at the time who made it very very special for me...
|
Frayed Knot Jul 28 2012 04:07 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
|
My memory of 1984 is as the year that rock radio fully slid into the singles oriented format that they were originally created to combat. And, I know that there are some who'll claim that TRUE free-format radio really only existed for about a year and a half or so and was pretty much dead soon after Woodstock (or even before) but there remained for a number of years some degree of autonomy within stations to play what their people thought was best without the constraints of market surveys and focus groups. But specifically I was listening to one DJ on WNEW (forget which one at this point) several months after the release of the Born in the USA as he was discussing one of the deeper cuts from that album (IOW, not Dancing in the Dark or the title track) and he was saying (paraphrasing): you know how when an album first comes out and you sort of dismiss some cuts as just filler - but then after a while some of those songs you've been ignoring start to grow on you? Well that's what happened to me with _______. I didn't really pay much attention to it at first but now blah, blah, blah ... at which point he proceeded to play the cut. What I realized fairly quickly - like after hearing that very song 3 or 4 more times later that day and another dozen or so before the week was out - was that his "decision" to play the song wasn't at all due to some 'hearing it again for the first time' moment but rather because it had just been released as a single and that the decision to play or not play songs was no longer in the hands of the disc jockeys despite his intro speech intended to maintain that fiction. The song was now part of the official rotation because the record company had designated it as a single and because the radio station was creating their ever-stricter play list based on those actions. Rock radio was never quite the same after that and maybe the reason the three 'super' albums that started this poll were so highly touted at the time was because of their ability to deliver hits singles over the likes of Prince or The Replacements who were never going to be as hit-friendly. Plus I blame MTV. I always blame MTV.
|
Edgy MD Jul 28 2012 05:00 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
Hey man, I had Stop Makin' at number twelve. My friend had a busted up Toyota called "Swamp," because "What's that? Who's drivin'. Where we goin'? Nobody knows." But we knew we were going to Slipped Disc in Valley Stream to get Stop Makin' the day it came out.
|
Mets – Willets Point Jul 28 2012 05:31 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
All right, you didn't have to spew vomit over Huey Lewis and the News. It was a joke based on the list in the previous post showing Sports the number one album for just one week amidst all these multi-month behemoths.
|
Edgy MD Jul 28 2012 05:37 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
It's not like he can now un-vomit.
|
metsguyinmichigan Jul 29 2012 09:42 PM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
Like a Virgin is actually a really good album.
|
HahnSolo Aug 17 2012 07:11 AM Re: Rank the 1984 superalbums |
|
This got heavy, heavy, heavy rotation on the Solo turntable and cassette players. And still on my iPod. Saw him live twice in support of this album.
|