Master Index of Archived Threads


2012 Report Cards

MFS62 Oct 04 2012 10:15 AM

While the memory is still fresh, rate 'em. Dickey Niese Santana Young Gee Heffner Harvey Batista Pelfrey Mejia McHugh E. Ramirez Familia Parnell Hampson R. Ramirez Edgin Acosta Carson Rauch Francisco Byrdak Thole Davis Murphy Tejada Wright Bay Torres Duda Hairston Nieuwenhuis Baxter Valdespin Cedeno Turner Nickeas Shoppach Quintanilla Johnson Rottino Lewis Lutz Satin Later

seawolf17 Oct 04 2012 10:36 AM Re: 2012 Report Cards

Purely on gut. Dickey A Niese B Santana A- Young C Gee C Hefner C Harvey B Batista D Pelfrey C Mejia D McHugh C E. Ramirez C Familia C Parnell B Hampson D R. Ramirez D Edgin B- Acosta C Carson B- Rauch B Francisco B- Byrdak B- plus you forgot: Schwinden D Beato D Carrasco D Egbert D Olson D Thole C+ Davis B Murphy B Tejada B+ Wright A- Bay F- Torres D Duda C+ Hairston B+ Nieuwenhuis B Baxter C+ Valdespin C+ Cedeno C Turner C Nickeas D Shoppach D Quintanilla C Johnson D Rottino D Lewis D Lutz D Satin D

Ashie62 Oct 04 2012 10:43 AM Re: 2012 Report Cards Edited 1 time(s), most recently on Oct 04 2012 10:44 AM

Dickey A Niese A Santana B Young A Gee B Heffner D- Harvey A Batista F Pelfrey F Mejia INC McHugh F E. Ramirez B Familia INC Parnell B+ Hampson INC R. Ramirez F Edgin C+ Acosta F Carson C+ Rauch D Francisco B Byrdak B Thole F Davis B Murphy A Tejada B Wright B+ Bay F Torres F Duda C Hairston A Nieuwenhuis C Baxter C+ Valdespin C Cedeno F Turner F Nickeas D Shoppach D Quintanilla C Johnson C Rottino C Lewis F Lutz F Satin F

Benjamin Grimm Oct 04 2012 10:44 AM Re: 2012 Report Cards

The Daily News has its annual Keep Him or Dump Him survey.

metirish Oct 04 2012 10:44 AM Re: 2012 Report Cards

MFS62 wrote: While the memory is still fresh, rate 'em. Dickey - A Niese - B - but honestly I can't remember one game he pitched in...... Santana - A obviously he's not an A but that Friday night was the highlight of my Mets fandom right there Young - C Gee - D Heffner - D Harvey - C Batista - F Pelfrey - F Mejia - P for promise McHugh - P for promise - grade B twitter though E. Ramirez - No idea Familia - P for Promise Parnell - C Hampson - No idea who he was until the other night R. Ramirez - F Edgin - D Acosta - F Carson - W for who Rauch - a solid B Francisco - F Byrdak - D Thole - F Davis - C+ Murphy - C Tejada - B Wright - B+ Bay - F for fuck off Torres - B for bleh Duda - D Hairston - B Nieuwenhuis - F Baxter - D Valdespin - C Cedeno - D Turner - D Nickeas - D Shoppach - D Quintanilla - D Johnson - F Rottino - F Lewis - F Lutz - F Satin - F Later

bmfc1 Oct 04 2012 11:17 AM Re: 2012 Report Cards

Dickey A Niese B Santana B Young D Gee C Hefner F Harvey B Batista F Pelfrey F Mejia INC McHugh INC E. Ramirez C Familia INC Parnell C Hampson C R. Ramirez F Edgin B Acosta D Carson C Rauch C Francisco D Byrdak D Thole F Davis B Murphy C Tejada B Wright B Bay F Torres D Duda D Hairston A Nieuwenhuis C Baxter A Valdespin C Cedeno C Turner D Nickeas F Shoppach C Quintanilla C Johnson F Rottino D Lewis F Lutz F Satin F

Ashie62 Oct 04 2012 11:19 AM Re: 2012 Report Cards

Benjamin Grimm wrote: The Daily News has its annual Keep Him or Dump Him survey. Hilarious...9% to keep Bay 8 for Torres and 12% to keep Fred W.

Vic Sage Oct 04 2012 11:24 AM Re: 2012 Report Cards Edited 2 time(s), most recently on Oct 04 2012 11:37 AM

PITCHERS = 15 [u:34dotrnc]starters:[/u:34dotrnc] Dickey - A Niese - B+ Harvey - B+ Young - C Gee - C Santana - C- Heffner - D Batista - F [u:34dotrnc]relievers:[/u:34dotrnc] Parnell - B Rauch - C+ Byrdak - C- R. Ramirez - C- Edgin - C- Francisco - D Acosta - F [u:34dotrnc]"Incomplete":[/u:34dotrnc] Pelfrey Schwinden Mejia McHugh Familia E. Ramirez Hampson Carson Beato Carrasco Egbert G.Olson PLAYERS = 15 [u:34dotrnc]starters:[/u:34dotrnc] Wright - A Davis - B- Murphy - C+ Tejada - C Duda - C- Torres - D Thole - F Bay - F [u:34dotrnc]Bench:[/u:34dotrnc] Hairston - B+ Baxter - B Cedeno - C+ Valdespin -C Turner - C Nieuwenhuis - C- Nickeas - F [u:34dotrnc]Incomplete:[/u:34dotrnc] Shoppach Quintanilla Johnson Rottino Lewis Lutz Satin

Chad Ochoseis Oct 04 2012 11:29 AM Re: 2012 Report Cards

I don't get the Pelfrey hate. In 2012, he pitched one decent game and two great games. Then he got hurt. Why all the Fs?

Vic Sage Oct 04 2012 11:34 AM Re: 2012 Report Cards

I agree; i didn't think he pitched enough to get anything other than an "incomplete", but if you were going to give him an actual grade on his 3 starts and 20 IP, then it would be around a B, based on his results. The F seems to blame him for getting injured AND the poor results from an assortment of incompetent starters trying to fill his slot (schwinden, Batista, Heffner, McHugh, etc). Or its just a hangover from past hate.

metirish Oct 04 2012 11:42 AM Re: 2012 Report Cards

Chad Ochoseis wrote: I don't get the Pelfrey hate. In 2012, he pitched one decent game and two great games. Then he got hurt. Why all the Fs? well, it's based on initial memory, to me that's not bothering going back to look at the stats.....

Ceetar Oct 04 2012 11:46 AM Re: 2012 Report Cards

Dickey - A+ Niese - A Santana - B- Young - C Gee - B Heffner - B Harvey - B Batista - D+ Pelfrey - I Mejia - I McHugh - D E. Ramirez - D Familia - I Parnell - A- Hampson - I R. Ramirez - D+ Edgin - D+ Acosta - F- Carson - I Rauch - B+ Francisco - D Byrdak - B+ Thole - D+ Davis - B- Murphy - B- Tejada - C Wright - A- Bay - F- Torres - C Duda - C Hairston - A- Nieuwenhuis - B Baxter - B+ Valdespin - D+ Cedeno - B+ Turner - B Nickeas - F Shoppach - D Quintanilla - C+ Johnson - F Rottino - I Lewis - I Lutz - I Satin - I

MFS62 Oct 04 2012 01:29 PM Re: 2012 Report Cards

The rating scale I used was: E = exceeded my expectations for them this season, M= met them, D= did not meet. Dickey E Niese E Santana E (couldn't expect too much after his surgery) Young M Gee M Heffner M Harvey M Batista D Pelfrey D Mejia M McHugh M E. Ramirez M Familia M Parnell M Hampson M R. Ramirez D Edgin E Acosta D Carson M Rauch M Francisco D Byrdak M Thole D Davis E (His debilitating illness set my expectations very low) Murphy E (Mainly because of his improvement on defense) Tejada M Wright M Bay D Torres M Duda D Hairston E Nieuwenhuis D Baxter M Valdespin M Cedeno E Turner D Nickeas D Shoppach D Quintanilla E Johnson D Rottino M Lewis M Lutz D Satin D Later