Master Index of Archived Threads
Elimination Round: 'For No One' v. 'One on One'
We have to ask:
| "For No One' -- Beatles | 11 votes |
| 'One on One' -- Hall and Oates | 2 votes |
| Johnny Dickshot Dec 18 2005 10:40 PM |
|
That's Beatles v. Hall & Oates
|
| Edgy DC Dec 18 2005 10:44 PM |
|
I'm a fan of "One on One," but it is a cliche-ridden mass of mixed metaphors, lyrically. It was a good vehicle for what Darryl Hall does best.
|
| sharpie Dec 19 2005 08:49 AM |
|
I voted "For No One" as I can't vote for a H&O tune under almost any circumstances but I still think it's not really a "one" song.
|
| mlbaseballtalk Dec 19 2005 10:09 PM |
|
Plus "Cry for no one/A love that should have lasted years" can be put into several different Met contexts
|
| Rockin' Doc Dec 19 2005 10:32 PM |
|
Hall and Oates taking another vicious beat down. Mercifully for them, there is no third round match up in their future.
|
| Johnny Dickshot Dec 19 2005 11:07 PM |
|
Hall & Oates is out. Although I haven't added up all the scores yet, 2-20 is going to be tough to do worse than.
|