Master Index of Archived Threads
The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy"
batmagadanleadoff Aug 30 2013 08:50 AM |
|
Mets great Tom Seaver reacts to Matt Harvey's injury by saying today's pitchers are being babied
http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/baseb ... -1.1441192
|
Benjamin Grimm Aug 30 2013 09:06 AM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" |
He sounds like a grumpy old man, but I agree with him.
|
seawolf17 Aug 30 2013 09:25 AM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" |
|
Completely. The problem is that when managers/organizations try to do this, pitchers get hurt anyway, and then managers get blamed (See "Baker, Dusty"). We've gone too far and there's no "right" way to do it any more.
|
metsguyinmichigan Aug 30 2013 09:27 AM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" |
Tom -- bowing my head reverently -- lists the great Hall of Fame pitchers from the 1960s and 1970s, but what we don't know are if there are other pitchers who would have joined that group had they been "babied" and not been injured in the pre-Tommy John era.
|
Ceetar Aug 30 2013 09:38 AM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" |
Those guys are Hall of Famers in part because they're lucky/exceptions to the rule. Not the other way around.
|
Zvon Aug 30 2013 12:30 PM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" |
I think the problems of todays pitchers can also be attributed to the restrictions put on kids as they play the game growing up. Used to be you'd pitch until you couldn't and those that still could ended up with pretty strong arms. Now there are 12 yr old kids on pitch counts. Now I'm not saying thats a bad thing. But you could say they are being babied at every level. And it most certainly could be a factor in the conditioning of todays pitchers.
|
metsmarathon Aug 30 2013 12:34 PM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" |
well, i htink one of hte things that's indirectly captured in citing hte hall of famers is that, if you do let your pitchers just pitch and throw 300 innings a year, you'll end up getting a hell of a lot more value out of hte healthy ones than you would if you limited them, and would get seemingly no benefit from limiting them. and, for those pitchers who would break down anyways, you'd still get no benefit from limiting them. and then there's the argument that limiting them is damaging them moreso than unlimiting them, and that by unlimiting your pitchers you would be encouraging them to have better mechanics and perhaps be better pitchers instead of just harder throwers, and you'd see benefit there as well.
|
metsmarathon Aug 30 2013 12:41 PM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" |
i tend to think that you need to treat starting pitches like you would distance runners (and perhaps relievers/closers as sprinters).
|
Frayed Knot Aug 30 2013 12:49 PM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" Edited 1 time(s), most recently on Aug 30 2013 01:04 PM |
|
I notice he leaves out Koufax, who threw his last pitch at age 30, and Drysdale who was 31, just to name a few who don't fit in that preconceived box. Also Marichal, cited in the 'tough guy' list above, was effectively finished as a top pitcher by age 33. Doesn't mean Tom (and others) aren't right about certain things in this no-easy-answers topic. But the use of selective evidence to prove the point is maybe more prevalent here than in most other arguments. Oh, and how did Gary Gentry's career pan out?
|
Ceetar Aug 30 2013 01:04 PM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" |
|
or weight lifting maybe. I agree. I don't know that they aren't doing this though, i'm no expert. I know from my experiences with exercising that some days your muscles hurt more or strain more easily. One day is not the same as the next. Will a pitcher only throw 80 pitches on a day he can feel his body straining? or will he muscle through it to damaging results? And the days his muscles are loose and warm and he can throw 130 with ease...will he? They talk about watching a guy for changes in mechanics, but do they really? tight 6th inning one run game runner on second, 1 out, guys tiring and ends up altering his mechanics slightly for 10-15 pitches to get out of it..a pitching coach is really going to go out there and make him change? Or are they going out there to give him a breather, hoping that'll get his arm back where it belongs and going back to the dugout praying he doesn't twist his wrist a little toooo much while tired?
|
Frayed Knot Aug 30 2013 01:06 PM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" |
The funniest statement from the whole article may be Seaver saying: "There’s just too much damn money in the game now."
|
Edgy MD Aug 30 2013 02:27 PM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" |
My dad just threw my brothers and me in the ocean to teach me to swim. He also never gave shit if I buckled my seatbelt. Secondhand smoke? He sucked long drags and then exhaled as he kissed us goodnight. Look at me. I'm fine.
|
LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr Aug 30 2013 04:20 PM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" |
"Hell, it worked for me!"
|
d'Kong76 Aug 30 2013 07:11 PM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" |
Seaver and Namath should go take a soak together.
|
RealityChuck Aug 30 2013 08:09 PM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" |
The truth, as usual, is somewhere in between. There is something to the argument that the more you pitch, the stronger your arm gets, and pitchers are facing fewer batters. It's interesting that last year's leader in batters faced, Justin Verlander, wouldn't have made the top ten in 1969. (Seaver didn't even make the top ten that year and he still faced more batters than Verlander last year).
|
Frayed Knot Aug 30 2013 08:34 PM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" |
|
That's a big factor which usually goes unmentioned much of the time this topic is brought up. One of the things those pitchers didn't have to contend with was today's 6' 2"/215 lb middle infielders who can take a pitcher out of the park the other way. This isn't to say that yesterday's 5' 10"/170 guys could have been just anyone off the street, but they were often the size of the average guy off the street and the worst they could do to you most of the time was poke a single through a hole. I've heard Seaver himself talk about picking out the batters he could "rest" on while saving his best stuff for the two or three really dangerous hitters in the lineup. Today's pitcher doesn't have that advantage (or at least not as big a one) as very few lineups today are carrying hitters whose only job is to bunt, hit behind the runner, and play defense.
|
Ashie62 Aug 31 2013 09:14 AM Re: The Franchise: "Baby, Baby, Stick Your Head in Gravy" |
Sometimes it just comes down to luck. The human body was not designed for the torque involved in pitching.
|