Forum Home

Master Index of Archived Threads


Band Ladder Challenge: Queen v. Jimi Hendrix Experience

Johnny Dickshot
Feb 08 2006 10:04 AM

LONDON — Laser focused on avoiding a further slide in the All-Time Greatest Band Ladder Challenge, Queen adjusted its lineup for its upcoming tilt with acid-dropping psychedelic guitar genius Jimi Hendrix and his band, the Experience.

“You don’t bring a knife to a gun fight. So we swapped out some of the mellower songs from our repertoire, so as to take on Jimi axe-to-axe,” explained metaphor-mixing Queen guitarist Brian May. “We sat ‘39’ on the bench in favor of the power-hitting ‘Fat-Bottomed Girls,’ and replaced ‘I’m in Love with Car’ with the even more fiery and furious ‘Death on Two Legs.’ I think it’s our strongest set yet.”

May admitted his high-flying guitar work lacks the reputation of his dead opponent’s but said he hopes voters come away from the contest with a deeper appreciation for his unique contributions to music that often in this contest has been dismissed as the bombastic ego-trip of ‘mercurial’ lead singer Freddy Mercury. He added that Queen's proficiency in a variety of styles may attract voters against the overwhelmingly blues-based Experience style.

“Sure, we’re over the top, and, as this set shows, we’re still not too proud to take aim at a variety of styles ranging from ballads to disco to opera,” May said. “But without blowing my own horn, of if you will, strumming my own strings, I think I made Queen music worth listening to, and with all due respect to my opponent, we intend to sling him around our back, set him on fire, and smash him to pieces on stage.”

The lineup:

Don't Stop Me Now
Another One Bites the Dust
Bohemian Rhapsody
You're My Best Friend
Under Pressure
Somebody to Love
Fat Bottomed Girls
Death on Two Legs (Dedicated to…)
Keep Yourself Alive
We Will Rock You/We are the Champions

cooby
Feb 08 2006 10:11 AM

Heheh. Cute.



*Disclaimer: The above album was ineligible for this exercise, but the picture of Jimi was just too beautiful to pass up


Ladies and Gentlemen:
Now presenting---Jimi Hendrix and The Experience


Foxy Lady

Purple Haze

Voodoo Child

Are You Experienced?

Hey Joe *

All Along the Watchtower

(Let Me Stand Next to Your) Fire

Sunshine of Your Love

Crosstown Traffic (very 60's, I love it)

If 6 were 9



*Hey Joe is my personal favorite. How cool is this song? Utter perfection

Johnny Dickshot
Feb 08 2006 10:21 AM

Game on.

Don't Stop Me Now v. Foxy Lady

Another One Bites the Dust v. Purple Haze

Bohemian Rhapsody v. Voodoo Child

You're My Best Friend v. Are You Experienced?

Under Pressure v. Hey Joe

Somebody to Love v. All Along the Watchtower

Fat Bottomed Girls v. Let Me Stand Next to Your Fire

Death on Two Legs (Dedicated to…) v. Sunshine of your Love

Keep Yourself Alive v. Crosstown Traffic

We Will Rock You/We are the Champions v. If 6 Were 9

Edgy DC
Feb 08 2006 10:29 AM
Edited 1 time(s), most recently on Feb 08 2006 10:39 AM

"Don't Stop Me Now"vs."Foxy Lady"
"Another One Bites the Dust"vs."Purple Haze"
"Bohemian Rhapsody"vs."Voodoo Chile"
"You're My Best Friend"vs."Are You Experienced?"
"Under Pressure"vs."Hey Joe"
"Somebody to Love"vs."All Along the Watchtower"
"Fat Bottomed Girls"vs."(Let Me Stand Next to Your) Fire"
"Death on Two Legs (Dedicated to…)"vs."Sunshine of Your Love"
"Keep Yourself Alive"vs."Crosstown Traffic"
"We Will Rock You/We are the Champions"vs."If 6 were 9"

seawolf17
Feb 08 2006 10:31 AM

Don't Stop Me Now v. Foxy Lady -- JIMI

Another One Bites the Dust v. Purple Haze -- JIMI

Bohemian Rhapsody v. Voodoo Child -- QUEEN

You're My Best Friend v. Are You Experienced? -- JIMI

Under Pressure v. Hey Joe -- QUEEN

Somebody to Love v. All Along the Watchtower -- QUEEN

Fat Bottomed Girls v. Let Me Stand Next to Your Fire -- QUEEN

Death on Two Legs (Dedicated to…) v. Sunshine of your Love -- JIMI

Keep Yourself Alive v. Crosstown Traffic -- JIMI

We Will Rock You/We are the Champions v. If 6 Were 9

-- QUEEN

Recap: Queen 5, Hendrix 5.
This was a great battle; I think several of these could have gone either way. DIdn't like voting against "Fire," "Bites The Dust," and "Hey Joe." But you gotta do wha tyou gotta do.

Edgy DC
Feb 08 2006 10:31 AM

Question: what album do I find the Experience version of "Sunshine of your Love" on? I think I've seen footage of them performing the song, but I'm not sure what track Coo is referring to.

Willets Point
Feb 08 2006 10:33 AM

Don't Stop Me Now v. Foxy Lady HENDRIX

Another One Bites the Dust v. Purple Haze HENDRIX

Bohemian Rhapsody v. Voodoo Child HENDRIX

You're My Best Friend v. Are You Experienced? HENDRIX

Under Pressure v. Hey Joe QUEEN

Somebody to Love v. All Along the Watchtower HENDRIX

Fat Bottomed Girls v. Let Me Stand Next to Your Fire HENDRIX

Death on Two Legs (Dedicated to…) v. Sunshine of your Love TIE

Keep Yourself Alive v. Crosstown Traffic HENDRIX

We Will Rock You/We are the Champions v. If 6 Were 9 QUEEN

QUEEN 2.5:7.5 JIMI HENDRIX EXPERIENCE

seawolf17
Feb 08 2006 10:34 AM

From Wikipedia:

On 18 February and 24 February 1969 the Experience performed at London's Albert Hall to two sold-out concerts, each attended by 5000 people. A film marketed as the Experience's last performance initially was released as a four-track LP soundtrack featuring the songs "Sunshine of your Love" (Cream), "Room Full of Mirrors", "C Sharp Blues" and "Smashing of Amps". Many varied audio track compilations have later surfaced. These include "Voodoo Child (Slight Return)" and "Little Wing," found on "In the West", as well as "Stone Free" released on "Concerts", all of which were taken from these Albert Hall performances.

cooby
Feb 08 2006 10:35 AM

="Edgy DC"]Question: what album do I find the Experience version of "Sunshine of your Love" on? I think I've seen footage of them performing the song, but I'm not sure what track Coo is referring to.






It's on here, Edgy. I was pleased.

Willets Point
Feb 08 2006 10:44 AM

Those 'fros can barely be contained by the album cover.

metirish
Feb 08 2006 10:53 AM

excellent challenge....

Don't Stop Me Now v. Foxy Lady - Queen

Another One Bites the Dust v. Purple Haze - Hendrix

Bohemian Rhapsody v. Voodoo Child - Queen

You're My Best Friend v. Are You Experienced? - Queen

Under Pressure v. Hey Joe - Hendrix(very close)

Somebody to Love v. All Along the Watchtower - Hendrix

Fat Bottomed Girls v. Let Me Stand Next to Your Fire - Queen

Death on Two Legs (Dedicated to…) v. Sunshine of your Love - Hendrix

Keep Yourself Alive v. Crosstown Traffic - Hendrix

We Will Rock You/We are the Champions v. If 6 Were 9 - Queen


I'm all tied up at 5 each....

Edgy DC
Feb 08 2006 10:54 AM

Edgy favorites not in the Experience lineup: "Little Wing," "Roomful of Mirrors," "May This Be Love."

soupcan
Feb 08 2006 10:57 AM

Don't Stop Me Now v. Foxy Lady - JIMI HENDRIX EXPERIENCE

Another One Bites the Dust v. Purple Haze - JIMI HENDRIX EXPERIENCE

Bohemian Rhapsody v. Voodoo Child - QUEEN

You're My Best Friend v. Are You Experienced? - QUEEN

Under Pressure v. Hey Joe - QUEEN

Somebody to Love v. All Along the Watchtower - JIMI HENDRIX EXPERIENCE

Fat Bottomed Girls v. Let Me Stand Next to Your Fire - JIMI HENDRIX EXPERIENCE

Death on Two Legs (Dedicated to…) v. Sunshine of your Love - JIMI HENDRIX EXPERIENCE

Keep Yourself Alive v. Crosstown Traffic - JIMI HENDRIX EXPERIENCE

We Will Rock You/We are the Champions v. If 6 Were 9 - QUEEN

JIMI HENDRIX EXPERIENCE - 6 / QUEEN - 4

Color me stunned. I like Queen a whole lot and never considered myself a big Jimi fan at all, but how do you vote against the classic tunes that JImi and his pals threw out there?

Tough tilt that very easily could've been a landslide for Hendrix.

Nice work cooby.

sharpie
Feb 08 2006 11:20 AM

Don't Stop Me Now v. Foxy Lady - Jimi

Another One Bites the Dust v. Purple Haze - JImi (close)

Bohemian Rhapsody v. Voodoo Child - Queen

You're My Best Friend v. Are You Experienced? - Jimi

Under Pressure v. Hey Joe - TIE

Somebody to Love v. All Along the Watchtower - Jimi

Fat Bottomed Girls v. Fire - Jimi

Death on Two Legs (Dedicated to…) v. Sunshine of your Love - Jimi

Keep Yourself Alive v. Crosstown Traffic - Jimi

We Will Rock You/We are the Champions v. If 6 Were 9 - Queen

Jimi 7.5, Queen 2.5.

sharpie
Feb 08 2006 11:54 AM

Jimi's covers are great. Hey Joe, Sunshine of Your Love, Like a Rolling Stone and Wild Thing all rule. Bob Dylan has always played All Along the Watchtower a la Jimi as he instantly realized that Jimi's version was better (otherwise he hasn't changed arrangements, never using jangly guitars on Mr. Tambourine Man for instance).

Paul McCartney tells a story of the weekend that "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band" came out, when he went out with some friends to see the Jimi Hendrix Experience at a London club, they opened with the title track which was only a few days old at that time. Apparently a killer version (I've never heard it).

cooby
Feb 08 2006 11:56 AM

Hey Joe is just wonderful

Johnny Dickshot
Feb 08 2006 12:35 PM

Don't Stop Me Now v. Foxy Lady
IMO, hardest decision of the whole contest right here. Jimi.

Another One Bites the Dust v. Purple Haze
A win for Jimi.

Bohemian Rhapsody v. Voodoo Child
Queen.

You're My Best Friend v. Are You Experienced?
Queen.

Under Pressure v. Hey Joe
Second hardest. Queen

Somebody to Love v. All Along the Watchtower
Jimi.

Fat Bottomed Girls v. Let Me Stand Next to Your Fire
Jimi. My favorite, prolly.

Death on Two Legs (Dedicated to…) v. Sunshine of your Love
Queen.

Keep Yourself Alive v. Crosstown Traffic
Jimi.

We Will Rock You/We are the Champions v. If 6 Were 9
Queen.

This is a 5-5 tie. Hated voting in almost every matchup.
_________________

Edgy DC
Feb 08 2006 12:41 PM

A lot of tie-age. I'm holding out until I can find at least a clip from "Death on Two Legs (Dedicated to…)" and "Sunshine of Your Love." I'm unfamiliar with both recordings.

cooby
Feb 08 2006 12:49 PM

See if you can find it on here

http://www.jimi-hendrix.com/

cooby
Feb 08 2006 12:51 PM

cooby wrote:
See if you can find it on here

http://www.jimi-hendrix.com/



It's on the second disc of the BBC album

Edgy DC
Feb 08 2006 12:59 PM

Can't get it to play.

cooby
Feb 08 2006 01:02 PM

I'm sorry :(

I'm pretty sure that is where I heard it last night

cooby
Feb 08 2006 01:39 PM

Queen is a very tough opponent
When I told my husband what I was up to, he said that I should ask our Jimi expert (our son) for advice and I said that if I’m gonna run with the big dogs (Widey), I have to run alone. So I just borrowed his CDs.

Here’s my votes


Don't Stop Me Now v. Foxy Lady JIMI

Another One Bites the Dust v. Purple Haze JIMI

Bohemian Rhapsody v. Voodoo Child TIE

You're My Best Friend v. Are You Experienced? QUEEN

Under Pressure v. Hey Joe JIMI

Somebody to Love v. All Along the Watchtower JIMI

Fat Bottomed Girls v. Let Me Stand Next to Your Fire JIMI

Death on Two Legs (Dedicated to…) v. Sunshine of your Love JIMI

Keep Yourself Alive v. Crosstown Traffic JIMI

We Will Rock You/We are the Champions v. If 6 Were 9 QUEEN

Jimi 7.5 Queen 2.5

Johnny Dickshot
Feb 08 2006 01:42 PM

'Death on Two Legs' is a put-down song just as vicious as Positively 4th Street -- positively.

If you can find a sample (iTunes, or Amazon -- first track on NIGHT AT OPERA lp) try to hear the intro where May's guitar just SCREAMS. Evidently, the unnamed dedication is to a biz manager who screwed them out of some $$$.

Here are the lyrix:

]You suck my blood like a leech
You break the law and you preach
Screw my brain till it hurts
You've taken all my money - and you want more

Misguided old mule
With your pigheaded rules
With your narrow-minded cronies who are fools
Of the first division

Death on two legs
You're tearing me apart
Death on two legs
You never had a heart of your own

Kill joy, bad guy
Big talking, small fry
You're just an old barrow-boy
Have you found a new toy to replace me
Can you face me

But now you can kiss my ass goodbye

Feel good, are you satisfied ?
Do you feel like suicide (I think you should)
Is your conscience all right
Does it plague you at night
Do you feel good - feel good

Aah
Talk like a big business tycoon
But you're just a hot-air balloon
So no one gives you a damn
You're just an overgrown school-boy
Let me tan your hide

A dog with disease
You're the king of the 'sleaze'
Put your money where your mouth is Mr. know all
Was the fin on your back part of the deal...(a shark!)

Death on two legs
Tearing me apart
Death on two legs
You've never had a heart of your own
(You never did, right from the start)

Insane, you should be put inside
You're a sewer-rat decaying in a cesspool of pride
Should be made unemployed
Make yourself null-and-void
Make me feel good
I feel good

Edgy DC
Feb 08 2006 01:50 PM

There was actually a Queen song that encouraged suicide?

Johnny Dickshot
Feb 08 2006 03:48 PM

Queen's later hit "Bicycle Race" would rip this song off in some ways.

Edgy DC
Feb 09 2006 12:19 AM

I'm kissing my sister a lot in this one.

"Don't Stop Me Now" vs. "Foxy Lady"

Tie. 1/2-1/2.

=indigo]"Another One Bites the Dust" vs. "Purple Haze"

Queen. 1 1/2-1/2.

=darkred]"Bohemian Rhapsody" vs. "Voodoo Chile"

Tie. 2-1.

=olive]"You're My Best Friend" vs. "Are You Experienced?"

Queen. 3-1.

=red]"Under Pressure" vs. "Hey Joe"

Queen. 4-1.
=cyan]
"Somebody to Love" vs. "All Along the Watchtower"

JHE. 4-2.

=orange]"Fat Bottomed Girls" vs. "(Let Me Stand Next to Your) Fire"

JHE. 4-3.
=darkblue]
"Death on Two Legs (Dedicated to…)" vs. "Sunshine of Your Love"

JHE (rocks more than the original, and the Experience seem to hold it toghether). 4-4.

=brown]"Keep Yourself Alive" vs. "Crosstown Traffic"

JHE. 4-5.

=green]"We Will Rock You/We are the Champions" vs. "If 6 were 9"

Queen. 5-5.

Find a more complete clip of "Death on Two Legs," and I might change my vote. "Sunshine..." is only 1:17, for Pete's sake.

Johnny Dickshot
Feb 09 2006 07:12 AM

JHE leads 48.5-31.5. Queen will have to run the table on the next few votes, but haven't done better than .500 in any.

soupcan
Feb 09 2006 09:53 AM

Downloaded 'Death on Two Legs' last night.

Eh.

cooby
Feb 09 2006 10:21 AM

Johnny, I have to admit I'm not a big "All Along the Watchtower" fan, and that is one of the Jimi songs I thought in advance that I might not vote for, but the breathy singing in "Somebody to Love" just always annoyed me so I had no choice but to vote "Watchtower".

RealityChuck
Feb 09 2006 10:55 AM

Nice matchup.

Don't Stop Me Now v. Foxy Lady -- Hendrix
Another One Bites the Dust v. Purple Haze -- Hendrix
Bohemian Rhapsody v. Voodoo Child -- Queen
You're My Best Friend v. Are You Experienced? -- Queen (by a hair)
Under Pressure v. Hey Joe -- Hendrix
Somebody to Love v. All Along the Watchtower -- Hendrix
Fat Bottomed Girls v. Let Me Stand Next to Your Fire -- Hendrix
Death on Two Legs (Dedicated to…) v. Sunshine of your Love -- Queen
Keep Yourself Alive v. Crosstown Traffic -- Hendrix
We Will Rock You/We are the Champions v. If 6 Were 9 -- Queen

Johnny Dickshot
Feb 10 2006 06:54 PM

="Johnny Dickshot"]JHE leads 48.5-31.5. Queen will have to run the table on the next few votes, but haven't done better than .500 in any.


Let's call this a final: Jimi Hendrix 54.5, Queen 35.5

Lock this baby up

soupcan
Feb 11 2006 11:25 PM

So I was doing a little Googlin' on Jimi and his Experience and I found this little nugget of info:

]The Experience's last album, Electric Ladyland (Reprise 2 RS 6307), was released in the U.S. in October 1968. The front cover has a beautiful photo of Jimi, but it is the cover released in England that received the most attention. The two disq set featured a gatefold cover photo of about 20 naked women. There was an immediate and (I'm sure not unexpected) negative response from the retailers, but what's worse is that the photo makes them all appear less attractive than was intended.


The British version is easy enough to find, just do a Google image search for 'Electric Ladyland' and there she is, or rather, there 'they' are. I would've posted the image myself but it is a tad risque.

Interesting because the sanitized, American version (below) is thought of as a somewhat classic album cover.



Is this news to anybody or is it well-documented and I'm the last know?

cooby
Feb 11 2006 11:32 PM

So that's what the album name means...

Actually there seem to be several different ones

soupcan
Feb 11 2006 11:34 PM

No, theres a front and a back - one big picture folded into two.

cooby
Feb 11 2006 11:39 PM

I think you're full of beans, it looks like three different ones. Maybe somebody else made their own version and that's what I"m seeing

soupcan
Feb 11 2006 11:41 PM

I'm talking only about the nekkid ladies.

That's all I'm interested in.

cooby
Feb 11 2006 11:41 PM

I'm sure...

soupcan
Feb 11 2006 11:49 PM

To: The Powers That Be

Delete if you must, but my pride neccesitated this response:



Apologies.

-soupcan

metirish
Feb 11 2006 11:59 PM

Damn, can you say "find me an image of"?, this should not be deleted, a classic back cover.

Rockin' Doc
Feb 12 2006 02:30 PM

cooby (in response to Soupcan) - "I think you're full of beans..."


No, that's his cousin. Now he's full of beans.

cooby
Feb 17 2006 05:46 PM

heh, just saw this...