Master Index of Archived Threads


Set the World Series Rotation

Game 1: deGrom, Game 2: Harvey, Game 3: Syndegaard

10 votes

Game 1: deGrom, Game 2: Syndegaard, Game 3: Harvey

9 votes

Game 1: Harvey, Game 2: deGrom, Game 3: Syndegaard

2 votes

Game 1: Harvey, Game 2: Syndegaard, Game 3: deGrom

7 votes

Game 1: Syndegaard, Game 2: deGrom, Game 3: Harvey

0 votes

Game 1: Syndegaard, Game 2: Harvey, Game 3: deGrom

0 votes

Elster88 Oct 21 2015 09:47 PM

Game 1 is Tuesday so everything is open.

Gwreck Oct 21 2015 10:09 PM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

Don't mess with what works. Harvey, Syndergaard, deGrom, Matz. I want deGrom going if we have a game 7.

Nymr83 Oct 21 2015 10:39 PM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

Gwreck wrote: Don't mess with what works. Harvey, Syndergaard, deGrom, Matz. I want deGrom going if we have a game 7. yeah, me too, as in games 1, 4, and 7. But really, iwould go Degrom, Syndergaard, Harvey, Matz

Benjamin Grimm Oct 22 2015 06:30 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

I voted deGrom, Syndergaard, Harvey. Sure, deGrom is the ideal Game 7 pitcher, but I'd rather have him get his second start sooner than that, in the hope of making a Game 7 unnecessary. So I'd have those three guys pitch games 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, and 7. I'm starting to have my doubts about Matz in Game 4. (Unless the Mets win the first three games. There's precedent for that!) I don't doubt Matz's talent, or his future potential, but I'm not all that certain about his present. Maybe Colon would be a better choice for Game 4.

Farmer Ted Oct 22 2015 06:53 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

With the added rest, I'd go with Harvey first. Hold Thor until the first home game given his history of HAMMER TIME at Citi.

themetfairy Oct 22 2015 07:10 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

It's easier to go from Matz to Colon in Game 4 than from Colon to Matz. If Matz is in trouble, Colon is less likely to get ruffled. But I don't like the idea of putting the rookie into a pressure situation in the World Series if Colon gets into trouble.

Ceetar Oct 22 2015 07:24 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

deGrom, Thor, Harvey. or maybe deGrom, Harvey, Thor. Wait and see what the series is at before deciding on deGrom short or Matz.

MFS62 Oct 22 2015 07:37 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

I picked option #1 because I still prefer Noah pitching at Citi than on the road. Later

John Cougar Lunchbucket Oct 22 2015 07:41 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

None of us have the information we need to really make this decision wrt health, not to mention the opponent yet. My choice is what Terry says.

LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr Oct 22 2015 07:46 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

MFS62 wrote: I picked option #1 because I still prefer Noah pitching at Citi than on the road. Well, yeah, that's just, like, your opinion, man. (Again, most EVERYONE pitches better at home, including deGrom and Harvey.) Give me deGrom, Harvey, Syndergaard. Or Harvey, Thor, Dutch. Or Noah, Dutch, Jake would be Jake. Honestly... I trust deGrom just a little bit more, but the order is almost immaterial to me.

MFS62 Oct 22 2015 08:11 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr wrote: MFS62 wrote: I picked option #1 because I still prefer Noah pitching at Citi than on the road. Well, yeah, that's just, like, your opinion, man. Isn't that the objective/ purpose of a poll? To get our opinions? Later

Lefty Specialist Oct 22 2015 08:22 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

DeGrom, Syndergaard, Harvey, pitching 1-2-3 then 5-6-7 (*if needed). Matz on a short leash in Game 4, with The Fat Man on call. Done. We have such an embarrassment of pitching riches that there's no need for anyone to pitch games 1, 4 and 7. And if Harvey gets in trouble in a potential Game 7, you have deGrom out of the bullpen for an inning or two.

batmagadanleadoff Oct 22 2015 08:26 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr wrote: MFS62 wrote: I picked option #1 because I still prefer Noah pitching at Citi than on the road. Well, yeah, that's just, like, your opinion, man. (Again, most EVERYONE pitches better at home, including deGrom and Harvey.) Give me deGrom, Harvey, Syndergaard. Or Harvey, Thor, Dutch. Or Noah, Dutch, Jake would be Jake. Honestly... I trust deGrom just a little bit more, but the order is almost immaterial to me. Same exact here. I have no preference and can't decide anyways.

Farmer Ted Oct 22 2015 09:10 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

My friend, a Cubs fan, texted me earlier today. "You have three guys better than Arrieta. The other is better than Lester." BOOM

Fman99 Oct 22 2015 10:19 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

Do what worked against the Cubs. Harvey and Syndergard on the road, deGrom/Matz at home, Colon at the ready.

Centerfield Oct 22 2015 10:30 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

You know those fantasy lineups where you say I'd start '85 Gooden, followed by '69 Seaver? '15 deGrom '15 Syndegaard '15 Harvey '15 Matz

dinosaur jesus Oct 22 2015 10:42 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

Lefty Specialist wrote: We have such an embarrassment of pitching riches that there's no need for anyone to pitch games 1, 4 and 7. Would there be a tee, or would the Royals/Blue Jays toss the ball up and hit it?

Gwreck Oct 23 2015 08:52 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

Buster Olney reporting it will be: deGrom, Syndergaard, Harvey, Matz (in that order)

Benjamin Grimm Oct 23 2015 08:54 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

I approve of that.

El Segundo Escupidor Oct 23 2015 09:07 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

So Harvey is your Game 7 starter? Also 12 days between starts. Not down with that.

Benjamin Grimm Oct 23 2015 09:13 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

DeGrom should be able to pitch a bit in Game 7 on two days rest, if needed. I prefer to see Jacob get his two starts before Game 7 in the hope that the Mets can wrap it up before that 7th game is needed.

El Segundo Escupidor Oct 23 2015 09:15 AM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

Benjamin Grimm wrote: DeGrom should be able to pitch a bit in Game 7 on two days rest, if needed. I prefer to see Jacob get his two starts before Game 7 in the hope that the Mets can wrap it up before that 7th game is needed. Yeah, i deleted that part before you posted.

Benjamin Grimm Oct 23 2015 03:17 PM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

Mike Puma reporting in the Post that it may be Harvey-deGrom-Syndergaard in the first three games, in order to give deGrom an extra day of rest. Mets may push tired deGrom to Game 2, go Harvey in Game 1

Benjamin Grimm Oct 24 2015 03:53 PM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

Word is that it will be Harvey in Game 1, followed by deGrom, Syndergaard, Matz.

Zvon Oct 24 2015 04:06 PM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

Centerfield wrote: You know those fantasy lineups where you say I'd start '85 Gooden, followed by '69 Seaver? '15 deGrom '15 Syndegaard '15 Harvey '15 Matz boc

MFS62 Oct 24 2015 09:18 PM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr wrote: MFS62 wrote: I picked option #1 because I still prefer Noah pitching at Citi than on the road. Well, yeah, that's just, like, your opinion, man. (Again, most EVERYONE pitches better at home, including deGrom and Harvey.) Well, now its, like, Terry's opinion. He has Noah scheduled for game 3, too. Later

Benjamin Grimm Oct 25 2015 12:08 PM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

Just to ponder some possibilities... The weather forecast for Kansas City for Tuesday includes showers. If there's a rainout, then I imagine we'd lose the travel day, playing games 1 and 2 on Wednesday and Thursday and then to Citi Field on Friday. What would that mean for Game 5, then? Harvey on three days rest? Or a start for Colon or Niese instead?

El Segundo Escupidor Oct 25 2015 01:37 PM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

Benjamin Grimm wrote: Just to ponder some possibilities... The weather forecast for Kansas City for Tuesday includes showers. If there's a rainout, then I imagine we'd lose the travel day, playing games 1 and 2 on Wednesday and Thursday and then to Citi Field on Friday. What would that mean for Game 5, then? Harvey on three days rest? Or a start for Colon or Niese instead? Are the rules for rainouts the same in the playoffs or did they change since the 2008 WS?

Frayed Knot Oct 25 2015 01:43 PM Re: Set the World Series Rotation

The only rain rules that are different in the post-season is that all interrupted games will be played to a full game conclusion, whether later that same day or at the next possible opportunity. No shortened 'official game' results are allowed.