Master Index of Archived Threads
Supermarket Maven Speaks
G-Fafif Dec 09 2015 10:58 PM |
|
Mrs. FAFIF brought to my attention JCL's inclusion in this Grub Street (NY Mag) piece on high-end grocery shoplifting.
Gives good quote!
|
Fman99 Dec 10 2015 05:20 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
d'Kong76 Dec 10 2015 08:18 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
The Shop-Rite by where we used to live had a full-time security guy posing as a 'stock boy.' He walked around the store with his pony tail flapping, donned an apron and blended in well. I saw him bust someone who had a big pack of Duracell's under his coat and said something to him next time I saw him. He said people don't realize how much stuff disappears off of supermarket shelves and they catch people all the time.
|
Ceetar Dec 10 2015 08:51 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
||
How much by stockers who are like 'oops, only 49 of 50 of these cartons of milk made it onto the shelf'!
|
d'Kong76 Dec 10 2015 09:36 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
I don't know, but my guess is that employee theft is not a big thing
|
Ceetar Dec 10 2015 09:59 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
Maybe not. Seems like it would be fairly easy for a box of cereal to fall off a pallet while unloading the truck. Anyway, I've always wondered if theft is really that big a deal considering how we're moving to self-checkouts more often. Hell, I walk into the store grab a scanner, pack my bags in the aisles and simply scan the scanner at the register and walk out. I generally stack 30 cans of cat food on a shelf to scan one by one, but how would anyone know if I only got 28 of 'em?
|
John Cougar Lunchbucket Dec 10 2015 10:07 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
That story (which the writer says was originally pitched to, but rejected by, the Times) is getting a lot of attention. Last night the Fox 5 news van came over to interview me for their take on the story, but despite my making it clear to the producer and the reporter beforehand that my expertise is in retail and not shoplifting, got barraged with questions on-camera as to the motivation of shoplifters, for which I had no answers. I think I killed the piece singlehandedly.
|
d'Kong76 Dec 10 2015 10:14 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
Why pay $35 for the good olio oliva when you can steal it is
|
cooby classic Dec 10 2015 10:20 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
I hope you went back :)
|
cooby classic Dec 10 2015 10:21 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
Btw lunchy why is everyone across the street looking away from the camera?
|
John Cougar Lunchbucket Dec 10 2015 10:24 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
Numbers are hard to come by but believed that something like 60% of retail store "shrink" (unaccounted for losses) is believed to come from employees, between merchandise theft by employees and vendors; cashier shenanigans; and mistakes like failing to see that bag of dog food on the bottom rack of the cart.
|
d'Kong76 Dec 10 2015 10:27 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
||
KB did.
Don't pick your nose in Sears is all I can add here.
|
Fman99 Dec 10 2015 10:40 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
I'd show her my lahmers, you can bet that. I'm pitching a "Fort Wadsworth" in my pants right now.
|
Edgy MD Dec 10 2015 10:42 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
Flashing back to losing a job a Borders when I tried to encourage my fellow employees that the store had no right to arbitrarily implement a we-get-to-search-your-bags-when-you-leave policy.
|
d'Kong76 Dec 10 2015 10:49 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
Rousing the rabble were we?
|
Edgy MD Dec 10 2015 11:10 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
I was a union-organizing failure at two straight jobs.
|
LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr Dec 10 2015 11:21 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
I like how the-- superrich, mind you-- Shoplifters Anonymous success story at the end kept the fucking wine. I'm not a big 12-step guy, but isn't making amends sort of a big thing with these guys?
|
Benjamin Grimm Dec 10 2015 01:05 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
Maybe she looks a lot better from the front than she does from the back? I imagine that those self-checkout lanes in supermarket do make it easier to steal and that some people do take advantage of that. But they probably figure that whatever they lose from self-checkout theft costs them less than it would to pay a cashier. Or that if they don't offer it, and another supermarket does, they'll lose some regular customers.
|
Ceetar Dec 10 2015 01:07 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
||
Ha, like they pay cashiers much than junk change.
|
Benjamin Grimm Dec 10 2015 01:16 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
I realize that it wouldn't take too much theft to exceed a cashier's salary, but I also suspect that in an average hour, less than $9 or $10 of self-checkout theft would occur.
|
dgwphotography Dec 10 2015 01:29 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
||
This is where I go an a bit of a rant (again): I refuse - REFUSE - to use those self-checkout lanes. Not only am I costing someone a job, but I am also paying the same amount for less service. Here in CT, gas stations that offer both full and self service charge more for full service. You want me to go through self check out? then give me a discount that is roughly equal to what you would pay a cashier. I'm not filling your coffers any more than I have to.
|
d'Kong76 Dec 10 2015 02:03 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
Eh, I don't check out on principle... I check out on which
|
Benjamin Grimm Dec 10 2015 02:13 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
Yeah, if I only have a few items, I always go to the self-checkout.
|
Ceetar Dec 10 2015 02:14 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
the fewer people involved in my checkout, the better.
|
cooby classic Dec 10 2015 02:15 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
Yeah me too. Makes me mad when it screws up though.
|
John Cougar Lunchbucket Dec 10 2015 02:21 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
There's been studies demonstrating that although shoppers perceive self-checkout is faster, it's not. That's doubly great for retailers because as dwg pointed out, it's primarily a labor-driven innovation.
|
Ceetar Dec 10 2015 02:33 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
I'd suspect those studies. It's at least twice as fast.
|
d'Kong76 Dec 10 2015 02:38 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks Edited 1 time(s), most recently on Dec 10 2015 02:39 PM |
|
When I visit an ATM or self-checkout, it's always faster than studies that demonstrate otherwise. I do prefer humans though. OE: can't flirt with a scanner
|
Benjamin Grimm Dec 10 2015 02:39 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
I think it depends on how many items you have and how long the lines are in the regular checkout lanes.
|
Ceetar Dec 10 2015 02:43 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
It's demonstratively slower in May/June when kids are getting out of school and taking summer jobs and learning the ropes. I think a good rule of thumb is the more people involved, the slower. So if there are 4 people ahead of you in self checkout, but a cashier and three people at the regular line, it's about the same. Shifted in favor of self because you never get people paying with checks that way, and usually less with cash too.
|
themetfairy Dec 10 2015 03:08 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
At BJ's Warehouse we prefer the checkers, but often the lines for the checkers are tremendous and the self-checkout lines are minimal.
|
LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr Dec 10 2015 03:24 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
I mostly shop at fruit stands, farmer's markets, ethnic markets, and Trader Joe's.
|
John Cougar Lunchbucket Dec 10 2015 03:36 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
One company today has installed infrared cameras in its stores that detect when shoppers approach checkout so as to direct the opening of additional checklanes when necessary (and closing them when not). They say it has helped average wait time go from 3+ minutes to 26 seconds.
|
Nymr83 Dec 10 2015 03:55 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
bingo.
|
MFS62 Dec 10 2015 06:33 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
I usually only shop for a few items at a time, so I look and see how the backup on the "10 items or less" line with a real cashier compares to the backup at the self- scan lines.
|
cooby classic Dec 10 2015 07:19 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
That is funny, I have a thing for odd numbers (I am not kidding...)
|
MFS62 Dec 10 2015 07:29 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
How many times did you read my post? Later
|
d'Kong76 Jan 15 2016 12:34 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
Not supermarket, but retail and shopping centers/malls in general... the
|
John Cougar Lunchbucket Jan 15 2016 01:34 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
Not a huge surprise that Sears (poorly run and more or less in the business of selling stores vs. selling stuff) announced closures. Most of the US Walmart closures are sort of experimental small stores that were developed under the previous leadership; the new boss either had to continue to invest in them to make it profitable or drop 'em, and he dropped 'em. The reason you heard so many in recent weeks -- you always do in January. Nobody closes before they squeeze all the sales they can from the holiday season.
|
Ceetar Jan 15 2016 01:39 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
or in September so you can sell to a Spirit Halloween? (That's what the K-Mart did by me)
|
d'Kong76 Jan 15 2016 01:42 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
Seemed like more than usual but maybe I'm just reading business news
|
John Cougar Lunchbucket Jan 15 2016 01:46 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
Well, the Internet is killing lots of department stores so the dealth toll is theoretically rising. Target is closing a bunch of stores too but they announced in December so as to get swallowed up in the Xmas season hype. Macy's. Only about 2/3rd of A&P stores have found new owners.
|
Edgy MD Jan 15 2016 04:15 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
Sears is still the place to get the solid-state small appliances that aren't designed to break in a year and built in a Chinese slave factory.
|
seawolf17 Jan 15 2016 04:53 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
I literally can't imagine a world where Kohl's closes. Feels like the lines are out the wazoo every time I go.
|
d'Kong76 Feb 25 2016 12:13 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
They're closing 18 stores, don't know how big that news is.
|
Lefty Specialist Feb 25 2016 12:50 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
I have a rule. If you're not paying me, I'm not working for you. I never use the self check-out. What will happen is that I'll be waiting on line and the self-checkout lanes are empty. The one person who monitors 4 self-checkouts for the inevitable customer problems comes up to me and the conversation usually goes like this: "Sir, the self-checkout lanes are open with no waiting." "I don't do self-checkout." (Brief second or two of confusion, then the programming kicks in) "Oh, that's okay, I'll do it for you." And he or she does it. I get out quicker and I don't have to do it myself. Works almost every time. Once they've interacted with you they can't just leave you hanging.
|
d'Kong76 Feb 25 2016 12:56 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
"What are you grinning about?"
|
batmagadanleadoff Feb 25 2016 01:01 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks Edited 3 time(s), most recently on Feb 25 2016 01:25 PM |
|
How come supermarket express-line cashiers never enforce the x items or less rule? Drives me fucking nuts. And if you say something to the offending shopper, they always say that they didn't know it's an express line. Even though the sign's four times as big as their head and as bright as a 42nd Street billboard. If it's a married couple, or more than one shopper/person with one larger than express order, they'll break up their order so that each offending shopper now has less than "x" items. But the worst supermarket checkout line scam I ever saw is the one where (usually it's) a married couple gets two wagons --- one spouse has the bulk of the order and the other spouse has like two or three items in his/her wagon. The wagon with the small number of items is nothing more than a pretext to carry out the scam. Then they each get on a different checkout line. When it's clear that one of the two lines they're on is moving much quicker than the other, the shopper on the slower moving line moves to the quicker line, joining his/her other and cutting in front of any shoppers that have since gotten on that line behind the "other". This one doesn't bother me so much when it's the shopper with the two or three item jumping in front of me, but when it's the shopper with like 50 items in the cart jumping in from of me -- well that's a different story.
|
Edgy MD Feb 25 2016 01:09 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
I think that's the main reason people get married.
|
d'Kong76 Feb 25 2016 01:17 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
I think they're told to look the other way and let the other customers do the complaining and don't get involved other than just rolling their eyes at the complainer in a "I know, but douche-bags will be douche-bags fashion..."
|
John Cougar Lunchbucket Feb 25 2016 01:20 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
I'm tellin ya about these heat-seeking cameras. It's the future.
|
batmagadanleadoff Feb 25 2016 01:22 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
||
Yeah ... but why? Sometimes, I'll say something to the cashier instead of to the offending shopper. Not when the shopper exceeds the count by like one or two items, but when it's an egregious abuse -- like a shopper coming on the express line with like 30 or 40 items. This happened this week and so the experience is fresh in my head. I'll tell the cashier -- sarcastically -- why even bother with the x items or less sign? Or ... "hey I guess we're on the honor system here, right?"
|
batmagadanleadoff Feb 25 2016 01:23 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
How are they gonna fix express line abuse?
|
d'Kong76 Feb 25 2016 01:40 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
Don't know for sure, but probably an off-shoot of the customer is always right even when they're wrong philosophy.
|
Ceetar Feb 25 2016 01:47 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
thing is, with a competent cashier and a swift customer (i.e., ready to pay. Credit card.) the number of items is really the smallest time factor. Bonus points if there is a bagger.
|
Lefty Specialist Feb 25 2016 01:51 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
||
Let's just say it's a mistake you'll only make once.
|
themetfairy Feb 25 2016 02:44 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
||
They are indeed told to look the other way. My daughter worked as a cashier at our local supermarket and she was instructed not to confront the douche-bags about it.
|
MFS62 Feb 25 2016 03:00 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
Life is too short to waste a moment of it being delayed by someone who has violated the "X items or less" sign to be ahead of me on a line. If the lines around me are too long to make it worth changing lines, I'll usually turn to the person behind me (who has also obeyed the rules) and say out loud, "too bad some people can't read".
|
dgwphotography Feb 25 2016 03:31 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
LOL - I usually say something like, "This is what happens when people try Common core in real world applications..."
|
John Cougar Lunchbucket Feb 25 2016 04:03 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
||
By reducing wait times at all lanes, shoppers less inclined to abuse product limits AND limits less likely to be required. If you think about it "10 items or less" is really just a stupid and failed strategy to reduce wait times in the first place. It doesn't by itself do anything. As you said it's just a sign. There's no science behind it. I have this company brochure here on my desk. It is awesome.
|
batmagadanleadoff Feb 25 2016 04:49 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks Edited 2 time(s), most recently on Feb 25 2016 05:54 PM |
I just remembered an even more outrageous supermarket line scam that I saw but forgot to mention in my earlier post. It's a bad-faith evolution of that honest situation where a group of two are on line (usually a married couple, again, but sometimes a parent and child) and while they're on line, one of them realizes that they sincerely forgot to pick up an item, so while one person holds their place in the line, the other goes to fetch the forgotten item.
|
Frayed Knot Feb 25 2016 05:39 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
I had one of those incidents once. Husband pushing the cart separates from (considerably younger) wifey who walks toward an empty check-out line as he continues shopping. I assume, seeing as how she's empty-handed, that she's simply walking through the empty line to go fetch the car, or hit the CVS across the parking lot, or whatever. But then she stops short at the cashier causing me to skid to a stop when I realize she's not just waking through. "Oh, sorry" she says, as she notices me for the first time and decides that I'm worthy of going ahead (I didn't have much). Half a minute or so later, macho-looking hubby shows up and accusingly asks me why I jumped ahead of his wife. "Umm, because she told me I could" I cleverly replied. He then apologized (twice as I recall) but it was clear that this was a regular scheme of theirs and the fact that it didn't "work" this time immediately indicated to him that *I* must have done something wrong by scooting ahead of his trophy wife. And the stupid thing was, the upside of having this stunt getting them ahead of me rather than behind would have shaved a whole 45 seconds or so off of their day.
|
Frayed Knot Feb 25 2016 09:03 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
Fortunately my other supermarket pet peeve is dying out because no one pays cash anymore - well I do but I'm 3/4 of the way to being a fossil.
|
seawolf17 Feb 26 2016 08:17 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
That used to drive me BANANAS as a cashier. We had a contest in the store to see who was the fastest cashier, and those wasted seconds KILLED ME because I was usually at or near the top, and I hated when people wasted my time.
|
John Cougar Lunchbucket Feb 26 2016 08:29 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
From 4 minute average wait time to 30 seconds, wthout adding extra labor. Heat-detecting cameras.
|
Frayed Knot Feb 26 2016 08:33 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
"Oh wait young man, I have the three pennies" ... dives into pocketbook ... cue 'Jeopardy' music
|
seawolf17 Feb 26 2016 08:35 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
||
DO YOU UNDERSTAND THAT I'VE WON LIKE FIVE WEEKS IN A ROW, LADY? SCREW YOU AND YOUR THREE PENNIES.
|
Ceetar Feb 26 2016 08:45 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
did those images describe how this heat-sensing thing works, functionally?
|
Lefty Specialist Feb 26 2016 10:08 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
||
I hate to say it, but that's my wife. Drives me crazy as well. She's obsessed with getting rid of extra change.
|
John Cougar Lunchbucket Feb 26 2016 10:10 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|||
Thermal kinetic sensors. Cameras detect heat as light, people are hotter than checkstands and displays of Tide detergent, making it easy to distinguish or "count" them. From there you can "count" the hot things going to the deli, or the dairy section, or the exit, or in this case the check-out. Over time, and you'll see patterns that can help operators more efficiently schedule labor, but also, place things where they will best sell, manage energy, whatever. Do it over thousands of stores over time and it's even more effective.
Doing things more efficiently should theoretically be better for everybody -- the company (more profits, high sales and market share) employees (more hours, better earning potential as results improve) and customers. Less waiting at the register ---> more frequent/larger $$ store visits --> more sales ---> more profits to the company ---> more fuel to invest in jobs/prices/customer service ---> more sales ---> more profits etc etc). KR which is doing this is a union shop in most places it operates so it's not like this is slave trade. Without exaggerating too much, it's one of the most successful companies in American history (not to go all supermarket maven on you, but retailers measure success by increasing sales at the same location over the same period year after year. If you're not growing in retail you're shrinking. Kroger has accomplished this every quarter for the last 12 years. It's astonishing, considering they did it right in the midst of a recession, amid unprecendented growth by Walmart, Whole Foods, Amazon etc. and with food now available at drug stores, dollar general, and Bed Bath and Beyond etc etc. Why? because of the thermal kinetics! (not really but shit like thermal kinetics. You're right it's expensive and one of the advantages is that competitors cannot all afford this). Beyond all that they are sort of the Moneyball of food retail -- they' make the best use of data and analytics, proprietary strategies etc).
Yet you can still wait 10 minutes to check out there. I am sure Whole Foods also counts customers and tries to schedule labor efficiently but they need to reapproach checkout to adapt to their massive volume and tiny size.
|
Ceetar Feb 26 2016 10:45 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
ahh, okay yeah that's interesting.
|
Frayed Knot Feb 26 2016 10:58 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
That alone isn't a problem; I'm usually a change-getting-ridder too. The problem comes when the fact that the purchase doesn't hit an exact round number **comes as a complete and utter surprise to folks** and only then do they even begin to commence a hunt for the loose coin at the bottom of the mondo-purse. I just keep my coins (if I happen to have any) in my pocket or, as the cashier is finishing, in my hand to quickly spit out the 3 cents, or 37 cents, or whatever makes it easier. And if it's not easy then I don't bother and will get rid of some next time.
|
cooby classic Feb 26 2016 11:29 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
||
FK did they have goal?
|
cooby classic Feb 26 2016 11:30 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
||
My mom still does this, and not just at the supermarket, lol
|
Frayed Knot Feb 26 2016 12:06 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
|
Seemingly to "lay claim" to the check-out lane while it was empty until hubby returned after grabbing the final few items.
|
MFS62 Feb 28 2016 03:53 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
For folks who have worked at a supermarket-
|
seawolf17 Feb 28 2016 08:20 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
Nope. Well, not the case 25 years ago, anyway. Express was the plum spot, so it went to the longer-timers and/or better cashiers.
|
John Cougar Lunchbucket Mar 02 2016 09:25 PM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
Listen to the Maven tomorrow on your Marketplace morning report. At least that's what they tell me.
|
John Cougar Lunchbucket Mar 04 2016 09:56 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
I got pre-empted yesterday by that oil-and-gas executive who demonstrated how not to drive, but this aired this morning: http://www.marketplace.org/2016/02/29/w ... innovation
|
cooby classic Mar 04 2016 11:31 AM Re: Supermarket Maven Speaks |
Like we already don't know how to not drive. Sheesh.
|