Master Index of Archived Threads


Irving Berlin's White Christmas (1954)

1/2

0 votes

*

0 votes

* 1/2

0 votes

* *

2 votes

* * 1/2

2 votes

* * *

1 votes

* * * 1/2

0 votes

* * * *

0 votes

* * * * 1/2

0 votes

* * * * *

0 votes

Edgy MD Dec 16 2018 08:00 PM

My wife remarked about how much Rosemary Clooney looked like her nephew George, and now I can't stop seeing George Clooney in drag.

MFS62 Dec 17 2018 07:09 AM Re: Irving Berlin's White Christmas (1954)

The movie was written when America liked the title song, that had been performed in the movie 'Holiday Inn". It would have been like producing a movie titled "Maria" after the song in West Side Story. It was like dozens of Judy Garland/ Mickey Rooney/ Donald O'Connor musicals of its era, but with snow. Not bad for a "spin-off". Later

Benjamin Grimm Dec 17 2018 07:17 AM Re: Irving Berlin's White Christmas (1954)

I liked Holiday Inn better, even though the story in White Christmas made more sense. I'm not sure, but I think the real-life hotel chain Holiday Inn took its name from the Bing Crosby/Fred Astaire movie.

Mets Willets Point Dec 17 2018 09:35 AM Re: Irving Berlin's White Christmas (1954)

I always thought White Christmas was a remake of Holiday Inn that excised the racist blackface number, but apparently the story was different.

Edgy MD Dec 17 2018 10:29 AM Re: Irving Berlin's White Christmas (1954)

Benjamin Grimm wrote: I liked Holiday Inn better, even though the story in White Christmas made more sense. That's not a bad summation, even though White Christmas doesn't have a blackface sequence. ("Who was it set dem darkies free?!") On the other hand, it does have the hilariously awful "Snow!" song. The "old man" general whose late-life dignity Bing Crosby was trying to secure was, of course, the same age as Crosby.

seawolf17 Dec 17 2018 12:36 PM Re: Irving Berlin's White Christmas (1954)

This is possibly my wife's favorite movie of all time.

RealityChuck Dec 18 2018 10:58 AM Re: Irving Berlin's White Christmas (1954)

My wife loves it. I think it's mediocre at best. Cloyingly sentimental and a plot that was just plain nonsense (a retired general is not going to go bankrupt; he could get a job just about anywhere in an eyeblink*). The score is most filler, too. Holiday Inn, despite the blackface, is a better film. The story is cliched, but the songs are better and it's funnier. Plus you have Fred Astaire, who, when he read the script for White Christmas not only turned it down, but asked to be released from his contract with Paramount. But it better than the stage musical version, which surgically removes everything in the movie that wasn't awful. *Maybe even Commissioner of Baseball.

Edgy MD Dec 18 2018 12:38 PM Re: Irving Berlin's White Christmas (1954)

I don't know I would guess we had a surplus of retired generals and colonels by 1954, and didn't always know what to do with them. They're not all as brilliant as John Kelly.

MFS62 Dec 24 2018 09:46 AM Re: Irving Berlin's White Christmas (1954)

Sundance Channel is showing it all day today. Later