Master Index of Archived Threads


Stupid and Meaningless Realmuto poll

Michael Conforto

1 votes

Brandon Nimmo

4 votes

Amed Rosario

8 votes

Noah Syndergaard

0 votes

Benjamin Grimm Dec 12 2018 12:03 PM

Let's say the Mets and the Marlins could make a one-for-one deal for JT Realmuto. Which of these four players would you prefer to give up? The Mets wouldn't be sending or receiving any additional players. The deal does not include a negotiating window.

smg58 Dec 12 2018 12:10 PM Re: Stupid and Meaningless Realmuto poll

If you forced me at gunpoint to pick one it would be Rosario, but I do not believe giving up five years of him, or four of Nimmo, or three of Thor or Conforto is worth two years of Realmuto. I'd vote none of the above.

Centerfield Dec 12 2018 12:12 PM Re: Stupid and Meaningless Realmuto poll

smg58 wrote: If you forced me at gunpoint to pick one it would be Rosario, but I do not believe giving up five years of him, or four of Nimmo, or three of Thor or Conforto is worth two years of Realmuto. I'd vote none of the above. This.

d'Kong76 Dec 12 2018 12:15 PM Re: Stupid and Meaningless Realmuto poll

I took Rosario in the spirit of the poll question 'let's say they could' but I'm really in Camp SMG on this one.

John Cougar Lunchbucket Dec 12 2018 12:16 PM Re: Stupid and Meaningless Realmuto poll

You know how nervous I must be not to participate in a stupid and meaningless exercise.

HahnSolo Dec 12 2018 12:17 PM Re: Stupid and Meaningless Realmuto poll

Who will it be? I think Nimmo. But I don't want to give up Nimmo in this deal. Who should it be? None of the above.

batmagadanleadoff Dec 12 2018 12:21 PM Re: Stupid and Meaningless Realmuto poll

Why do youse say that? This depends on what youse think Realmuto'll do over the next two years. If he can repeat 2018, he's probably worth it. And he'd command a fortune after that, that the cheapskate Mets might not meet. He's also a catcher and 30 ( what he'd be in his 1st year after FA) in catcher years is like 33 or 34 in regular baseball years.

batmagadanleadoff Dec 12 2018 12:32 PM Re: Stupid and Meaningless Realmuto poll

batmagadanleadoff wrote: Why do youse say that? This depends on what youse think Realmuto'll do over the next two years. If he can repeat 2018, he's probably worth it. And he'd command a fortune after that, that the cheapskate Mets might not meet. He's also a catcher and 30 ( what he'd be in his 1st year after FA) in catcher years is like 33 or 34 in regular baseball years. First, you have to figure out what you want out of this. What your goals are. Are you trying to give the Mets the best chance at winning the WS in the near future or would you rather have exciting players for many years that might not contend because to seriously contend, you need solid players everywhere, even in the 6th and 7th batting order slots. If you think you're in a small window to .make a serious run, then there should be a sense of urgency to this.

Benjamin Grimm Dec 12 2018 12:36 PM Re: Stupid and Meaningless Realmuto poll

I voted Nimmo because I think he's probably the most replaceable. The idea of Syndergaard is completely absurd.

batmagadanleadoff Dec 12 2018 12:40 PM Re: Stupid and Meaningless Realmuto poll

Might as well offer them Plawecki for Realmuto straight up because the Marlins accepting just Nimmo is about as likely as a Biden/Romney ticket.

Benjamin Grimm Dec 12 2018 12:45 PM Re: Stupid and Meaningless Realmuto poll

I know. That's why this poll is "stupid and meaningless". I'm mainly, I guess, trying to figure out which players we're most and least attached to.

Ashie62 Dec 12 2018 01:18 PM Re: Stupid and Meaningless Realmuto poll

Aint happenin