Forum Home

Master Index of Archived Threads


What did you read in 2018?

Benjamin Grimm
Dec 28 2018 09:00 AM

We'll use this thread for our traditional year-end posting of the books that we've read.

41Forever
Dec 28 2018 09:35 AM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

I used an Amazon gift card I got for Christmas to buy the Fish Sticks book that Lunchbucket has been talking about. His Q&A with the author is a great read. Should arrive today or tomorrow and will start reading to meet the deadline.

A Boy Named Seo
Dec 28 2018 02:19 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

A couple few years back, I found a podcast on a TV show I love and would online befriend the nice married couple who co-hosted. Before they finished the podcast, there was a longish break, and when they returned, the husband quickly revealed he had transitioned to a woman, and the two of them finished the podcast, like nothing had changed.



I learned that the wife had written a book of poetry describing what it was like when her husband of 10+ years revealed the desire to transition and what it was like from her perspective to laud her spouse for her bravery, love and support her decision, but also experience all the pains of a marriage crumbling and a love lost. This thing was very good.



https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/41t5OUz00TL._SX342_BO1,204,203,200_.jpg>

Theoldmole
Dec 28 2018 02:40 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/81G9W%2Bt6v9L.jpg>

Here's one i really liked.

Also reading a lot of crime novels, a couple by Michael Connelly, who continues to impress, and Joe Ide, new to me - liked him too. Sherlock Holmes recreated in the 'hood.

https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/515XczeUdcL._SX322_BO1,204,203,200_.jpg>



And of course, the new Kevin Chapman.

Benjamin Grimm
Dec 28 2018 02:52 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

For some reason replies in this thread (and none of the others so far) require administrative approval. I don't know why that is, but please bear with us as we try to figure out what's going on.

A Boy Named Seo
Dec 28 2018 03:02 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

Yeah, I got a message when I posted saying admin approval was required. I wondered if it was because I linked to an image.

Benjamin Grimm
Dec 28 2018 03:37 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

Doesn't seem to be, because this latest post also required approval.

whippoorwill
Dec 28 2018 03:38 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

That Britt Marie book looks good!



I read a whole bunch of MC Beaton this year.



For Christmas I asked for and got some Dickens! Yay :)

metsmarathon
Dec 28 2018 08:34 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

I read a few good books this year.



In no particular order, and perhaps neither all inclusive nor fully confined to this year...



The last Jedi

Ashoka

Thrawn alliance

Battlefront: twilight company



Sapiens



1493



The rise and fall of the dinosaurs



Thomas Jefferson and the Tripoli pirates. (Possibly that was last year)

Andrew Jackson, also by Brian kilmeade



Astrophysics for people in a hurry



Currently reading silk roads.



There may have been another Star Wars book mixed in too.



My reading list has been very enlightening this year.

Between 1493 and silk roads, as well as sapiens, it really lays down how fairly recent an idea racism as we currently experience and exercise it is, and how, ultimately (I'm greatly oversimplificating here, but not overly much if you think about it) it came about as a rationalization to justify for the tremendous enrichment available to those who would partake in the slave trade.



And that Islam as an enemy of the us is an even newer concoction borne of idiotic and shady dealings around the First World War, kicked off by the British and carried forth by our short-sighted and profit-focused countrymen.



I'm sure that if I did not go into either book with a liberal-progressive mindset I might not have pulled out the same threads, but here I am.



They kinda make me a little sad that my trumping mom has effectively given up on engaging in any political discussions at family gatherings.. c'est la vie.



The kilmeade books are decent, but the more you read them the more one-sides they become. And at one point he flat out wrote that Andrew Jackson beat the British because he was an American, damnit, and that made him better. It really stripped away whatever credibility he had, tbh.



Seriously:

“Pakenham had reason to feel optimistic. After all, he had the finest fighting force in the world and, if his scouts had it right, a considerable advantage in both men and artillery. What didn't he have? Andrew Jackson and the American commitment to victory.”



Well, shit. Why did I read this whole damned book if that's all you needed to write. And how good a leader could Jackson be if it was the americancommitment to victory that truly carried the day. And why bother discussing any British failures or faults ( ok, he mostly didn't discuss them) if even a perfectly run was couldn't stand up to our great americanisticness!



Sigh. What should inexpect from a fox newser.



I'm mostly caught up on the full del Rey timeline of Star Wars new canon. I need to catch up on the YA content I think. Never did read a single bit of the old expanded universe though.

bmfc1
Dec 29 2018 08:35 AM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

Two books stand out:

"The Force" by Don Winslow. The author tells you what's going to happen at the start and still has your attention for the entire book. Bad cops, bad politicians, everyone is bad in this New York. I loved it and still think of it.

http://don-winslow.com/books/the-force/



"Righteous Assasin" by Kevin G. Chapman.

I hear that the author is a Mets fan.

My Amazon review: "There's a killer on the loose in New York City, Detective Mike Stoneman is in pursuit, and author Kevin G. Chapman is telling us the exciting case in rich detail. The storytelling is so realistic that I wondered if the author was chronicling a true story. Heart-stopping action told in vivid fashion makes “Righteous Assassin” a must read."

Fman99
Dec 30 2018 03:27 AM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

I've kept a list this year. I'll share soon.

Benjamin Grimm
Dec 30 2018 02:51 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

Forty books in 2018, and here they are, along with the rating I gave each one on Goodreads. When I noticed that the first four or five books I read had been written by female authors, I decided to celebrate the "Year of the Woman" by making this the first year since I began keeping track (in 1982!) in which I read more books by women than by men. I ended up with 23 of the 40 written by women, including four of the five that got a five-star rating.



I typically read about 80 to 90 per cent non-fiction, and this year I landed on the high end of that range, with 36 of 40 non-fiction books.



Looking back, it's nice to see that there were no one-star books, and only two two-star books. That means I chose fairly well this year. The first book on this list, The Warmth of Other Suns, is one that everyone should read.




[TABLE][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR][TR]
[TH]Title[/th][TH]Author[/th][TH]Rating[/th]
[TD]The Warmth of Other Suns: The Epic Story of America's Great Migration[TD]Wilkerson, Isabel [TD]5 stars
[TD]Mabel: Hollywood's First I-Don't-Care Girl[TD]Fussell, Betty Harper[TD]4 stars
[TD]Ten Days in a Madhouse[TD]Bly, Nellie[TD]4 stars
[TD]The Handmaid's Tale[TD]Atwood, Margaret [TD]4 stars
[TD]Nellie Bly: Daredevil, Reporter, Feminist[TD]Kroeger, Brooke[TD]3 stars
[TD]Resurrection Science: Conservation, De-extinction and the Precarious Future of Wild Things[TD]O'Connor, M.R.[TD]5 stars
[TD]St. Marks Is Dead: The Many Lives of America's Hippest Street[TD]Calhoun, Ada [TD]3 stars
[TD]Dietrich & Riefenstahl: Hollywood, Berlin, and a Century in Two Lives[TD]Wieland, Karin[TD]4 stars
[TD]97 Orchard: An Edible History of Five Immigrant Families in One New York Tenement[TD]Ziegelman, Jane[TD]4 stars
[TD]The Ice Cream Blonde: The Whirlwind Life and Mysterious Death of Screwball Comedienne Thelma Todd[TD]Morgan, Michelle[TD]2 stars
[TD]A Feathered River Across the Sky: The Passenger Pigeon's Flight to Extinction[TD]Greenberg, Joel[TD]3 stars
[TD]The Underground Railroad[TD]Whitehead, Colson [TD]3 stars
[TD]Catwatching[TD]Morris, Desmond[TD]3 stars
[TD]Somebody: The Reckless Life and Remarkable Career of Marlon Brando[TD]Kanfer, Stefan[TD]5 stars
[TD]Beale Street Dynasty: Sex, Song, and the Struggle for the Soul of Memphis[TD]Lauterbach, Preston [TD]3 stars
[TD]Stan and Ollie: The Roots of Comedy: The Double Life of Laurel and Hardy[TD]Louvish, Simon[TD]4 stars
[TD]My Fathers' Ghost Is Climbing in the Rain[TD]Pron, Patricio[TD]3 stars
[TD]The River of Doubt: Theodore Roosevelt's Darkest Journey[TD]Millard, Candice[TD]4 stars
[TD]Bad Times in Buenos Aires[TD]France, Miranda[TD]5 stars
[TD]The Prodigal Tongue: The Love-Hate Relationship Between American and British English[TD]Murphy, Lynne[TD]4 stars
[TD]Dangerous Men: Pre-Code Hollywood and the Birth of the Modern Man[TD]LaSalle, Mick[TD]4 stars
[TD]Montgomery Clift[TD]Bosworth, Patricia[TD]4 stars
[TD]The Man in the Mirror: A Life of Benedict Arnold[TD]Brandt, Clare[TD]3 stars
[TD]Silent Spring[TD]Carson, Rachel[TD]4 stars
[TD]To Have and Have Not[TD]Hemingway, Ernest[TD]4 stars
[TD]American Heiress: The Wild Saga of the Kidnapping, Crimes and Trial of Patty Hearst[TD]Toobin, Jeffrey[TD]4 stars
[TD]The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness[TD]Alexander, Michelle[TD]4 stars
[TD]Rachel Carson: Witness for Nature[TD]Lear, Linda [TD]3 stars
[TD]Champagne and Baloney: The Rise and Fall of Finley's A's[TD]Clark, Tom[TD]4 stars
[TD]The Poisoned City: Flint's Water and the American Urban Tragedy[TD]Clark, Anna[TD]3 stars
[TD]Madame Sarah[TD]Skinner, Cornelia Otis[TD]4 stars
[TD]Dean and Me: A Love Story[TD]Lewis, Jerry[TD]3 stars
[TD]The New York Nobody Knows: Walking 6,000 Miles in the City[TD]Helmreich, William B.[TD]3 stars
[TD]Samuel Pepys: The Unequalled Self[TD]Tomalin, Claire[TD]3 stars
[TD]Ben Hecht: A Biography[TD]MacAdams, William[TD]2 stars
[TD]Dangerously Funny: The Uncensored Story of "The Smothers Brothers Comedy Hour"[TD]Bianculli, David[TD]3 stars
[TD]Frank Rizzo: The Last Big Man in Big City America[TD]Paolantonia, S.A.[TD]3 stars
[TD]Orange Is the New Black[TD]Kerman, Piper [TD]3 stars
[TD]Off the Cliff: How the Making of Thelma & Louise Drove Hollywood to the Edge[TD]Aikman, Becky [TD]5 stars
[TD]The General vs. the President: MacArthur and Truman at the Brink of Nuclear War[TD]Brands, H.W.[TD]3 stars

Johnny Lunchbucket
Dec 31 2018 07:01 AM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

I continued with rock bios + sports nonfiction and one novel. it was the year of the guy as I read no woman-authored books. If you're going to pick something to read from my list make it Backman, the Elton John book or Swingin As...





GRUMPY OLD ROCK STAR, Rick Wakeman (sucked)



HOMEWARD BOUND: The Life of Paul Simon, Peter Ames Carlin (pretty good)



CAPTAIN FANTASTIC: Elton John's Stellar Trip Through the 70s, Tom Doyle (very good)



DYNASTIC, BOMBASTIC, FANTASTIC, Reggie, Rollie, Catfish and Charlie Finley's Swingin' A's, Jason Turbow (loved it)



TWILIGHT OF THE GODS: A Journey to the End of Classic Rock, Steven Hayden (disappointed)



FASTBALL JOHN, John DAquisto and Dave Jordan (fun)



SIREN SONG: My Life in Music: Seymour Stein (interesting)



WAITING TO DERAIL: Ryan Adams and Whiskeytown, alt-country's beautiful wreck, Thomas O'Keefe (pretty good)



LIGHTFOOT, Nicholas Jennings (very good but not great)



US AGAINST YOU, Frederik Backman (great)



NEVER A DULL MOMENT: 1971, the Year Rock Exploded, David Hepworth (pretty good)



THE YACHT ROCK BOOK, Greg Prato (sucked)



THANKS A LOT, MR KIBBLEWAIT, Roger Daltrey (eh)



BIG CITY CAT: My Life in Folk-rock, Steve Forbert ( good)



FOOTBALL FOR A BUCK, The crazy rise and crazier demise of the USFL, Jeff Pearlman (pretty good)



WE WANT FISH STICKS; The bizarre and infamous rebranding of the New York Islanders, Nicholas Hirshon (fun)



I'M KEITH HERNANDEZ, Keith Hernandez (liked it a lot)



THE DOWN GOES BROWN HISTORY OF THE NHL: The World's Most Beautiful Sport, the World's Most Ridiculous League, Sean McIndoe (interesting but not as funny as I wanted)

TransMonk
Dec 31 2018 02:51 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

https://i.imgur.com/usm3V9z.png>



Educated by Tara Westover and The Beastie Boys Book were my favorites.

Frayed Knot
Dec 31 2018 03:14 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

By chance I just finished up the final one a few hours ago.



FICTION



READY PLAYER ONE — Ernest Cline (2011) ***-1/2

Mid-21st century technology meets 1980's pop culture as a billionaire recluse wills control of the virtual world he created to the winner of a contest to be played out in that world. Role playing gamer geeks will think this is their bible and, although I'm the furthest thing from any of that, I enjoyed the ride anyway. Now a major motion picture (which was decently good in its own right).



MANHATTAN BEACH - Jennifer Egan (2017) **-1/2

Very well-written story and interesting characters from a Pulitzer-winning (for a different book) author about a girl/young woman during Depression/WWII era NYC. But it made some odd plot choices which left me less than awed.



JULIET, NAKED — Nick Hornby (2009) ***-1/2

So check it out, a Nick Hornby novel about relationships, music, and relationships through music. Still a lot of fun despite the well-trod Hornby path and even if the title makes people who see you reading this in public assume you're consuming porn. Also movie-ized earlier this year.



US AGAINST YOU — Fredrik Backman (2018) ****

A sequel to Backman's 2017 novel ‘BEARTOWN' follows the characters of two small hockey-obsessed Swedish towns down some dark holes.

Set up in a way where you can follow and enjoy this one without having read the first ... but why would you want to?







NON-FICTION



THE SELLING OF THE BABE: The Deal that Changed Baseball and Created a Legend — Glenn Stout (2016) ***-1/2

THE BIG FELLA: Babe Ruth and the World He Created — Jane Leavy (2018) ****


Two books on The Babe 100 or so years after his career was getting started:

-- ‘THE SELLING' is a nice little fact-from-myth look detailing Ruth from his Boston tenure through his first year in New York, and particularly about the deal transferring him from the one to the other.

-- In ‘BIG FELLA', the author of previous bios on Mantle & Koufax takes on the Babe through several of his off-season barnstorming tours in a way that attempts to explain the creation of Ruth the phenomenon more so than the ballplayer, even as the two remain intrinsically linked.



REPUBLICAN LIKE ME: How I Left the Liberal Bubble and Learned to Love the Right — Ken Stern (2017) ***-1/2

Liberal big-city easterner (former CEO of NPR) goes out into red state America trying both to understand the other side and possibly seek some common ground.



PALE RIDER: The Spanish Flu of 1918 and How it Changed the World — Laura Spinney (2017) ***-1/2

The origins and effects of the worldwide pandemic that killed more people than WWI



STING-RAY AFTERNOONS: A Memoir — Steve Rushin (2017) ***-1/2

He certainly nails the whole Zeit-Geist of growing up in the ‘70s. Also interesting to see how his life as a wordsmith — and there are few better — began practically at birth.



DISCOVERING THE MAMMOTH: A Tale of Giants, Unicorns, Ivory, and the Birth of a New Science — John J. McKay (2017) **

It took a long time between man first finding evidence of the Mammoth and their realization that it was, and that there was even such a thing as, an extinct species.

It also took seemingly as long for the author to get around to chronicling that process.



GAME CHANGE: The Life and Death of Steve Montador and the Future of Hockey — Ken Dryden (2017) ****

Although it centers around just one of the recent deaths of young, former NHL'ers, Dryden goes into the whole history and the psyche of hockey in Canada as a way of explaining how things got to this point and where he thinks they should go.



A BRIEF HISTORY OF EVERYONE WHO EVER LIVED: The Human Story Retold Through Our Genes — Adam Rutherford (2017) ***-1/2

How we became us in general and, more specifically, how you become you.



THE ENDS OF THE WORLD: Volcanic Apocalypses, Lethal Oceans, and Our Quest to Understand Earth's Past Mass Extinctions — Peter Brannen (2017) ***

What happened to cause virtually all life on earth to die out five previous times during the history of this planet and how all that applies to our own future.



INHERITORS OF THE EARTH: How Nature is Thriving in an Age of Extinction — Chris D. Thomas (2017) ***

How nature is not just losing species and habitats in this human-dominated era of earth's history but also continues to gain species and habitats at the same time.



RED CARD: How the U.S. Blew the Whistle on the World's Biggest Sports Scandal — Ken Bensinger (2018) ***

A somewhat broad overview of the mostly secret investigations which led to the massive U.S. DoJ indictments of high level soccer officials.

Spoiler Alert: the entire sport is corrupt and the decision to go to Russia was decided and funded by bribery.



DISAPPOINTMENT RIVER: Finding and Losing the Northwest Passage — Brian Castner (2018) ***-1/2

The author both chronicles and reenacts Alexander MacKenzie's 1787 attempt to find a navigable water route through northern North America.



CARTOON COUNTY: My Father and His Friends in the Golden Age of Make-Believe — Cullen Murphy (2017) ***

Talking about a life with slight parallels to my own, the author describes growing up as the son of a cartoonist and of the world of cartooning in general.



RESURRECTION SCIENCE: Conservation, De-extinction, and the Precarious Future of Wild Things — M. R. O'Connor (2015) ***

The possibilities, but also the roadblocks and potential drawbacks, of man trying to manipulate nature even with good intentions.



FOOTBALL FOR A BUCK: The Crazy Rise and Crazier Demise of the USFL — Jeff Pearlman (2018) **-1/2

BIG GAME: The NFL in Dangerous Times — Mark Leibovich (2018) ***


Two football books in one year (which is right about two above my usual quota) one current, one nostalgic, and, as a bonus, Trump comes off looking like a childish ass-clown in both.

-- Pearlman was gaga over the USFL as a kid and 'FOR A BUCK' gives that league the full — wasn't it fun / weren't they colorful / damn shame they were broke — type of treatment.

-- 'BIG GAME' is from an NFL fan-boy but one who's starting to question the game's less healthy impact and isn't above mocking its more ridiculous contradictions and excesses.



I CAN'T BREATHE: A Killing on Bay Street — Matt Taibbi (2017) ***-1/2

The events leading up to the police killing of Eric Garner on Staten Island and the entrenched bureaucracy preventing justice afterward.



THE SPY AND THE TRAITOR: The Greatest Espionage Story of the Cold War — Ben MacIntyre (2018) ***-1/2

A cold war spy story out of the John LeCarre playbook, except that this one is real. I read this author's SPY AMONG FRIENDS a couple years ago about English spy/secret communist Kim Philby.

This one flips the script and focuses on the most valuable KGB agent to go to work for the British in the ‘80s.



I'M KEITH HERNANDEZ - Keith Hernandez (2018) ***

Keith Hernandez talking about the making of Keith Hernandez. Focuses mostly on his early/pre-NYM career and touching only intermittently on his current life in the TV booth.



ON DESPERATE GROUND: The Marines at the Reservoir, the Korean War's Greatest Battle — Hampton Sides (2018) ****-1/2

If Hampton Sides were to write my obituary I'd look forward to reading it.

This one relays, in often stunning detail even 68 years after the fact, the horror and chaos of an early major battle for the Americans while also serving as an example of when hubris from military chiefs and politicians gets young men killed and maimed.



THE WHITE DARKNESS — David Grann (2018) ***

Short little book about a British military officer and his obsession with Antarctica in general and Antarctic explorer Ernest Shackelton in particular.



INSEPARABLE — The Original Siamese Twins the Their Rendezvous with American History — Yunte Huang (2019) ***-1/2

As a yute I was fascinated by the brief bio of these guys in my very first copy of ‘Guinness Book of World Records'. Now, as Paul Harvey would say, for the rest of the story, one which includes how their story bumped up against social conditions in mid-19th century America.

The Hot Corner
Jan 01 2019 03:46 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

Edited 1 time(s), most recently on Jan 03 2019 05:14 PM

I read 42 books this year. My favorite titles are signified with bold print. Fiction titles are designated with bold astericks(**).

1. Coolidge by Amity Schlaes

2. The Road Out of Hell by Anthony Flacco with Jerry Clark

3. Eye Chart by William Germano

4. Liar, Temptress, Soldier, Spy by Karen Abbott

5. Distillery Cats by Brad Thomas Parsons

6. It's Not Yet Dark by Simon Fitzmaurice

7. Son's and Soldiers by Bruce Henderson

8. Jungleland by Christopher S.Stewart

9. Kon Tiki by Thor Heyerdahl

10. My Grandmother Asked Me to Tell You She's Sorry by Fredrick Backman**

11. Ben Franklin: An American Life by Walter Isaacson

12. Patient H69: The Story of My Second Sight by Vanessa Potter

13. And the Sea Will Tell by Vincent Bugliosi with Bruce Henderson

14. The Man From the Train by Bill James

15. Nomadland: Surviving America in the 21st Century by Jessica Bruder

16. The Republic of Pirates by Colin Woodard

17. Once Upon A Team by Jon Springer

18. Rocket Men by Robert Kurson

19. Judgement Ridge: The True Story Behind the Dartmouth Murders by Dick Lehr

20. The Phenomenon: Pressure, the Yips, & the Pitch that Changed my Life by Rick Ankiel

21. Endurance: Shackleton's Incredible Voyage by Alfred Lansing

22. Britt Marie Was Here by Fredrick Backman**

23. Enrique's Journey by Sonia Navario

24. Dead Presidents by Brady Carlson

25. Our Towns by James Fallows & Deborah Fallows

26. The Cadaver King and the Country Dentist by Radley Balko & Tucker Carrington

27. Sing For Your Life by Daniel Bergner

28. The Sense of An Ending by Julian Barnes**

29. The Devil & Sherlock Holmes by David Grann

30.The Remains of the Day by Kazuo Ishiguro**

31. BlackKKlansman by Ron Stallworth

32. Us Against You by Fredrik Backman**

33. Girl in the Woods by Aspen Matis

34. Crashing Through by Robert Kurson

35. Into the Storm by Tristram Korten

36. Where the Crawdads Sing by Delia Owens**

37. On Desperate Ground by Hampton Side

38. The Perfect Mile by Neal Bascomb

39. Into the Storm by Tristram Korten

40. The White Darkness by David Grann

41. Ten Hours Until Dawn by Michael J. Tougia

42. The Library Book by Susan Orlean

cal sharpie
Jan 02 2019 09:22 AM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

62 for me in 2018.



MY STRUGGLE: BOOK FIVE – Karl Ove Knausgaard

STEPHEN SONDHEIM: A LIFE – Meryle Secrest

THE SIGNAL AND THE NOISE – Nate Silver

THE COMPLETE SHORT NOVELS – Anthon Chekhov

STORIES – T.C. Boyle

THE ZENITH – Duong Thu Huong

AMERICAN HEIRESS – Jeffrey Toobin

THE KILLER INSIDE ME – Jim Thompson

VILLA TRISTE – Patrick Modiano

MANHATTAN BEACH -- Jennifer Egan

THE SUN AND THE MOON AND THE ROLLING STONES – Rich Cohen

THE GIRLS – Emma Cline

DEPT OF SPECULATION – Jenny Offill

THE LAND OF GREEN PLUMS – Herta Muller

BROOKLYN WAS MINE – Chris Knutsen and Valerie Steiker (eds)

WE WERE THE MULVANEYS – Joyce Carol Oates

FLORENCE OF ARABIA – Christopher Buckley

BAD NEWS – Anjan Sundaram

MY ABSOLUTE DARLING – Gabriel Tallent

NANA – Emile Zola

CRUISING PARADISE – Sam Shepard

MIDDLEMARCH – George Eliot

RAZORGIRL – Carl Hiaasen

WHY HAVEN'T YOU WRITTEN? – Nadine Gordimer

THIRTEEN DAYS IN SEPTEMBER – Lawrence Wright

A GENTLEMAN IN MOSCOW – Amor Towles

THE ITALIAN TEACHER – Tom Rachman

FANTASYLAND – Kurt Andersen

MOUNTAINS BEYOND MOUNTAINS – Tracy Kidder

WEST OF SUNSET – Stewart O'Nan

DROWN – Junot Diaz

MISSING PERSON – Patrick Modiano

OUR SOULS AT NIGHT – Kent Haruf

HIROSHIMA – John Hersey

A SEPARATION – Katie Kitamura

RETURN TO THE DARK VALLEY – Santiago Gamboa

THE MAKING OF HENRY – Howard Jacobson

THE LITTLE RED CHAIRS – Edna O'Brien

THE DEPORTEES – Roddy Doyle

WORDS FOR THE TAKING – Neal Brower

BLACK SWAN GREEN – David Mitchell

THE SELLOUT – Paul Beatty

BAD FAITH – Carmen Callil

THE ICE STORM – Rick Moody

WHITE TEARS – Hari Kunzru

THE BOOK OF DUST: LA BELLE SAUVAGE – Philip Pullman

VACATIONLAND – John Hodgman

PARADISE NEWS – David Lodge

DARKTOWN – Thomas Mullen

THE UNDERGROUND GIRLS OF KABUL – Jenny Nordberg

HOW TO CHANGE YOUR MIND – Michael Pollan

THE SNOWMAN – Jo Nesbo

OUTLINE – Rachel Cusk

SWEETLAND STORIES – E.L. Doctorow

THE LINE OF BEAUTY – Alan Hollinghurst

BECOMING – Michelle Obama

CASTLE – J. Robert Lennon

ALL THAT IS – James Salter

ON TYRANNY – Timothy Snyder

THE BLUE GUITAR – John Banville

GOOD TROUBLE – Joseph O'Neill

MOONGLOW – Michael Chabon



While I've read other books on the other lists, the only ones that show up on my list and another 2018 list are AMERICAN HEIRESS which I shared with Ben (okay, not great) and MANHATTAN BEACH which I shared with Frayed Knot (liked it quite a bit).

Willets Point
Jan 02 2019 01:15 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

My list

Willets Point
Jan 02 2019 01:19 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

Frayed Knot wrote:





CARTOON COUNTY: My Father and His Friends in the Golden Age of Make-Believe — Cullen Murphy (2017) ***

Talking about a life with slight parallels to my own, the author describes growing up as the son of a cartoonist and of the world of cartooning in general.


I've been meaning to read this. Cullen Murphy attended my high school about 20 years before I did and donated a custom drawing of Prince Valliant that was on display in the front hall of the school.

Frayed Knot
Jan 02 2019 01:27 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

cal sharpie wrote:

62 for me in 2018.


What Cal didn't mention is that he's currently on his 4th book of 2019












... and MANHATTAN BEACH which I shared with Frayed Knot (liked it quite a bit).


I liked it too ... until I didn't, or at least until I liked it less so.

I read that one very early in the year so the specific details as to why are beginning to slip away, but I remember some leaps in the plot that I had trouble buying after a while.

As I said in my mini-review: good characters, nice set-up, etc., but then less satisfying towards the end.

batmagadanleadoff
Jan 02 2019 01:31 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

I don't know how youse could have read so many books this year with what's happening in the White House. I'm jealous. Among the books I've read this year that are also appearing on your lists are Manhattan Beach and Warmth of Other Suns. I'm currently reading The Poisoned City, which also made several of your lists.





And boy does Grimm love to read about Old Hollywood. Every year.

Frayed Knot
Jan 02 2019 01:38 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

Willets Point wrote:
I've been meaning to read this. Cullen Murphy attended my high school about 20 years before I did and donated a custom drawing of Prince Valliant that was on display in the front hall of the school.


I may even have met him at some point via some cartoonist function although he's somewhat older than me as well and if I did I don't remember.

I'm certain our fathers knew each other through the NCS but this book came out too late for me to ask and, though many other cartoonists of that era were mentioned, dad never was as, being

Long Islanders, we weren't part of the Greenwhich County clan he largely writes about..

A Boy Named Seo
Jan 02 2019 01:55 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

I'm about to order this book, but am tempted to get the audio version, which I've never done. Dig this cast of narrators:



https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/51htrhbiHnL._SX342_.jpg>



Steve Buscemi

Ada Calhoun

Bobby Cannavale

Exene Cervenka

Roy Choi

Jarvis Cocker

Elvis Costello

Chuck D

Nadia Dajani

Michael Diamond

Snoop Dogg

Will Ferrell

Crosby Fitzgerald

Randy Gardner

Kim Gordon

Josh Hamilton

Adam Horovitz

LL Cool J

Spike Jonze

Pat Kiernan

Talib Kweli

Dave Macklovitch

Rachel Maddow

Tim Meadows

Bette Midler

Mix Master Mike

Nas

Yoshimi O

Rosie Perez

Amy Poehler

Kelly Reichardt

John C. Reilly

Ian Rogers

Maya Rudolph

Rev Run

Luc Sante

Kate Schellenbach

MC Serch

Chloe Sevigny

Jon Stewart

Ben Stiller

Wanda Sykes

Jeff Tweedy

Philippe Zdar

Frayed Knot
Jan 02 2019 01:58 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

=batmagadanleadoff post_id=343 time=1546461091 user_id=68]I don't know how youse could have read so many books this year with what's happening in the White House.



We read to escape what's happening in the White House

cal sharpie
Jan 02 2019 02:04 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

batmagadanleadoff wrote: ↑Wed Jan 02, 2019 3:31 pm

I don't know how youse could have read so many books this year with what's happening in the White House.

Frayed Knot wrote:

We read to escape what's happening in the White House


Yeah, that's part of it. Staying off of social media (other than CPF) is another part. Not watching much TV other than the Mets is another part. Also, subway commutes help. I usually have a couple of books working at a time.



I don't count books that I didn't finish or books that I used only for reference (travel guides and the like) or books that I read to children. I do feel that I have the right to skip introductions and such that I don't care about.

A Boy Named Seo
Jan 02 2019 02:07 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

I waste entirely too much time looking at st00pid social media. Deleted insta and FB apps from my phone yesterday. New year, new start!



/spends infinitely more time on CPF

TransMonk
Jan 02 2019 04:01 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

A Boy Named Seo wrote:

I'm about to order this book, but am tempted to get the audio version, which I've never done.


I listened to the audio book. It was amazing.



Spike Jonze “reads” a chapter that is only pictures by describing each picture and it's relevance.



I don't think I would have enjoyed the book as much any other way.

A Boy Named Seo
Jan 02 2019 04:30 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?


A Boy Named Seo wrote:

I'm about to order this book, but am tempted to get the audio version, which I've never done.


I listened to the audio book. It was amazing.



Spike Jonze “reads” a chapter that is only pictures by describing each picture and it's relevance.



I don't think I would have enjoyed the book as much any other way.


Done. Thanks for the rec!

Fman99
Jan 06 2019 05:12 AM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

I read these:







and these:



DocTee
Jan 06 2019 09:48 AM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

48 books in 2018, just shy of my goal of one per week:



The Chicago Cubs: Story of a Curse. Rich Cohen

Exiled: The Last Days of Sam Houston. Ron Rozelle.

Al Capone and the 1933 World's Fair: The End of the Gangster Era in Chicago. William E. Hazelgrove

The Mad Bomber of New York: The Extraordinary True Story of the Manhunt that Paralyzed a City. Michael Greenburg.

The Witch of Lime Street: Seance, Seduction, and Houdini in the Spirit World. David Jaher.

Breakfast with Socrates: Am Extraordinary (Philosophical) Journey through your Ordinary Day. Robert R. Smith

All Souls: A Family Story from Southie. Michael Patrick McDonald

Bobby Kennedy: A Raging Spirit. Chris Matthews

If the Oceans Were Ink: An Unlikely Friendship and a Journey to the Heart of the Q'uran. Carla Power

Zero K. Don Delillo.

Killers of the Flower Moon: The Osage Murders and the Birth of the FBI. David Grann

The Looming Tower: Al Qaeda and the Road to 9/11. Lawrence Wright

Bad Jobs and Poor Decisions: Dispatches from the Working Class. JR Helton

The Johnstown Flood: the Incredible Story Behind One of the Most Devastating Disasters America Has Ever Known. David McCullogh

A Higher Loyalty: Truth, Lies, and Leadership. James Comey

Braving the Wilderness: The Quest for True Belonging and the Courage to Stand Alone. Brene Brown

Hero of the Empire: The Boer War, A Daring Escape, and the Making of Winston Churchill. Candace Millard.

American Crucifixion: The Murder of Joseph Smith and the Fate of the Mormon Church. Alex Beam

From Here to Eternity: Travelling the World to Find the Good Death. Caitlin Doughty

Inseparable: The Original Siamese Twins and their Rendezvous with American History. Yunte Huang

Happiness in this Life: A Passionate Meditation on Earthly Existence. Pope Francis

Twelve Years a Slave: A Narrative of Solomon Northrup. Solomon Northrup

The Things They Carried. Tim O'Brien

It's All Relative: Adventures Up and Down the World's Family Tree. AJ Jacobs

White Fox and Icy Seas in the Western Arctic: The Fur Trade, Transportation and Change in the Early Twentieth Century. John Bockstoce

The Road of Lost Innocence: the Story of a Cambodian Heroine. Samaly Mam

Coming to My Senses: The Making of a Counter-Culture Cook. Alice Waters

The Island at the Center of the World: The Epic Story of Dutch Manhattan and the Forgotten Colony that Shaped America. Russell Shorto

The Restless Wave: Good Times, Just Causes, Great Fights and Other Appreciations. John McCain and Mark Salter.

The Book of Aron. Jim Shepard

When: the Scientific Secrets of Perfect Timing. Don Pink

Kicks: The Great American Story of Sneakers. Nicholas Smith

It Can't Happen Here. Sinclair Lewis

My Beloved World. Sonia Sotomayor

Shortfall: Family Secrets, Financial Collapse, and a Hidden History of American Banking. Alice Echols

Fire and Fury: Inside the Trump White House. Michael Wolff

Big Game: The NFL in Dangerous Times. Mark Leibovich

The Subtle Art of Not Giving a Fuck: A Counter-intuitive Guide to Living a Good Life. Mark Manson

Six Degrees: Our Future on a Hotter Planet. Mark Lynas

The Last Boy: Mickey Mantle and the End of America's Childhood. Jane Leavy

The Last Lecture. Randy Pausch

Option B: Facing Adversity, Building Resilience, and Finding Joy. Sheryl Sandberg and Adam Grant

The American Spirit: Who we Are and What we Stand For. David McCullogh

Wasteland: the Great War and the Origins of Modern Horror. F. Scot Poole

The Man Who Walked Backward: An American Dreamer's Search for Meaning in the Great Depression. Ben Montgomery

The Travels of a T-Shirt in the Global Economy: An Economist Examines the Markets, Power, and Politics of World Trade. Pietra Rivoli

The Men Who United the States: America's Explorers, Inventors, Eccentrics, Mavericks and the Creation of One Nation, Indivisible. S Winchester

Astoria: John Jacob Astor and Thomas Jefferson's Lost Pacific Empire--A Tale of Ambition and Survival on the Early American Frontier. Peter Stark

whippoorwill
Jan 13 2019 05:52 AM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

Johnny Lunchbucket, did you read the John Oates book?

MFS62
Jan 13 2019 07:35 AM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

I just finished Origin by Dan Brown, which I started in 2018.

I spent so much time following the news last year (every day was an adventure), the other books I read don't stick in my memory. (Maybe they weren't that memorable)



I just got a call that my local Barnes and Noble is holding a copy of the 2019 Baseball Almanac for me. I can't wait to read the statistics of the prospects BVW has traded away.



Later

Johnny Lunchbucket
Jan 13 2019 02:13 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

=whippoorwill post_id=1077 time=1547383965 user_id=79]
Johnny Lunchbucket, did you read the John Oates book?



I did but I think it was in 2017.



I loved the first half of it. But he's very boring when not keeping a diary, which really flopped the second half the book

whippoorwill
Jan 13 2019 03:44 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

Yes time flies, but I'll be it was 2017 when I read it too.



I thought it weird that almost as soon as I finished it, I saw that his Colorado house, which he went on and on about, was up for sale so he could move to Tennessee and be a country singer

Frayed Knot
Jan 13 2019 06:16 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

Johnny Lunchbucket wrote:

BIG CITY CAT: My Life in Folk-rock, Steve Forbert ( good)


I always got the impression that, even though Forbert had some initial success, that success was capped by him being the victim of really bad timing.

He blows into NYC from Meridian, Mississippi all denim-ed out while toting his acoustic guitar and harmonica, but did so just as the NYC music scene was going all new-wavy and punkish

via the likes of the Ramones, Blondie, Talking Heads, etc.

Later, like Oates and many others, he wound up in Nashville where the music scene is probably better suited to his talents.

Johnny Lunchbucket
Jan 13 2019 06:32 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

The book surprised me by Forbert's confessing how much of the blame for his so-called lack of success was actually on him. He was determined and good enough to cut through the fact that all the trends were against him and along the way gathered in a lot of people who wanted him to succeed, but turned out to be really uncomfortable with where that got him. He was also too hardheaded in the studio, didn't always take the best advice, and drank too much beer. He also intimates his biggest mistake might have been schtupping CBS boss Walter Yentikov's secretary. That he says got him into that lengthy purgatory.



The other thing you learn was that he wasn't always a folk rocker, but set out to be a "real" rocker (you can hear some of that with his Rough Squirrels rockabilly period but he grew up in a band covering T-Rex and The Stones and all that. He was adept at doing many things because at heart he's a helpless music geek.



Good book!

Edgy MD
Jan 13 2019 08:53 PM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

The funny thing is that his nickname, Stevie Orbit, would have been a great nu wave handle.

Theoldmole
Jan 14 2019 10:24 AM
Re: What did you read in 2018?

In reverse chronological order, with my Goodreads reviews:





A Visit from the Goon Squad

Egan, Jennifer ****

This is probably more 3.5 than 4, but err on the side of generosity. It's Elizabeth Strout with urban glitz, an omnibus of characters inhabiting stories separately and together. Egan doesn't have Strout's philosophic acceptance of the human condition, but her frenetic skewering of it has it's own rewards. Maybe more rewards than I was expecting. I decided fairly early on that I wasn't going to like this book, but it kept almost winning me over with the strength of the characterizations.

Thank god for Kindle. It helped a lot that when a character appeared in a story, I could use the search command to go back a figure out where I'd first seen that character. Because Egan is no respecter of chronology. We may see a character as. Young woman in one chapter, a child in the next, then a matron several chapters later and a rebellious teenager a while after that, also making cameo appearances as someone else's afterthought or vague memory. Keeps you on your toes.

Sometimes Egan will finish a story by telling you what the youthful protagonist is doing thirty years hence. It's another part of her overall theme that life sucks, which is not generally what I want to hear, but she has a disconcerting habit of subverting that overall theme.

She also has one chapter, the first person narrative of a young teenage girl obsessed with PowerPoint slides, which is written entirely in PowerPoint slides. Again, oddly appealing.





IQ (IQ, #1)

Ide, Joe ****

Joe ide's creation of a kid from the ‘hood with the insights and intellectual skills of a Sherlock Holmes is a strange notion, but it works. This first book tracks its protagonist's journey from prodigy to petty criminal to a force for good. I'll read more.



The Modern Art Invasion: Picasso, Duchamp, and the 1913 Armory Show That Scandalized America

Lunday, Elizabeth ****

Short, breezy, insightful...what more could you ask?



My Sister's Bones

Ellwood, Nuala ***

All the way through this book, I wasn't sure that I liked it. Then to be met with plot twists that were successively far-fetched and telegraphed, I was even less sure. But by the time I had finished, I certainly wasn't sure that I didn't like it. It does have something that gets to you. Three stars for me is generally a warm, but not hot, recommendation. You can Read this one - it's ok, it won't be a waste of time, at least not a serious waste. This time, it means something different. It means I don't know whether to recommend it or not. Read some other reviews and decide then.



The Fall of the Stone City

Kadare, Ismail ****

I didn't love this one as intensely as I loved Chronicle in Stone, but I liked it a lot. Part history, part magic realism of a special, weird Eastern European sort, it takes Albania from fascism to communism as two sides of a nightmare.



The Brass Verdict (Mickey Haller, #2; Harry Bosch Universe, #18)

Connelly, Michael ****

After reading a lot of the Bosch books, and growing more and more impressed by Connelly as a writer, I turned to this, the second in the Mickey Heller series, and became even more impressed, Connelly finds a different approach - first person narrative - and really creates a different voice for Haller. And yeah, it goes without saying that the man can craft a masterful plot.





Britt-Marie Was Here

Backman, Fredrik *****

Britt-Marie takes some getting used to. Certainly for the citizens of depression-ravaged Borg. She's hard to get to know, and hard to like, and she doesn't fit in. A reader can hardly be blamed for being put off by her either. But the reader, like the townspeople of Borg, will come to love her as he or she has loved few other characters in fiction. She grows on you that much.



And that's all you really have to know, isn't it? Except that there's a lot of soccer in it, and if, like Britt-Marie, you hate soccer, you'll come to love it too. Like her.



The Golden Girl and All (Hardman, #3)

Dennis, Ralph ***

Ralph Dennis is a cult favorite of crime novelists, not much known outside that circle. He wrote a series of mass market paperbacks in the ‘70s that were appreciated by cognoscenti as being a cut above the usual paperback series fare of that era. His books have been long out of print, but are back now, and I was interested, since I'm also a 70s paperback novelist whose books were, I'd like to think, a cut above.

Dennis lives up to the rather esoteric hype. This book, the first I've read, is way better written than a lot of the big best sellers of today like David Baldacci. Dennis knows how to weave a plot, to create characters, to write believable dialogue and to write a clear and cliche-free English sentence.

His setting is Atlanta, which he seems to know very well. His character is Jim Hardman, a former cop who has never bothered to get a p.i. license but instead “does favors “ for people, much like Lawrence Block's Matthew Scudder. His best friend/sidekick is a very tough black man who operates outside the law, much like Robert Parker's Spenser and Hawk. I don't know who came first, and I don't see any plagiarism here - just ideas that were in the air at the time. Dennis and Block were both part of the same New York paperback circuit, and probably knew each other (I knew Block slightly, never met Dennis).

The story involves kidnapping, double crosses, a girl with almost too much sexual allure to be believable (but Dennis keeps her believable, a tribute to his ability), some beatings, some drinking, enough twists to keep you turning the pages. I'm now a fan. I'll read more.







Before She Met Me

Barnes, Julian **

This is a petty, unpleasant novel by a very gifted writer. It's a problem relationship novel about relationships between people it's impossible to care about. I guess I'm glad he got it out of his system. I'm sorry I wasted time reading it, especially since Barnes is a good enough writer that I felt I ought to read it all the way through.





The Paris Architect

Belfoure, Charles **

An interesting situation was enough to keep me reading all the way through, but in the end not rewarding. It was just clumsy. Clumsy prose, clumsy plotting, clumsy characterization. I guess skill and precision as an architect doesn't necessarily translate to other art forms,





Righteous Assassin (Mike Stoneman #1)

Chapman, Kevin G. ****

Kevin Chapman has some ingenious murders, and some very believable relationships, particularly between a very relationship-shy Middle Aged cop and a woman of a certain age whose appeal leaps off the page. And he has a narrative device that I've never seen before. He alternates chapters between the cops trying to figure out what the killer is up to, and the killer, via a blog, telling you what he's up to. And it works.





Circe

Miller, Madeline ****

The problem with writing about an immortal is there's really no place to stop, which can make for a long book. Miller eventually solves that problem very nicely, if not unexpectedly, but not until the book has gotten quite long. But that's ok too, because the last part is really the best part, with the richest characters and most interesting relationships. She picks up Mary Renault's mantle as no one else really has.



Grist Mill Road

Yates, Christopher J. ***

There's something not real about it. The characters don't seem real, they seem invented in order to stick into a contrived plot, and the inevitability of the plot isn't all that real, either.



The Crowded Grave (Bruno, Chief of Police #4)

Walker, Martin ****

I have an instinctive prejudice against any book where the private eye whips up a little something with shallots and creme fraiche, but I'll make an exception for Bruno and his navarin d'agneau. That, along with the French countryside, the ever-developing plot, the complex relationships and rivalries between different police entities, the emotional complexities of Bruno's love life, all make for a most satisfying read. I started with the fourth in the series because it's the one that Overdrive had available, but I look forward to going back and starting with the first. Thanks to Kayla Abelove Feldman for the recommendation.





Still Life (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #1)

Penny, Louise

I've read three of these now, and will read more. I've read them out of order, which means I've learned a lot of things that should be surprises when I get to the books that they're in, but I can live with that. My real problem with Penny, and it's one of those things that once you notice it, you can't stop noticing it -- the unnecessary withholding of information. Of course, a mystery novel is built on the withholding of information -- you have to read through to the end to find out who the murderer is -- but I'm talking about the small-scale withholding. Inspector Gamache sees something in a drawer that makes him gasp. Why not tell us what he sees? Why make us wait ten pages? Nothing is particularly gained.

But all in all, good characters, good plots, good mis en scene.



Worth Dying For (Jack Reacher, #15)

Child, Lee ****

I don't really have to review every Lee Child novel - they're all good reads; he sets a high bar. But a couple of thoughts. One - yeah, there's a formula. Reacher, traveling aimlessly, arrives in a small town, gets involved in something his code of honor won't let him walk away from. But it's a flexible formula. Because Reacher isn't tied to a job, whether cop, private eye or spy, he's open to a lot more plot possibilities than someone who is, and this is a really good ploy on Child's part.

Second, he's better at writing scenes of physical brutality than probably anyone ever. Too good. brrrrr.





The Overlook (Harry Bosch, #13; Harry Bosch Universe, #17)

Connelly, Michael *****

I've always liked Connelly, but only recently stopped to think about just how good he is. I'm not going to say much more about this one because almost anything would be a spoiler. I'll just say that it's intricately and cleverly plotted. All the clues are there. And I didn't come close to guessing the ending.





King Zeno

Rich, Nathaniel ***

Ultimately, an engrossing, clever plot, very good mise en scene of New Orleans right after WWI, before Prohibition. But the plot takes a while to get going, and for me, the characters took a long time to coalesce—to make me feel them as real.

My main issue with the plot, and I'll try to phrase this so it isn't a spoiler. Everyone seems to figure out who the ax murderer is, and I'm not sure exactly how.

I do recommend the book. Not unreservedly, but I recommend it.





Two Kinds of Truth (Harry Bosch, #20; Harry Bosch Universe, #30)

Connelly, Michael *****

I've read and enjoyed a lot of Connelly's Harry Bosch novels, but this one pushed Connelly over the top for me, to the pantheon of crime novelists. He's got the pure simplicity of Elmore Leonard, the humanity of Ross McDonald. He's a sharp and original plotter. And he's damn near as prolific as Simenon, so I still have a whole lot of reading ahead of me.



The Underground Railroad

Whitehead, Colson ****

Surreal, fanciful, and yet as real as it could possibly be about slaves' existence, and the dream of freedom, and being, slave or free, black in America.





The Tunnels: Escapes Under the Berlin Wall and the Historic Films the JFK White House Tried to Kill

Mitchell, Greg *****

Full disclosure. Part of what made me pick up this book in the first place—Greg Mitchell is an old friend. But that's not what kept me reading it. It's a page turner. It's contemporary history, but because it's an almost forgotten story, you don't know how it's going to turn out, and it's life or death for the people involved on both sides of the Berlin Wall. Mitchell brings us memorable characters and illuminates an important historical context.



Astral Weeks: A Secret History of 1968

Walsh, Ryan H. ****

You might expect a book that takes Van Morrison's legendary album title for its own, and suggests that it will be about Morrison's time in Boston creating this breakthrough music, to actually be about that.

The bad news is that if that's what the book is supposed to be about, it does get a little lost in digressions.

The very good news is that the digressions—Boston's counterculture in the year of Counterculture ascendant—are far more interesting than a linear book about Van Morrison and the making of Astral Weeks could ever have been.

Closer than Van the Man to the center of the book is Mel Lyman, the guru of a commune/cult who started as a banjo player, claimed to be God, and built a little empire that outlasted him (he died at some point, no one is exactly sure when) and still exists today.

For a book about the counterculture, politics and lifestyles, Astral Weeks is surprisingly good about music. For a book about music, it's surprisingly good about the counterculture, politics and lifestyles. Walsh is a terrific researcher, diligent in tracking down and interviewing more primary sources than one would imagine possible, and he has a clear-eyed understanding of the importance of all of his sources and all of his subjects.

And Mr. Walsh, if you read your Goodreads reviews, I'd love to get a contact for David Silver, an old and dear friend I've lost touch with.





The Marsh Madness (Book Collector Mystery, #4)

Abbott, Victoria ****

Takes a long time to get going - longer than it needs to, because by the time she's figured out the mcGuffin that sets the plot in motion, you're screaming it at her - but once it gets going, it's fast paced and complex. Enjoyable characters. I'd read another.





Fallout (V.I. Warshawski, #18)

Paretsky, Sara ****

Haven't read her in a while. Did V. I. go from hippies to Facebook without aging? Well, Nero and Archie did the same thing.

She really is awfully good. She's back on my list.



Lord Jim

Conrad, Joseph *****

There's such richness in Conrad. His narratives within narratives, his richness of language, the complexity of his characters.