Master Index of Archived Threads
Where ya gonna go?
Double Switch Jul 15 2019 06:03 PM |
Where you gonna go when 2nd-generation US citizen Trump demands you "go home"? I'm only 3rd generation and cannot figure out which among the nations Ancestry.com says are my genetic heritage to choose when the time comes - I have never visited any of them. Good thing I don't have a Twitter account to draw attention to myself and get targeted as an "America hater" because I don't agree with him and hate everything he stands for.
|
Benjamin Grimm Jul 15 2019 06:20 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
When they ship me out, it will be to Sicily.
|
kcmets Jul 15 2019 06:33 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Double Switch Jul 15 2019 06:39 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
whippoorwill Jul 15 2019 07:04 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Frayed Knot Jul 15 2019 07:49 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Fman99 Jul 16 2019 04:18 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
metirish Jul 16 2019 06:48 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
metsmarathon Jul 16 2019 07:35 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Ceetar Jul 16 2019 08:00 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Lefty Specialist Jul 16 2019 08:30 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
LWFS Jul 16 2019 08:32 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Centerfield Jul 16 2019 11:45 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? Edited 3 time(s), most recently on Jul 16 2019 12:20 PM |
I only have one option.
|
whippoorwill Jul 16 2019 12:14 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Benjamin Grimm Jul 16 2019 01:27 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
=Centerfield post_id=16026 time=1563299159 user_id=65] |
Benjamin Grimm Jul 16 2019 01:28 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
=whippoorwill post_id=16033 time=1563300863 user_id=79] |
Frayed Knot Jul 16 2019 02:07 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
I'd call that third generation, as if the word 'born' is implied even if not stated. So the immigrants give way to the first [born] generation of Americans, who then beget second gens, etc. Not sure if that's the officially official way of stating it, but it's what I've always gone with.
|
seawolf17 Jul 16 2019 02:10 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
His wife knew what she was getting when she married him. He so clearly is what he is. I have no sympathy for her. |
Ceetar Jul 16 2019 02:18 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
=seawolf17 post_id=16055 time=1563307818 user_id=91] |
Benjamin Grimm Jul 16 2019 02:38 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Johnny Lunchbucket Jul 16 2019 03:00 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
whippoorwill Jul 16 2019 05:43 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Double Switch Jul 16 2019 06:03 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
MFS62 Jul 16 2019 06:49 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Centerfield Jul 17 2019 08:00 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
||
I'm zero generations removed from Korea. Born in Seoul, lived in Pusan as a baby, moved to the States when I turned 3. I don't have a lot of memories of Korea, but I do remember a time when I didn't live in the United States. My brother, on the other hand, was born in Syracuse. I think these generation definitions are kinda vague. My parents (born and raised in Korea, immigrated to the US as young adults) are commonly referred to as first generation. People like me (born in Korea, raised in the US) are called 1.5 gen. My brother would be second generation. Which doesn't make a lot of sense, since we should be the same generation. So keeping in line, my kids would be second generation Korean Americans, while his kids would be third generation Korean Americans. Which again, doesn't really make sense since they are the same generation. Also his kids will be half Korean, half Scottish/Italian. So I'm not sure what that does for the "generations" label.
|
Centerfield Jul 17 2019 08:01 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
kcmets Jul 17 2019 08:09 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
I love New York and America, but just in case...
|
Ceetar Jul 17 2019 08:22 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
seawolf17 Jul 17 2019 08:24 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Edgy MD Jul 17 2019 09:20 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Oh, damn, how have they not invited me to speak at their commencements and shit yet?
|
Vic Sage Jul 17 2019 09:59 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
batmagadanleadoff Jul 17 2019 10:47 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Can I copy this post into the Trump is Hitler thread?
|
RealityChuck Jul 17 2019 11:54 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
MFS62 Jul 18 2019 06:06 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Exactly. The list of countries in which my family once lived and from which they had to flee is long and distinguished. On my father's side is Austria (my last name is a town there), Romania, and they moved here from France. My mother's family was from Lithuania. I remember people in my neighborhood when I was a kid who had the concentration camp serial number tattoos. And I fear it is only a matter of time when Dump's followers will be wearing arm bands. Later
|
Chad ochoseis Jul 18 2019 09:31 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
A Boy Named Seo Jul 18 2019 10:01 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
kcmets Jul 18 2019 10:11 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
A Boy Named Seo Jul 18 2019 10:27 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
seawolf17 Jul 18 2019 11:08 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
WAIT, WE LET THEM HAVE A *NEW* MEXICO?!?! RIGHT HERE IN THE UNITED STATES?!?!
|
A Boy Named Seo Jul 18 2019 02:52 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
shhhhh....
|
dinosaur jesus Jul 18 2019 05:15 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
My grandparents were all born in the United States. My great-grandparents too. And all my great-grandparents, except for a rogue Irishman from County Cork. Which makes me only slightly less of an American than Ilhan Omar, since no one in my family ever had to choose to come here. Most of them never even had the imagination to leave Texas. Not that terms like "less of an American" have any meaning, of course. This is all so stupid. And it's so obviously stupid that I feel stupid even saying anything about it.
|
Frayed Knot Jul 22 2019 03:25 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|||
SEND HIM BACK! SEND HIM BACK!
They are vague. Also totally meaningless except for the case in being legally able to run for President. btw, how often does your brother remind you that he could run for President while you never can? I'd refer to your kids as 'first generation' (depending on your wife's status) but, as I said earlier, that's merely the way I learned it. Not arguing that there's an official right/wrong definition here. It's like how one defines relations: some will refer to their cousins' kids as 'second cousins' while others go to the more cumbersome, but possibly more technically correct, 'first cousins/once removed' label. I just call them cousins.
It'll make their backgrounds mixed and variable, just like most us. My brother's wife, like you, immigrated as a young child. So that makes their two kids either 1st or 2nd gen Americans (depending on your preferred definition) on their mom's side and yet as much as 10th to 12th on the other.
|
seawolf17 Jul 23 2019 06:36 AM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
FWIW, CF, I would *totally* vote for you.
|
Centerfield Jul 23 2019 12:27 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
kcmets Jul 23 2019 12:56 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Willets Point Jul 23 2019 01:16 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
Lefty Specialist Jul 23 2019 02:12 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|
My friends from college have pictures. I'm not running for anything.
|
MFS62 Jul 23 2019 07:12 PM Re: Where ya gonna go? |
|