Master Index of Archived Threads


Keystone Chief

THE FREE SWINGER: Javier Baez

11 votes

THE CHEMICALLY ENHANCED: Robinson Canó

0 votes

THE ASS OF RED: Jeff McNeil

1 votes

THE SPECIALIST: Luis Guillorme

1 votes

THE ITINERANT: Jonathan Villar

0 votes

THE NEWCOMER: Ronny Mauricio

1 votes

A Free Agent Acquisition (please name)

0 votes

A Trade Acquisition (please name)

0 votes

An Organizational Up-and-Comer (please name)

0 votes

Edgy MD Nov 04 2021 03:52 PM

Who is your team's number one secondbaseman in 2022? What a wide-open field we have! Three guys claim the mantle of incumbent in different ways. Only you can decide who comes out on top! https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-lhEdmY6Nq7Y/WlO2ivVl8CI/AAAAAAAAFew/u-8OydzraagNR6V6tvTWWfvwBcqnrRtlACLcBGAs/s1600/baseball%2Bplayer%2Bfielding.jpg>

Chad ochoseis Nov 04 2021 04:12 PM Re: Keystone Chief

I'm the first voter? I went with McRedass. Baez is worth more to a team that needs a shortstop. Cano is cooked. Lindor and McNeil are going to have to learn to play nice on the diamond, and the Mets will bet on Jeffy Mac getting his .300 swing back.

G-Fafif Nov 04 2021 04:50 PM Re: Keystone Chief

Once I've gone El Mago I can't go backo

Fman99 Nov 04 2021 06:43 PM Re: Keystone Chief

=G-Fafif post_id=80670 time=1636066232 user_id=55] Once I've gone El Mago I can't go backo

This is where I'm at. I have a non sexual man crush on this guy.

Lefty Specialist Nov 04 2021 06:51 PM Re: Keystone Chief

If Cano is on this team next spring, I'll be surprised. Oh, and annoyed. Not that I'm in favor of it, but I get the feeling they're going to bring Baez back to keep Lindor happy. Which is an annoyance of a different kind.

Frayed Knot Nov 04 2021 07:23 PM Re: Keystone Chief

It seems like maybe a good time to bet on the improvement of El Mago in late 2021 being a more or less permanent sign of things to come (a la Muffy circa 2016) The question is how long do you wish to bet on that bet?

Edgy MD Nov 04 2021 08:09 PM Re: Keystone Chief

I like the notion, but why is this a good time to make that bet? A solid contact-making gap hitter like Murphy suddenly developing a pull stroke? That happens from time to time, and it seems more sustainable to me than a free-swinging slugger developing restraint at 28 or 29. That's happened too, but it sure feels rarer and more fleeting.

Edgy MD Nov 06 2021 12:17 PM Re: Keystone Chief

This is not an easy decision. Each of those top three decisions have a wide range of outcomes. McNeilo is appealing because he'd be the easiest to divest from, but you don't want to make a whole lot of decisions that way. It's hard to be confident that Canó has a whole range of upside left, but one way or another, he's paid for.