Forum Home

Master Index of Archived Threads


Dark & Moody BLC: Radiohead v. The Doors

Willets Point
Apr 25 2006 12:42 PM

Thom Yorke sez "I wanna be Jim Morrison."

Fake Plastic Trees
Karma Police
Paranoid Android
I Will (No Man's Land)
There There (The Boney King of Nowhere)
Idioteque
Anyone Can Play Guitar
No Surprises
Creep
Lucky

sharpie
Apr 25 2006 12:52 PM

Jim Morrison says to Thom Yorke "I am the Lizard King -- and you aren't":

Love Me Two Times
Light My Fire
People Are Strange
Hello, I Love You
Riders On the Storm
L.A. Woman
Soul Kitchen
Alabama Song (Whiskey Bar)
Break On Through
Roadhouse Blues

Edgy DC
Apr 25 2006 01:38 PM
Edited 2 time(s), most recently on Apr 25 2006 06:21 PM

vs.

"Fake Plastic Trees"vs."Love Me Two Times"
"Karma Police"vs."Light My Fire"
"Paranoid Android"vs."People Are Strange"
"I Will (No Man's Land)"vs."Hello, I Love You"
"There There (The Boney King of Nowhere)"vs."Riders On the Storm"
"Idioteque"vs."L.A. Woman"
"Anyone Can Play Guitar"vs."Soul Kitchen"
"No Surprises"vs."Alabama Song (Whiskey Bar)"
"Creep"vs."Break On Through"
"Lucky"vs."Roadhouse Blues"

Willets Point
Apr 25 2006 04:47 PM

Hell, if no one else is going to start the voting in the Image Hosted by Tripod vs. The Doors challenge, then I will.

"Fake Plastic Trees"vs."Love Me Two Times" The Doors
- - - Thumping blues beats melodic folk rock.
"Karma Police"vs."Light My Fire" Radiohead
- - - Battle of the heavyweights, KP by a hair.
"Paranoid Android"vs."People Are Strange" Radiohead
"I Will (No Man's Land)"vs."Hello, I Love You" Radiohead
- - - These are two weak Doors tracks foolishly overexposed by Classic Rock radio IMHO.
"There There (The Boney King of Nowhere)"vs."Riders On the Storm" Radiohead
- - - Two atmospheric songs. I'll take the pulsating drums over the thunderclaps.
"Idioteque"vs."L.A. Woman" Radiohead
- - - The '99 Mets aside, I never liked LA Woman much althoughI have a techno remix of it that's almost as good as Radiohead's rock-electronica original here.
"Anyone Can Play Guitar"vs."Soul Kitchen" The Doors
- - - Ha, the song that invokes the name of Jim Morrison loses to the real thing.
"No Surprises"vs."Alabama Song (Whiskey Bar)" Tie
- - - Both of these songs are personal faves for each band.
"Creep"vs."Break On Through" The Doors
- - - I can identify with the loser unable to talk with the girl, but "Break on Through" is 2 1/2 minutes of rock brilliance.
"Lucky"vs."Roadhouse Blues" The Doors
- - - The blues beat just being plain blue.

Radiohead 5.5:4.5 The Doors

sharpie
Apr 25 2006 05:54 PM

"Fake Plastic Trees" vs. "Love Me Two Times" Doors.
"Karma Police" vs. "Light My Fire" Doors
"Paranoid Android" vs. "People Are Strange" Radiohead. 2 paranoid songs.
"I Will (No Man's Land)" vs. "Hello, I Love You" Tie
"There There (The Boney King of Nowhere)" vs. "Riders On the Storm" Doors
"Idioteque" vs. "L.A. Woman" Doors
"Anyone Can Play Guitar" vs. "Soul Kitchen" Doors
"No Surprises" vs. "Alabama Song (Whiskey Bar)" Radiohead. Tough one.
"Creep" vs. "Break On Through" Doors. 'Nother tough one.
"Lucky" vs. "Roadhouse Blues" Doors.

Doors 7.5
Radiohead 2.5

I went through a period of liking Radiohead and then Thom Yorke's voice suddenly started bugging me, maybe when I heard Chris Martin they sounded the same to me to Thom's disadvantage. If they were brand new when I was 16 I woulda probably loved them. As it is I kinda like them and they might get my vote in other challenges but not nearly this high up.

RealityChuck
Apr 26 2006 09:30 AM

Even considering that I disliked the Doors when they were active, I'll go 10-0 Doors.

abogdan
Apr 26 2006 02:15 PM

"Fake Plastic Trees" vs. "Love Me Two Times" - Doors
"Karma Police" vs. "Light My Fire" - Doors
"Paranoid Android" vs. "People Are Strange" - Doors
"I Will (No Man's Land)" vs. "Hello, I Love You" - Doors
"There There (The Boney King of Nowhere)" vs. "Riders On the Storm" - Doors
"Idioteque" vs. "L.A. Woman" - Doors
"Anyone Can Play Guitar" vs. "Soul Kitchen" - Doors
"No Surprises" vs. "Alabama Song (Whiskey Bar)" - Doors
"Creep" vs. "Break On Through" - Radiohead
"Lucky" vs. "Roadhouse Blues" - Doors

I love Creep. 9-1 Doors.

sharpie
Apr 27 2006 12:56 PM

Doors shut off the Radio(head) 31-9

Johnny Dickshot
Apr 28 2006 06:48 AM

Lame contest. I'm sorry I was too late & to vote.

Edgy DC
Apr 28 2006 07:38 AM

I saw Radiohead and dug them six years ago. But I only knew five songs here and didn't make the time to know the rest. I'll amend that for their next appearance.

Rockin' Doc
Apr 28 2006 08:51 AM

If I don't know one of the band's songs very well, I simply don't vote. Unfortunately, with some of the bands (like Radiohead) that leaves me out of the balloting. A 30 second sound bite isn't sufficient for me to form a fair appraisal to vote.

In this case, it was probably just as well for Radiohead that I did pass. The 2-3 songs I am familiar with, I'm not too fond. Listening to sound bites of the others simply makes me think that Radiohead is either a band that's just not for me or possibly I need far greater exposure in order to appreciate their music.

Willets Point
Apr 28 2006 08:59 AM

For some reason I thought CPF'ers were familiar with and liked Radiohead. Alas, it's just me.

Edgy DC
Apr 28 2006 09:29 AM

< sleezy guy >Hey, baby, I'm familiar. But I'm conversant-familiar rather than intimate-familiar. < /sleezy guy >

Reallly, I think they're pretty excellent and would totally like a gift of their entire catalog far more than the Doors catalog.

A Boy Named Seo
Apr 28 2006 01:16 PM

Bah. I meant to vote in this one, too. Sorry, Radiohead, you woulda had a few votes from me. I'll get down to the polls when you duel Steely Dan or Petty or whoever's next.

Willets Point
Apr 28 2006 01:21 PM

The funny thing about sharpie's "when I was 16" comment is that I didn't start listening to Radiohead until I was 29. I liked Creep when I was in college but figured they were one-hit wonders and was pretty oblivious about them until I went to see a movie (A Mighty Wind I think) and the cinema showed a premiere of the video for "There, There" which I really liked. I got "Hail to the Thief" loved it and quickly bought up the rest of the Radiohead catalogue. It's an interesting way to get to know a band without really knowing what songs are their "hits" or radio favorites.

Willets Point
Apr 28 2006 04:26 PM

From the Kids in the Hall:

]
"the doors sketch"
Bruce- Record Store Clerk
Kevin- Customer
Vito Viscomi- Second Customer
[THE SCENE: An old record store somewhere, presumably Los Angeles. There is a couple looking at records and a Bruce is talking to them.]
Bruce: Yeah...those are all hacked...[shrugs and gestures to couple] Take care.

[The Couple leaves and a Kevin enters the store and begins looking around the record bin.]

Kevin: 'Scuse me.

Bruce: Yeah?

Kevin: Do you have the new Depeche Mode record?

Bruce: Yeah it's over there, [motions to the record bin] but it sucks.

[He continues to work on paperwork.]

Kevin: Well, do you have the latest Pixies album?

Bruce: Yeah, but it sucks. All that new stuff sucks, but it's over there.

Kevin: You know, actually I was thinking of getting into something vintage. Anyway...I don't know, maybe The Doors?

[Bruce spins around and looks at Kevin.]

Bruce: Really! Never had you figured for a Doors fan.

Kevin: I'm not really a Doors fan, but sure I'd like to get into them...

Bruce: No no no my friend! Doors fans aren't made, they're born. I think right now in Africa there's some guy madly beating on a drum. He's a Doors fan. Or an old lady sitting on the bus sucking humbugs. She's a Rider On The Storm, but she ain't never heard the sounds.

[Bruce looks at Kevin and snaps his fingers.]

Bruce: So what about you?

Kevin: Well I heard a record of theirs last night at a party...

Bruce: Yeah?

Kevin: ...and I've always liked Love Her Madly.

Bruce: Well, if you become a Doors fan, Love Her Madly is the only song you won't like.

Kevin: Oh right! [Looking through the record bin eagerly] I guess I should start with the Greatest Hits?!

Bruce: Hey! Greatest Hits are for housewives and little girls!

[He takes the record away from the Kevin and throws it across the store, and starts pushing the Kevin out of the store.]

Bruce: You're not serious! You don't want to be a Doors fan! Get out of my store! We're closed, get out!

[Bruce walks back toward the counter, clearly offended.]

Kevin: No no no no! I want you to show me the way!

Bruce: turns and looks at Kevin with disgust.

Bruce: Was that a Frampton reference in my store?!

[Kevin thinks for a second as a look of terror crosses his face.]

Kevin: No no no no! No lyrics, just words, just words...words?

Bruce: All right if you want to be a Doors fan, you cant just buy any album. It's scientific.

[Bruce goes to the record bin and picks out an album.]

Bruce: You gotta buy this...Waiting For The Sun. It's the departure point.

[Bruce kisses the album tenderly and glances at the credits on the back.]

Bruce: Listen to it around dusk every night for about a month.

[He hands the album to Kevin.]

Kevin: Sounds good! Then what...?

Bruce: Who's playing bass?

[Kevin looks frantically at the back of the record.]

Kevin: Umm duuuu baaaa.... No one?!

Bruce: No bass!

Kevin: No bass?!

Bruce: That's right! The gypsies had no homes, The Doors had no bass. But don't let that scare you, my friend let that liberate you! 'Cause when you're free flying with the Doors, man - what do you need a safety net for?

Kevin: [shouting] Viva Le Doors!

Bruce: Viva Le Doors. But listen, there's a burden that every real Doors fan has got to live with. That's the fact that the greatest rock n' roll band of all time is never going to play live again. You can't live in the past...

Kevin: No wait...there's hope. I heard once that Iggy Pop is going to front them and the Doors are going to tour again!

Bruce: Where did ya hear that?

Kevin: I heard it somewhere...

Bruce: Yeah?!? Read it in your precious Creem Magazine maybe? Well, it's not going to happen.

Kevin: Well how do you know that?

Bruce: Because somebody told me.

Kevin: Well, who told you?

Bruce: Do you wanna know who told me?

Kevin: Well, yeah...

Bruce: Jim Fuckin' Morrisson told me, that's who!!

[Vito runs into the store.]

Vito: Hey! Do you have the new Depeche Mode album?

[Kevin points at Vito and screams...]

Kevin: SUUUUCCKKSS!

[Vito runs out of the store.]

Bruce: I forgive you. Here. [Hands Kevin a copy of Morrisson Hotel] Take this, it's an 8-track tape. It's one of the last in existence. I want you to steal a car...

Kevin: I have a car...

Bruce: Steal a car!

Kevin: Steal a car!!

Bruce: I want you to get in it and drive West. Play the tape full blast. When the tape ends, get out and get into a fight, then get back into the car, come to town and meet me at the Carcas Club.

Kevin: What will you do?

Bruce: I will let you in to the most prestigious hotel of all time...

Kevin: Which is?

Bruce: [rolling his eyes] Mor'son Hotel!

Kevin: Then what?

Bruce: Then, you're gonna be a Doors fan, man.

[A door opens to a bright new future, which the soon to be Doors fan walks through, with his spirit guide, the Bruce.]