Master Index of Archived Threads


2022 Player Grades

MFS62 Oct 11 2022 11:16 AM

After I answered the "stay or Go?" question, I realized that there hasn't been a 2022 grading thread yet. So, since Ben did the heavy lifting in his thread, I'll use his list. What grades would you give to each of the Mets for his year? PETE ALONSO FRANCISCO ALVAREZ CHRIS BASSITT BRETT BATY MARK CANHA CARLOS CARRASCO JACOB deGROM EDWIN DIAZ EDUARDO ESCOBAR MYCHAL GIVENS LUIS GUILLORME FRANCISCO LINDOR SETH LUGO STARLING MARTE TREVOR MAY JAMES McCANN JEFF McNEIL TYLOR MEGILL TYLER NAQUIN TOMAS NIDO BRANDON NIMMO ADAM OTTAVINO DAVID PETERSON JOELY RODRIGUEZ DARIN RUF DOMINIC SMITH DREW SMITH MARK VIENTOS DANIEL VOGELBACH TAIJUAN WALKER TREVOR WILLIAMS Thanks, Ben Later

Benjamin Grimm Oct 11 2022 11:36 AM Re: 2022 Player Grades

PETE ALONSO A FRANCISCO ALVAREZ Incomplete CHRIS BASSITT B BRETT BATY Incomplete MARK CANHA B CARLOS CARRASCO B JACOB deGROM B EDWIN DIAZ A EDUARDO ESCOBAR B MYCHAL GIVENS C LUIS GUILLORME B FRANCISCO LINDOR A SETH LUGO B STARLING MARTE A TREVOR MAY D JAMES McCANN F JEFF McNEIL A TYLOR MEGILL C TYLER NAQUIN C TOMAS NIDO C BRANDON NIMMO A ADAM OTTAVINO B DAVID PETERSON B JOELY RODRIGUEZ C DARIN RUF F DOMINIC SMITH F DREW SMITH B MARK VIENTOS Incomplete DANIEL VOGELBACH C TAIJUAN WALKER B TREVOR WILLIAMS B

Marshmallowmilkshake Oct 11 2022 12:03 PM Re: 2022 Player Grades

Those are pretty spot on - but I think a little rough - not Ruf - on Tylor. He was pretty awesome filling in for deGrom during those opening months! And starting the no-hitter! Gotta give him a B.

MFS62 Oct 11 2022 01:17 PM Re: 2022 Player Grades

PETE ALONSO A FRANCISCO ALVAREZ inc. CHRIS BASSITT B BRETT BATY inc. MARK CANHA C+ CARLOS CARRASCO B- JACOB deGROM B EDWIN DIAZ A+ EDUARDO ESCOBAR B MYCHAL GIVENS C LUIS GUILLORME B+ FRANCISCO LINDOR A+ SETH LUGO B STARLING MARTE B- TREVOR MAY C JAMES McCANN F JEFF McNEIL A TYLOR MEGILL B- TYLER NAQUIN C- TOMAS NIDO B BRANDON NIMMO B+ ADAM OTTAVINO B DAVID PETERSON C+ JOELY RODRIGUEZ C- DARIN RUF F DOMINIC SMITH F DREW SMITH C- MARK VIENTOS inc. DANIEL VOGELBACH B- TAIJUAN WALKER B TREVOR WILLIAMS B Later