Master Index of Archived Threads


Frankie or Petey?

Pete "Petey" Alonso

3 votes

Frank "Frankie" Alvarez

8 votes

batmagadanleadoff Jun 12 2023 04:43 PM Edited 1 time(s), most recently on Jun 12 2023 05:28 PM

Alvarez or Alonso? Who's having the better season rate-wise or pound-for-pound? Dont give Alonso extra credit for playing more often.

Edgy MD Jun 12 2023 04:48 PM Re: Frankie or Petey?

I'd encourage you to poll-arize this thread. I'd probably go for Álvarez, if only slightly.

MFS62 Jun 12 2023 05:34 PM Re: Frankie or Petey?

Edgy MD wrote: I'd encourage you to poll-arize this thread. I'd probably go for Álvarez, if only slightly. Not quite the same as Polar Bear-izing the thread. But I went for Alvarez, too. Later

batmagadanleadoff Jun 12 2023 05:38 PM Re: Frankie or Petey?

Edgy MD wrote: I'd encourage you to poll-arize this thread. I'd probably go for Álvarez, if only slightly. Not quite the same as Polar Bear-izing the thread. Polar Bear-izing this thread would have been polarizing. I'm striving for neutrality.

metirish Jun 12 2023 07:20 PM Re: Frankie or Petey?

I voted for Alvarez, by all accounts the pitchers like what he's doing behind the plate , and he's found his way at the plate , seems to have a very level head about him too.

batmagadanleadoff Jun 12 2023 09:07 PM Re: Frankie or Petey?

I'm the lone Alonso voter. So far. Though admittedly, the two are extremely close, almost inseparable. Offensively, they're having, rate-wise, virtually identical seasons. The flaw with this poll is that youse are being asked to nail a moving target. They're so close, that one or two very good or very bad games for Alvarez can change your minds. That's why I made the poll so that youse could change your votes.

Benjamin Grimm Jun 13 2023 02:58 AM Re: Frankie or Petey?

What are Alvarez's Rookie of the Year chances? Who are his main competitors?

ashie62 Jun 13 2023 03:38 AM Re: Frankie or Petey?

Frankie is a phenomenon Corbin Carroll James Outman Jordan Walker Elly De La Cruz Matt McClain Carroll is the frontrunner. The bottom three will likely be hard charging

smg58 Jun 13 2023 06:50 AM Re: Frankie or Petey?

Their numbers are close enough that I'd go with the catcher.