Master Index of Archived Threads


Take him to... DETROIT.

Johnny Dickshot Jun 14 2006 11:38 AM

Not for nothing but there's been chatter of Cliff Floyd to the Tigers aout the Internet, perhaps inspired by speculation by a Detroit writer here. Doesn't take long for this stuff to get out of control, so we may as well monitor it. The argument is Floyd might be expendable (highly debatable in and of itself), the Tigers need lefty swinger & Dombrowski has traded for him before. Just for laughs, could the Tigers provide a match? Cameron Maybin, who I recall may have been one of the h.s. outfielders drafted in the same first round as Milledge, would be a generous haul. Kyle Sleeth is another former top pick just back from TJ surgery. I guess he's analgous to Humber. Thoughts?

Elster88 Jun 14 2006 11:39 AM Re: Take him to... DETROIT.

Johnny Dickshot wrote: The argument is Floyd might be expendable (highly debatable in and of itself) In fact, what say we start one?

Edgy DC Jun 14 2006 11:43 AM

Redundancy is a good thing to have. The Mets have redundancy in all parts of their game right now (even starting pitching, with Maine back and Pelfrey a few weeks closer than he was a few weeks ago). I'd be loathe to cancel out our redundancy in the outfield --- leaving us one injury (or Milledge getting lost) short of a real crisis, even after Nady comes back. Floyd would have to be offered for a heckuva starter. I think well-enough-alone here.

Yancy Street Gang Jun 14 2006 11:49 AM

For a while, every Mets-Tigers trade rumor involved Bobby Higginson. (Bobby's no longer playing, though, is he?)

Johnny Dickshot Jun 14 2006 11:51 AM

I think Steve Phillips is trying to get him to come to ESPN.

Yancy Street Gang Jun 14 2006 11:57 AM

ABG Jun 14 2006 12:16 PM

Verlander, Bonderman or nuttin!

Willets Point Jun 14 2006 12:31 PM

We could try to put a package together for Kenny Rogers. SC=100

Elster88 Jun 14 2006 12:44 PM

The Tiggers are one team that makes sense from their point of view. They need any and all kinds of bats, not just lefty bats.

Frayed Knot Jun 14 2006 01:05 PM

]Cameron Maybin, who I recall may have been one of the h.s. outfielders drafted in the same first round as Milledge, would be a generous haul. Maybin is a 'Milledge-ish' HS OFer (uber-athletic toolsy dude) but was drafted just last June (2 years after Lastings) and is currently in low-A ball. Seeing as how we'd be in a 'going for it this year' kinda mode, even if we were of the mind to deal Cliffy I don't think you'd see such a now-for-later type deal.

MFS62 Jun 14 2006 01:09 PM

]Seeing as how we'd be in a 'going for it this year' kinda mode, even if we were of the mind to deal Cliffy I don't think you'd see such a now-for-later type deal. I dunno. Maybe we could catch Detriot in a John Smoltz-for-Doyle Alexander kind of mood. Later

Frayed Knot Jun 14 2006 01:14 PM

Except that the Braves weren't a playoff bound team that year so they could afford a now-for-later deal. Alexander pitched well for the contending Tiggers that year - as did Larry Anderson for Boston in the infamous Jeff Bagwell deal.

sharpie Jun 14 2006 01:21 PM

I'm not remembering any midseason deala between two likely playoff-bound teams

Yancy Street Gang Jun 14 2006 01:22 PM

If Floyd's to be traded, it has to be for someone who will be more useful to the Mets than Floyd will be during the final few months of the season. For example, if we suppose that Floyd's only going to be a reserve outfielder, getting a starting pitcher or a regular second-baseman would be an upgrade worth considering. But trading him for someone who's not going to be on the postseason roster would be a mistake. It's one thing if you're 20 games out to make trades for the future, but you don't weaken your current roster as you're heading into the playoffs. Or into a pennant stretch drive.

smg58 Jun 14 2006 04:12 PM

Unless Monroe can't get healthy, I don't see any urgent need for Detroit to pick up Floyd. Yes their line-up is very righthanded, but who sits to make room for Floyd? I could see a three-team deal, but otherwise the only major leaguer I could see the Tigers parting with is Todd Jones, who wouldn't help the Mets as a setup guy. It wouldn't make sense for the Mets to get prospects, unless somebody who has a major league player the Mets could use would want the Tigers' prospects.

TheOldMole Jun 14 2006 06:09 PM

I like keeping Cliffie, partly because I hate to trade anyone, partly because the outfield picture is stronger with him a part of it, even if Lastings starts for the rest of the season. But a trade that brought back a quality second baseman would be palatable.