Master Index of Archived Threads
PIRATES OF CARRIBEAN 2
1 * - series should be scuttled and sunk to the bottom of the sea | 1 votes |
2 ** - Knightley is nice but not nearly enough | 4 votes |
3 *** - Depp is a dandy dandy, film is fine | 1 votes |
4 **** - Aye, matey, a treasure chest chapter in a super series | 1 votes |
5***** - Errol who? Amongst the best pirating pictures yet produced! | 1 votes |
Vic Sage Jul 10 2006 09:25 AM |
I didn't much care for the first one, beyond Depp's performance. But this one makes the first one seem like THE SEA HAWK.
|
Vic Sage Jul 10 2006 09:27 AM |
i had a 5 ***** rating that seems to have gotten lost in the poll posted above....
|
Vic Sage Jul 10 2006 09:29 AM |
By the way, here's an earlier thread about PIRATE MOVIES:
|
Elster88 Jul 10 2006 09:41 AM |
I really liked the first one. Mainly for two reasons....Depp's performance of course, and because I had never seen Keira Knightley before. Being introduced to her would've been enough by itself.
|
Edgy DC Jul 10 2006 10:38 AM |
Knightly would've been right to turn it down, I imagine, 50,000,000 Elvis fans be damned.
|
metirish Jul 10 2006 10:41 AM |
It pulled in $132 million over the weekend, that's a record, I didn't go and won't either as the first one was not all that good and Depps acting wore on me after a while.
|
Willets Point Jul 10 2006 10:45 AM |
The first one caught by surprise because I expected it to be bad and it was actually quite entertaining. I can't imagine that lightning in a bottle will be caught twice.
|
Elster88 Jul 10 2006 11:28 AM |
|
All of that, too, but she was talking about turning down the original.
|
Edgy DC Jul 10 2006 11:47 AM |
I understand that, and my opinion is that her first instinct (also mine) was right artistically (a spinoff of an amusement park attraction, ugh), though clearly wrong financially.
|
Elster88 Jul 21 2006 10:34 AM |
Not impressed.
|
soupcan Jul 28 2006 10:46 AM |
I gave it 2 stars.
|
Benjamin Grimm Jul 28 2006 10:53 AM |
Too long. Too slapsticky. Had its moments of fun, though. I was torn between giving it 2 and 3 but went with 3 because my son liked it, and he's more of the target audience.
|
MFS62 Jul 28 2006 10:54 AM |
|
At least (I don't think) they ever tried for TRON II. Later
|
Benjamin Grimm Jul 28 2006 10:56 AM |
I think most Disney sequels have gone directly to video or DVD.
|
MFS62 Jul 28 2006 11:05 AM |
|
And then quickly to remainder bins in video stores or to flea markets. Later
|
Centerfield Dec 29 2006 08:19 AM |
Awful.
|