Forum Home

Master Index of Archived Threads


BLC: Squeeze v. The Police

HahnSolo
Jul 23 2006 08:42 PM

Another Nail in My Heart
Pulling Mussels from the Shell
Is That Love
Tempted
Goodbye Girl
Cool for Cats
If I Didn't Love You
Black Coffee in Bed
Take Me I'm Yours
Annie Get Your Gun

All can be heard here: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000002GE7/sr=1-1/qid=1153701721/ref=pd_bbs_1/002-0612049-7179236?ie=UTF8&s=music

Edgy DC
Jul 24 2006 10:16 AM

Café Matchup: "Black Coffee in Bed" vs. "Tea in the Sahara"

soupcan
Jul 24 2006 11:24 AM
Edited 1 time(s), most recently on Jul 24 2006 12:01 PM

Murder By Numbers
Roxanne
Every Breath You Take
Can't Stand Losing You
So Lonely
Message In A Bottle
Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic
Tea in The Sahara
Canary In A Coalmine
Don't Stand So Close To Me


Edited.

Now you should all be happy.

RealityChuck
Jul 24 2006 11:42 AM

"Every Breath You Take" is listed twice.

Willets Point
Jul 24 2006 11:44 AM

Edgy DC wrote:
Café Matchup: "Black Coffee in Bed" vs. "Tea in the Sahara"


Alas...it's not to be.

RealityChuck
Jul 24 2006 01:12 PM

Very happy

Another Nail in My Heart vs. Murder By Numbers -- Squeeze
Pulling Mussels from the Shell vs. Roxanne -- Squeeze (by a hair)
Is That Love vs. Every Breath You Take -- Police (by a hair)
Tempted vs. Can't Stand Losing You -- Police
Goodbye Girl vs. So Lonely -- Squeeze
Cool for Cats vs. Message In A Bottle -- Tie
If I Didn't Love You vs. Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic -- tie
Black Coffee in Bed vs. Tea in the Sahara -- Squeeze (though normally I prefer tea).
Take Me I'm Yours vs. Canary In A Coalmine -- Squeeze
Annie Get Your Gun vs. Don't Stand So Close To Me -- Police

Two groups I like a lot, but Difford and Tillbrook are just slightly better than Sting and co. Squeeze 6-4

HahnSolo
Jul 24 2006 04:27 PM

Another Nail in My Heart vs. Murder By Numbers -- SQUEEZE
Pulling Mussels from the Shell vs. Roxanne -- TIE
Is That Love vs. Every Breath You Take -- SQUEEZE
Tempted vs. Can't Stand Losing You -- POLICE
Goodbye Girl vs. So Lonely -- SQUEEZE
Cool for Cats vs. Message In A Bottle -- POLICE
If I Didn't Love You vs. Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic -- POLICE
Black Coffee in Bed vs. Tea in the Sahara -- SQUEEZE
Take Me I'm Yours vs. Canary In A Coalmine -- SQUEEZE
Annie Get Your Gun vs. Don't Stand So Close To Me -- SQUEEZE


Squeeze 6.5, The Police 3.5

Willets Point
Jul 24 2006 04:54 PM

Another Nail in My Heart vs. Murder By Numbers -- Squeeze
Pulling Mussels from the Shell vs. Roxanne -- Squeeze
Is That Love vs. Every Breath You Take -- Tie
Tempted vs. Can't Stand Losing You -- Police
Goodbye Girl vs. So Lonely -- Police
Cool for Cats vs. Message In A Bottle -- Police
If I Didn't Love You vs. Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic -- Squeeze
Black Coffee in Bed vs. Tea in the Sahara -- Tie
Take Me I'm Yours vs. Canary In A Coalmine -- Squeeze
Annie Get Your Gun vs. Don't Stand So Close To Me --Police

Squeeze 5:5 Police

Another f'in tie. I'm useless.

Rockin' Doc
Jul 24 2006 10:09 PM

Another Nail in My Heart vs. Murder By Numbers - Police
Pulling Mussels from the Shell vs. Roxanne - Tie
Is That Love vs. Every Breath You Take - Police
Tempted vs. Can't Stand Losing You - Squeeze
Goodbye Girl vs. So Lonely - Squeeze
Cool for Cats vs. Message In A Bottle - Police
If I Didn't Love You vs. Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic - Police
Black Coffee in Bed vs. Tea in the Sahara - Squeeze
Take Me I'm Yours vs. Canary In A Coalmine - Squeeze
Annie Get Your Gun vs. Don't Stand So Close To Me - Police

Narrow victory (5.5 to 4.5) for the Police.

soupcan
Jul 24 2006 10:44 PM

Murder By Numbers -v- Another Nail in My Heart -SQUEEZE
Roxanne -v- Pulling Mussels from the Shell -TIE
Every Breath You Take -v- Is That Love -POLICE
Can't Stand Losing You -v- Tempted -TIE
So Lonely -v- Goodbye Girl -POLICE
Message In A Bottle -v- Cool for Cats-POLICE
Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic -v- If I Didn't Love You -SQUEEZE
Tea in The Sahara -v- Black Coffee in Bed -SQUEEZE
Canary In A Coalmine -v- Take Me I'm Yours -POLICE
Don't Stand So Close To Me -v- Annie Get Your Gun -POLICE

POLICE - 6 / SQUEEZE - 4

Excellent matchup.

cooby
Jul 24 2006 11:06 PM

Murder By Numbers -v- Another Nail in My Heart -Police
Roxanne -v- Pulling Mussels from the Shell -Sqeeze
Every Breath You Take -v- Is That Love -Tie, ew
Can't Stand Losing You -v- Tempted -Police
So Lonely -v- Goodbye Girl -Police
Message In A Bottle -v- Cool for Cats-Police
Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic -v- If I Didn't Love You -Police
Tea in The Sahara -v- Black Coffee in Bed - Police
Canary In A Coalmine -v- Take Me I'm Yours -Police
Don't Stand So Close To Me -v- Annie Get Your Gun -Police

8.5 Police 1.5 Squeeze


Wrapped Around Your Finger would have garnered yet another Police vote

Edgy DC
Jul 24 2006 11:26 PM
Edited 1 time(s), most recently on Jul 25 2006 09:23 AM

vs.
vs.
"Another Nail in My Heart"vs."Murder By Numbers"
"Pulling Mussels from the Shell"vs."Roxanne"
"Is That Love?"vs."Every Breath You Take"
"Tempted"vs."Can't Stand Losing You"
"Goodbye Girl"vs."So Lonely"
"Cool for Cats"vs."Message In A Bottle"
"If I Didn't Love You"vs."Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic"
"Black Coffee in Bed"vs."Tea in the Sahara"
"Take Me I'm Yours"vs."Canary In A Coalmine"
"Annie Get Your Gun"vs."Don't Stand So Close To Me"
Interesting Fact: Jules Holland is a big fan of the tv series The Prisoner, owning some of the costumes and props from the series and occasionally appears wearing the trademark brown-with-white-pipe blazer featured in the series. What the hell happened to Patrick McGoohan?
Interesting Fact: Early in the Police's career, they would get complimentary press by Sewart Copeland posing as a reporter and submittiing flattering reviews. He'd also phone in multiple requests to radio stations for a song --- "Roxanne" --- that nobody had ever heard of.

Johnny Dickshot
Jul 25 2006 12:12 AM

My kinda BLC!

"Another Nail in My Heart" vs. "Murder By Numbers"
--Squeeze. Sting oversings "Murder" -- plus it's difficult to beat the buzzy whirliness of 'Nail."

"Pulling Mussels from the Shell" vs. "Roxanne"
--Heavyweight matchup. Roxanne has a classic dramatic chorus; 'Mussels" one of the top first 5 seconds in rock history. I'm going with Squeeze on the piano solo!

"Is That Love?" vs. "Every Breath You Take"
--Neither a favorite. The Police were just whoring for a hit here, and it sounds moire like solo Stink than the Police. Is that Love is fine but just fine. Tie.

"Tempted" vs. "Can't Stand Losing You"
--Cops. I liked Tempted and all, but it wasn't really a "Squeeze" song. That is to say, it turned out to be their most popular but wasn't particularly representative of them. I like Stinger's bass and Stew's drums as usual.

"Goodbye Girl" vs. "So Lonely"
--Nice matchup of overlooked early album cuts. The "sped-up" version of GG beats the version I'm being asked to vote for, so I'll go with the Police but reluctantly. 'Driven to Tears' would have creamed it but Soupy keeps dissing it.

"Cool for Cats" vs. "Message In A Bottle"
--Police. 'Cats' was a neat little song, but 'Message" is better. Terrific drumming again from Stew, particularly as he hammers those toms going into the climatic final verse.

"If I Didn't Love You" vs. "Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic"
--Squeeze. "If I" should have been a gigantic hit. It's gorgeous, sung in harmony throughout, pretty melody, kinda funny, memorable. Where does it go wrong? You coud say many of the same things about "Magic" which was a huge hit. What's the major difference? Discuss.


"Black Coffee in Bed" vs. "Tea in the Sahara"
--Squeeze. Don't take advice on cute thematic matchups from the peanut gallery. "De Doo Doo Doo" might have slaughtered here.

"Take Me I'm Yours" vs. "Canary In A Coalmine"
--Squeeze. I'd prefer, if you were going with silly Police sons, Bombs Away.

"Annie Get Your Gun" vs. "Don't Stand So Close To Me"
--So it comes to this. "Annie" is awful nice, and an awful nice song to go out on (this was the final single before Squeeze broke up), but I'd have preferred In Quintessence or Labelled with Love or even Messed Around here. "Don't Stand" is OK too, nice work from Andy and Stew. Police!

Squeeze 5.5, Police 4.5 Great work!

A Boy Named Seo
Jul 25 2006 12:31 AM

Murder By Numbers -v- Another Nail in My Heart -POLICE
Roxanne -v- Pulling Mussels from the Shell -POLICE
Every Breath You Take -v- Is That Love -SQUEEZE
Can't Stand Losing You -v- Tempted -POLICE
So Lonely -v- Goodbye Girl -POLICE
Message In A Bottle -v- Cool for Cats-TIE
Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic -v- If I Didn't Love You -SQUEEZE
Tea in The Sahara -v- Black Coffee in Bed -POLICE
Canary In A Coalmine -v- Take Me I'm Yours -POLICE
Don't Stand So Close To Me -v- Annie Get Your Gun -SQUEEZE

POLICE 6.5 - 3.5

seawolf17
Jul 25 2006 08:25 AM

"Another Nail in My Heart" vs. "Murder By Numbers" Police
"Pulling Mussels from the Shell" vs. "Roxanne" Police
"Is That Love?" vs. "Every Breath You Take" Police
"Tempted" vs. "Can't Stand Losing You" Squeeze
"Goodbye Girl" vs. "So Lonely" Police
"Cool for Cats" vs. "Message In A Bottle" Police
"If I Didn't Love You" vs. "Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic" Police
"Black Coffee in Bed" vs. "Tea in the Sahara" Police
"Take Me I'm Yours" vs. "Canary In A Coalmine" Police
"Annie Get Your Gun" vs. "Don't Stand So Close To Me" Police

9-1 Police.

sharpie
Jul 25 2006 09:34 AM

"Another Nail in My Heart" vs. "Murder By Numbers" SQUEEZE
"Pulling Mussels from the Shell" vs. "Roxanne" POLICE
"Is That Love?" vs. "Every Breath You Take" POLICE
"Tempted" vs. "Can't Stand Losing You" SQUEEZE
"Goodbye Girl" vs. "So Lonely" POLICE
"Cool for Cats" vs. "Message In A Bottle" POLICE
"If I Didn't Love You" vs. "Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic" POLICE
"Black Coffee in Bed" vs. "Tea in the Sahara" tie
"Take Me I'm Yours" vs. "Canary In A Coalmine" POLICE
"Annie Get Your Gun" vs. "Don't Stand So Close To Me" POLICE

POLICE 7.5
SQUEEZE 2.5

TransMonk
Jul 25 2006 11:15 AM

"Another Nail in My Heart" vs. "Murder By Numbers"
"Pulling Mussels from the Shell" vs. "Roxanne"
"Is That Love?" vs. "Every Breath You Take"
"Tempted" vs. "Can't Stand Losing You"
"Goodbye Girl" vs. "So Lonely"
"Cool for Cats" vs. "Message In A Bottle"
"If I Didn't Love You" vs. "Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic"
"Black Coffee in Bed" vs. "Tea in the Sahara"
"Take Me I'm Yours" vs. "Canary In A Coalmine"
"Annie Get Your Gun" vs. "Don't Stand So Close To Me"

The Police win 8-2
over Squeeze.

Edgy DC
Jul 25 2006 11:19 AM

This is the all-Brimstone and Treacle matchup.

Johnny Dickshot
Jul 25 2006 11:26 AM

This is out and out Police brutality.

HahnSolo
Jul 26 2006 05:05 PM

After five voters, Squeezed was in position for a minor upset, holding a 26-24 lead. But in a most arresting development, the Police poured it on in the second half to take a comfortable 68-42 win.