Forum Home

Master Index of Archived Threads


Battered Polo Grounds stairway

Benjamin Grimm
Jul 07 2008 08:48 AM

I thought this was interesting. It was on today's editorial page in the News, accompanied by a photo of Willie Mays making that 1954 World Series catch off the bat of Vic Wertz.

N.Y. Daily News editorial page wrote:


Let's go, teams!

The only remains of the storied Polo Grounds is a battered stairway that extends from Coogan's Bluff to lower ground.

Nowhere was more sports history made by more New York teams than in the Polo Grounds - and no place has been more forgotten. Only a plaque in a housing project marks the spot where the Giants, Yankees and Mets of baseball took a field that was also shared with the football Giants and Jets.

And all that remains of the storied stadium complex at 155th St. and Eighth Ave. is a battered stairway that extends from Coogan's Bluff to lower ground. Its 80 concrete steps were a 1913 gift to the city from the owner of the baseball Giants. Embedded in a landing, steel letters read:

"THE JOHN T. BRUSH STAIRWAY PRESENTED BY THE NEW YORK GIANTS'."

In their time, the steps were a prime route for walking from the neighborhood to the ballpark. Today, they are broken, lined by rusted handrails and closed off behind fencing that bears "No trespassing" signs.

And that's wrong. The stairs could be a valuable convenience that connects two communities, as well as the upper and lower portions of Highbridge Park. They could also commemorate the many agonies and ecstasies of the Polo Grounds.

New York will this year mark the closure of Yankee Stadium and the coming of a Mets arena designed to recall Brooklyn's Ebbets Field. Let us, too, refurbish the Polo Grounds steps.

There will be a cost, but one that would surely be affordable through the combined generosity of the five teams that shared the Polo Grounds over the decades.

The baseball Giants called the stadium home from 1890 to 1957, when the team left for San Francisco. It's where Bobby Thomson hit the shot heard 'round the world off the Dodgers' Ralph Branca. It's where Willie Mays made "The Catch" (photo) in the '54 World Series. All told, the Giants won 15 pennants and five Series at the Polo Grounds - and haven't been champs since they left.

The Yankees played in the Polo Grounds before moving to the Bronx. Babe Ruth made his New York debut there; the Yanks won their first pennant there, and they faced off there in 1921 against the Giants in a Series that was the first played on a single field and the first to be broadcast by radio.

The stadium was also birthplace to the Super Bowl champ Giants, who won three NFL titles in their 30-year residency, most famously beating the Bears in the 1934 Sneakers Game - so named because the Giants' players wore rubber-soled shoes on the frozen turf.

The Jets, then called the Titans, arrived at the Polo Grounds in 1960 as part of the upstart American Football League. And, in 1962, National League hardball returned with the Amazin'ly bumbling pre-Shea Mets.

Fans of all five teams used the staircase. It is fondly remembered by New Yorkers who are, well, old-timers. New generations should have the pleasure, particularly fans of Highbridge Park, which runs north and south on two levels of upper Manhattan's terrain.

Parks Commissioner Adrian Benepe says he would love to restore the Polo Grounds stairs to public use but lacks the money to get the job done. Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer has secured a down payment of $400,000. What's needed now is a true team effort.


They have $400,000? How much more do you need to fix a staircase?

It didn't cost that much to build my entire house!

sharpie
Jul 07 2008 09:10 AM

Spoke with a guy last week who grew up near the Polo Grounds. Too young for the Giants but snuck into a bunch of Mets games as a 10 year old, said cops looked the other way when neighborhood kids snuck in the bleachers. Told me a story about how one day he was hanging around while a game was in progress when a guy in a suit was leaving the park and asked him if he wanted in. The kid and his friend said sure so the guy took out his ticket stubs, initialed them and said "show these to the guys at the gate and they'll let you in." They did and the kids had great seats for once in their lives but never found out who the ticket-stub-initialing guy was.

Unfortunately, he (the guy I was talking to) no longer follows baseball.

soupcan
Jul 07 2008 09:33 AM

Thanks Grimmy, I love stuff like this. Never knew about it.

Here's a New York Times article from February.

With pictures!

February 19, 2008

A Stairway to Sports History From the Polo Grounds

By Timothy Williams


Steps that lead nowhere today once offered a clear, yet distant, view of games at the Polo Grounds.
(Photo: Geoffrey Croft/New York City Park Advocates)



A plaque at the bottom of the staircase honoring the New York Giants’ baseball team owner, John T. Brush,
was dedicated in July 1913, the year after his death. (Photo: Geoffrey Croft/New York City Park Advocates)



With the winter baseball news dominated by tales of steroids and human growth hormone drugs, hearings and investigations, and apologies and denials, a look back at a more innocent time in baseball may be in order this week, when position players are joining pitchers and catchers at training camp in Florida and Arizona.

The Polo Grounds, the northern Manhattan home of the New York Giants baseball team, has long been the site of a rather imposing public housing complex called the Polo Grounds Towers — four 30-story skyscrapers with 1,616 units.

Few clues remain about the glorious things that happened when the Polo Grounds was a sports stadium in Washington Heights — Willie Mays, the birth of the Mets, the New York Cubans, the New York football Giants, and Floyd Patterson vs. Ingemar Johansson, among them.

But one relic remains, not as the result of historic preservation, but by accident.

That relic is a staircase built down Coogan’s Bluff, the hill that overlooked the stadium, which is roughly where Edgecombe Avenue runs today. The staircase once led to a ticket booth, and was built by the owner of the Giants at the time.

Coogan’s Bluff had long been a sort of Tightwad Hill for local fans, a place where those unwilling or unable to pay the stadium’s entrance fee had a clear, if distant, view of the proceedings at no charge.

If nothing else, the Giants may have hoped a new stairway would prompt a few fans to buy tickets.

Today, the stairway leads nowhere, except for an overgrown stretch of Highbridge Park. Many, if not most, of its steps are missing; its guard rails rusting and falling apart; and some sections have disappeared into the underbrush, making an attempt to walk down them highly inadvisable.
But at a landing partway down is an inscription; like the staircase, it has been slowly disintegrating over the decades. Its letters are still clear despite rain, snow and heat, and it reads: “The John T. Brush Stairway Presented by the New York Giants.”

A New York Times article from July 9, 1913, retrieved by the Parks Department, says that on that day the baseball club would be formally presenting the “John T. Brush Stairway” to the city. The Giants’ team president, H. N. Hempstead, was to present the gift to the city parks commissioner, Charles B. Stover, to honor Mr. Brush, the Giants owner who had died in 1912.

But city officials say the long-forgotten inscription and staircase, which might be the last vestiges of the old ballpark, could be in for a reprieve.
As part of the Bloomberg administration’s PlaNYC2030 program, Highbridge Park is set for an overhaul, including the historic, and long-closed High Bridge — as well as the staircase.

The cost of repairing the staircase is about $1.2 million, according to city officials. So far, the city has only $400,000 to pay for it — all of it from the office of the Manhattan borough president, Scott M. Stringer.
Mr. Stringer, 47, who grew up in Washington Heights, near the stadium, said he never saw a game there. Indeed, Mr. Stringer said when someone mentions the Polo Grounds to him, his mind does not turn to images of Babe Ruth, Hank Aaron or Sugar Ray Robinson.

“When I think of the Polo Grounds, I think of the housing development and the people who live there,” he said.

As for the staircase, Mr. Stringer said he had no idea it existed until the Parks Department asked him to help finance its restoration. “It was sort of left to us,” he said. “But we’ll make sure the inscription is restored.”
(For the record, Mr. Stringer said he follows both the Mets and Yankees, but at heart, is a Jets fan.)

Adrian Benepe, the commissioner of the Department of Parks and Recreation, said the park “has undergone a significant rebirth in the last 10 years with more than $10 million worth of improvements completed or in progress” and that an additional $75 million in projects were already underway or planned. “Even with all that, there’s still more work we need to do on this historic park, including finding some additional funding for the Brush Stairway renovation,” he said.

G-Fafif
Jul 07 2008 10:49 AM

One day in 2000 I decided after years of thinking it would be neat to actually get up and go to the Polo Grounds apartments and take a look around. I open the News on the train and I find [url=http://www.nydailynews.com/archives/sports/2000/08/10/2000-08-10_a_stairway_to_heaven_once__g.html]this article[/url] by Vic Ziegel, published that very morning:

]A STAIRWAY TO HEAVEN ONCE, GIANTS WALKED THERE
BY VIC ZIEGEL
Thursday, August 10th 2000, 2:13AM

The staircase begins on 158th St. and Edgecombe Ave., several hundred feet from where Bobby Thomson was standing, a bat in his hands, Oct. 3, 1951. The staircase was a gift, 87 years ago, from a baseball team to the City of New York. That same team, long gone, needs the gift restored.

ONE OF THE WORST days in my life - I know you've been wondering - was a baseball afternoon in 1957 when it became indisputably clear that the Giants, the only team I would ever love, were leaving the Polo Grounds and New York.

Winters were for the Knicks and Rangers. The football Giants were more than a passing fancy. But I rooted harder for snow.

Baseball was the game and the Giants were my team. Until they left, and did the small quiet thing known as breaking hearts. It hurt then and - I made this discovery when I visited the Hall of Fame a few summers ago - it still hurts.

The New York Giants have disappeared. Which may not surprise anyone who has gotten off the subway at 155th St. and 8th Ave. Father Knickerbocker now pitches beer in that great saloon in the sky. Willard Marshall never calls. Sal Yvars never writes. The Giants are another lost tribe.

When ESPN Classic recalls the great sports rivalries, they say Giants and Dodgers and deliver the obligatory shot of a crowded Ebbets Field. Do they show the Polo Grounds? Do you have to ask?

OK, the team in Brooklyn ran out, too, and a wrecking ball crunched Ebbets Field. (Aw, rough.) And you probably don't think you need grainy film footage to remember what the Polo Grounds looked like - 279 feet to the wall in left, 257 to right, 483 to center. It's etched in your memory, but cleaner. Not as much pigeon glop dropping from the rafters.
Memory, it turns out, is a slap in the face.

My visit to Cooperstown was terrific until I hit the gift shop. There was plenty of Yankees' stuff. Tons of it. If you absolutely had to buy one of everything Yankee you would still be there, your credit card melting.

And if Dodger stuff was something you wanted to load up on, that wouldn't have been a problem. Roger Kahn made sure of that. F. Scott Fitzgerald did it for East Egg and Kahn's "Boys of Summer" did it for Flatbush Ave. People who weren't alive when the Dodgers were choking in October are walking the streets of this city wearing the words "Brooklyn Dodgers."

The Mayor thinks the West Side Highway is now Joe DiMaggio Highway and the Interboro Parkway has been renamed Jackie Robinson. There's a Gil Hodges Bridge out there. Fine. And enough already.

There is nothing in use today to remind anybody that the Giants, who won 15 National League pennants and five World Series, spent every baseball year until 1957 in New York. Not even the staircase, which was their gift to the city on July 10, 1913. And bears the inscription, still clearly visible on one landing, "The John T. Brush Stairway, presented by the New York Giants." (Brush was the team's president.)

A chain fence discourages anybody from walking the 78 steps from Edgecombe to the road that runs into the Harlem River Drive. Many of the steps are cracked. There are gaping holes on the landings. Three street lamps, from that long-ago time, are very close to stumps. The weeds are winning.

Across the street, another staircase takes you down to the Polo Grounds Houses, the high-rise complex that went up when the ballpark was torn down in 1964 (the same wrecking ball that did the job on Ebbets Field).

I walked the Polo Grounds neighborhood earlier this week with Larry Ritter, who wrote the book "Lost Ballparks," and Don Majeski, a boxing guy who has a feel for old New York sports sites. He told me about the staircase.

At 2991-2999 8th Ave., inside the Polo Grounds Houses, we saw the plaque that reads "Polo Grounds, Approximate Location of Home Plate, Home of the New York Giants, National Baseball League, 1890-1957, World Champions 1904. 1905. 1921. 1922. 1933. 1954. The Giants Shared the Field with the New York Yankees, 1913-1922. The New York Mets Played Here 1962-63."

So I stood there, the approximate location, and imagined I was Bobby Thomson. Sixty feet, six inches away, near a playground, Ralph Branca was on the mound.

The five most important words in Giants history - and maybe the history of the world, to that time - had been relayed from Clyde Sukeforth, the bullpen coach, to Dodgers manager Charley Dressen. "Erskine just bounced his curveball," the coach said.

And because of that message, Dressen brings in Branca to face Thomson. If he stays with Don Newcombe, or uses Carl Erskine, maybe Thomson doesn't hit Branca's second pitch for the home run that wins a pennant.
So long ago.

THE PLAQUE IS COVERED with scratch marks, bubble gum residue. It ain't glorious. Does the city have a few bucks to spend to shine it up? Can something be done for the staircase? Forget Mr. Brush. John McGraw, Christy Mathewson, Carl Hubbell, Mel Ott, Willie Mays. One of them deserves to be a bridge, a highway, a something. Memory isn't enough.


I saw the plaque (not the easiest find) but didn't get to the stairs, which it continues to blow my mind still exist with the inscription still visible. It seemed like enough of an accomplishment to stand where Thomson stood with Coogan's Bluff at my back.

I've met several old NY Giants fans who tell great stories about sneaking in to the Polo Grounds either with ushers looking the other way or ushers not being fast enough to keep up with them. Trying to imagine that happening today...or ever again.